Retention of two storey side/rear and single storey rear extensions and front porch
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 November 2025
by N Bromley BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28 November 2025
Appeal A Ref: APP/G4620/D/25/3371402
48 Parsons Hill, Oldbury, Sandwell B68 9BS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Arshed Saddique against the decision of Sandwell Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is DC/25/70619.
• The development proposed is retention of 2 storey side, rear and single storey rear extension.
Appeal B Ref: APP/G4620/D/25/3370856
50 Parsons Hill, Oldbury, Sandwell B68 9BS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Pamela Brazier against the decision of Sandwell Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is DC/25/70456.
• The development proposed is retention of two storey side/rear and single storey rear extensions and
front porch.
Decision
Appeal A
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal B
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
3. The two appeals in the banner heading above relate to a pair of semi-detached
dwellings. The description of development for both appeals is broadly the same
and they raise the same issues. Therefore, although they are two separate
appeals, I have considered both appeals in a single decision letter to avoid
repetition. However, I have considered each development on its individual merits.
4. For Appeal B, I have used the description of development taken from the Council’s
decision notice and the appeal form, as opposed to the application form, as it more
accurately describes that for which permission is sought. I have also excluded
superfluous information that is not an act of development.
5. I have assessed each appeal scheme based on the plans before me, but I
observed at the time of the site visit that the external works of each development
Appeal Decisions APP/G4620/D/25/3371402 and APP/G4620/D/25/3370856
2
were largely complete. Therefore, each development is retrospective. I have dealt
with each appeal on that basis.
6. I note that an Enforcement Notice for each property has been served by the
Council, and an appeal has been lodged against each. However, it is not within my
remit to comment upon the likely outcome of the Enforcement Notice appeals.
Main Issue
7. The main issue in both Appeal A and B is the effect of the development on the
character and appearance of the host property and the area.
Reasons
8. 48 and 50 Parsons Hill are a pair of two-storey, semi-detached dwellings, set
within a row of residential properties that front the road. The two properties each
have a frontage parking area, and a sizeable rear garden.
9. The street scene is characterised by modest, two storey semi-detached houses
that extend along both sides of the road. There are two distinct house types along
the road, largely of a similar scale, with a consistent front building line, and set
within uniform plots. Some of the properties have single storey side extensions but
equally many others preserve a small gap to the side, and the houses largely
retain their original appearance. As such, there is uniformity along the road.
10. The side extension to 48 Parsons Hill, with a two-storey height, built up to the side
boundary and with no set back from the front elevation, or break in the ridgeline,
overwhelms the host property. Indeed, its scale, form and appearance is not
subordinate to the design of the original dwelling. Furthermore, the side extension
is slightly set forward which portrays an appearance of a continuous front building
line. In combination with a minimal separation to the side, the extension appears
cramped and inharmonious, and the house is significantly at odds with the modest
scale and design of neighbouring properties. As such, the appearance of the
extension is incongruous.
11. In addition, with no set back or break in the ridgeline, and built up to the side
boundary, the two-storey side extension results in an unacceptable terracing
effect, and the house sits uncomfortably within the more uniform semi-detached
dwellings along the road.
12. Likewise, and for similar reasons to those set out for Appeal A, with no set back or
break in the ridgeline, the two-storey side extension to 50 Parsons Hill (No 50),
which is built up to the side boundary and with a seamless front building line at first
floor, is not a subservient extension. Instead, it is a dominant extension that is
harmful to the character of the original dwelling.
13. Built up close to the side boundary, the side extension to No 50 also significantly
reduces the gap between the neighbouring property. In combination with the lack
of a set back or break in the ridgeline, the extension contributes to an
unacceptable terracing effect within the street scene. It therefore represents an
incongruous extension to the host dwelling and is also discordant within the area.
14. Even if I had considered the cumulative harm of the two extensions together, I
would have found that the symmetrical appearance of the two extensions, with an
unacceptable form, size and appearance, does not represent good design.
Appeal Decisions APP/G4620/D/25/3371402 and APP/G4620/D/25/3370856
3
15. Both properties benefit from extant planning permissions and while I have
determined each appeal on its own merits, I have considered the claimed fallback
position for both Appeal A and Appeal B in my planning balance.
16. My attention has been drawn to other examples of residential extensions in the
area, which I observed during my site visit. The examples included first floor and
two storey side extensions to both detached and semi-detached dwellings.
However, the notable difference between the large majority of the examples and
the appeal schemes is that many of the extensions to semi-detached properties
have been set back from the front elevation of the original dwelling, which also
achieves a natural break in the ridgeline. The two appeal schemes do not include
such design features.
17. There is no question that two storey side extensions could be acceptable in
principle in this area, as illustrated by the extant planning permissions for two
storey side extensions at each property. Inevitably, it is the detail and specific
context of any development which determines whether it is acceptable in practice.
Having considered the size, location and design of the two appeal schemes, and
the effect on the character and appearance of each host property and this area, for
the reasons given, I consider that there is unacceptable harm. Given this, the other
highlighted examples do not add weight in favour of each development.
Accordingly, as I am required to do, I have determined each case before me on its
own merits.
18. For the reasons outlined above, I conclude that the developments subject of both
Appeal A and Appeal B harm the character and appearance of each host property
and the area. Therefore, the developments are contrary to Policies HOU2, CSP4
and ENV3 of the Black Country Core Strategy (2011), and Policy SAD EOS9 of
the Site Allocations and Delivery Development Plan Document (2012). These
together and amongst other things seek to ensure that development is of a high-
quality design and compatible with their surroundings.
Other Matters
19. Appeal A benefits from an extant planning permission1 for proposed single and two
storey side and rear extensions. Likewise, Appeal B benefits from two previous,
extant planning permissions2 for proposed two / single storey side / rear
extensions with new front porch and alterations to front canopy. A copy of the
approved plans for each of the extant planning permissions has been submitted.
20. In the event that each appeal is dismissed, I consider that there is a greater than
theoretical possibility that the works approved under the extant permissions might
take place. Accordingly, this represents a fallback position and is a significant
material consideration.
21. The difference between the extant planning permissions and the developments
subject of both Appeal A and Appeal B is that the proposed extensions previously
permitted have been set back at first floor on the front elevation of each property,
which also results in an extension with a lower ridge height than that of each main
dwelling. The set back and lower ridge height of each proposed extension would
be noticeable. As a result, the extant planning permissions for each property
1 Council reference: DC/23/67996
2 Council reference: DC/23/68291 and DC/24/69086
Appeal Decisions APP/G4620/D/25/3371402 and APP/G4620/D/25/3370856
4
achieve a subordinate and acceptable design that would also avoid an
unacceptable terracing effect. Consequently, the fallback position for both Appeal
A and Appeal B would have a markedly lesser effect on the character and
appearance of each host property and the area than the two appeal schemes. The
fallback position for both Appeal A and Appeal B would therefore be preferable
and consequently receives limited weight in the determination of each appeal.
22. The appellant for each appeal suggests that the extensions provide for meaningful
first floor accommodation that allows for the proper functioning of the bedrooms
including the coordinated distribution of furniture. Nonetheless, the weight attached
to these matters, including the fallback position and the acceptability of other
elements of each scheme, particularly those at the rear, would not outweigh the
harm caused by the impact that both Appeal A and Appeal B have on the
character and appearance of each host property and the area.
Conclusion
23. For the reasons given above, I conclude that Appeal A and Appeal B should be
dismissed.
N Bromley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.