Construction of a detached outbuilding comprised of a garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 August 2025
by M Clowes BA (Hons) MCD PG CERT (Arch Con) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 August 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/25/3367455
The Mistle, Firth House Barn, Scammonden Road, Barkisland, Sowerby Bridge
HX4 0EL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr K Johnson against the decision of Calderdale Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is 24/01148/HSE.
• The development proposed is the construction of a detached outbuilding comprised of a garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The spelling of the property name in the banner heading above is taken from the
name plaque viewed within the boundary walling I observed during my visit. The
description of development is taken from the planning application form with the
exception of the references to retrospective and a previous application, neither of
which are acts of development.
3. A detached garage with a dual pitched roof has been constructed at the appeal
site without planning permission1. It differs in form and height to the garage that is
now proposed. Given that the existing building is unauthorised and the description
of development refers to the construction of a new building, I have considered the
appeal on this basis.
Main Issues
4. The main issues of this appeal are;
i) Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
and development plan policies;
ii) The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area; and
iii) Whether any harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm,
would be clearly outweighed by other considerations so as to amount to the
very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
Inappropriate Development
1As explained within the appellant’s statement of case and with reference to the planning history of the site as set out in the
Council’s officer report.
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/25/3367455
2
5. Policy GB1 of the Calderdale Local Plan (CLP) 2023, gives priority to the
protection of the Green Belt, stating that the construction of new buildings should
be regarded as inappropriate in the Green Belt. It reiterates the closed list of
exceptions for new buildings set out within the Framework.
6. The exception at I(c) of Policy GB1 of the CLP and paragraph 154(c) of the
Framework allow the extension or alteration of a building providing that it does not
result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
In this instance the original building is the section of barn that formed the separate
planning unit of The Mistle. Neither the Framework nor Policy GB1 provide a
definition of what would constitute a ‘disproportionate addition.’ It is therefore a
matter of planning judgement.
7. The garage building would be located within the curtilage of dwelling2. It would be
used for the parking of vehicles and other storage purposes in connection with the
occupation of the dwelling. In this regard, despite being detached, the garage
would amount to a normal domestic adjunct.
8. The Council is clear that the existing dwelling has been extended on a number of
occasions3 which has resulted in a total increase in volume of 65% over and above
the original. I was able to observe these extensions during my site visit which were
distinguishable by the change in colour to the stonework and pointing.
9. The Council advises that the proposed garage would result in a cumulative
increase of 96% when added to the volume of the existing extensions. The
appellant has not provided me with his own calculations, nor sought to dispute the
Council’s position regarding the volume increase. No information has therefore
been presented, that would lead me to disagree with these figures.
10. Visually the extensions have already significantly increased the size of the original
dwelling. Even with a flat roof, the proposed garage would have a large size and
scale, such that I am not satisfied that the original dwelling would in visual terms,
remain the dominant element within the appeal site. It is my view that the resultant
cumulative increase in volume and size would amount to disproportionate
additions to the original dwelling.
11. The exception specified in paragraph 154c) of the Framework makes no mention
of Green Belt openness, unlike other Green Belt exceptions. Openness is not
therefore relevant, when determining whether the proposal would amount to a
disproportionate addition and I am not required to consider this further.
12. For the reasons given, the proposal would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt which is, by definition harmful, and should not be approved except in
very special circumstances. It would therefore conflict with Policy GB1 of the CLP
and paragraph 154(c) of the Framework as set out above.
Character and Appearance
13. The appeal site comprises a dwelling formed through the subdivision and
conversion of a traditional former agricultural barn. The Council has advised that
the appeal site lies within a special landscape area (SLA) although I have not been
referred to a specific one, nor a landscape character assessment. It seems to me
from my site visit that the character of the landscape surrounding the appeal site is
2 As confirmed through the granting of a lawful development certificate reference 21/00408/191.
3 With reference to planning application references 18/00510/HSE for a first-floor side extension and 22/00948/HSE for a single
storey side extension (retrospective).
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/25/3367455
3
formed predominantly by the pattern of upland pastures enclosed by drystone
walls with occasional bands of woodland planting. Buildings typically include
scattered farmsteads or isolated dwellings with a strong vernacular of local natural
stone and dual-pitched slate roofs.
14. The appeal property has been altered and extended such that its former
agricultural character has been somewhat diminished. Nonetheless, as part of a
group of buildings that make up a former traditional farm steading in a
predominantly rural location, it contributes positively to the character and
appearance of the area.
15. The proposed garage would be single storey and of stone construction with a flat
roof. I understand that the design of the building has evolved in an attempt to
address the Council’s concerns regarding size and volume. Nonetheless, the
limited height and flat roof design combined with the extensive width of the garage
and wide garage door would result in a building with an unusually squat
appearance and large scale. As such, the form of the garage would contrast with
and detract from the local vernacular architecture where dual-pitched roofs
predominate.
16. As the proposed garage would face the lane that carries a public right of way, the
garage would be highly visible from a public vantage point, albeit at close quarters
due to the alignment of the route and the presence of mature landscaping along it.
Notwithstanding its single storey height and lack of wider visibility, the form of the
proposed garage would appear inharmonious in such views. In this regard, the
proposal would not make a positive contribution to the quality and distinctiveness
of the existing environment or wider landscape.
17. Whilst the design of the proposed garage would be incongruous in its immediate
context, it could in no way be considered to be dominant and prominent in the
landscape. Given the screening afforded by nearby planting, the proposal would
not have an overbearing influence on the landscape as a whole.
18. I find that the proposal would harm the character and appearance of the area. It
would conflict with Policies BT1 and GN4 of the CLP which amongst other things,
require new development to be of a high quality that respects or enhances the
character and appearance of existing buildings and surroundings, including its
location within a special landscape area.
Other Considerations
19. Paragraph 153 of the Framework states that very special circumstances will not
exist unless the potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness,
and any other harm resulting from the proposal, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations.
20. The appellant contends that the proposed garage is required for the secure
storage of his vehicles. Whilst understanding this concern, I have not been
presented with any substantive evidence that crime is a significant problem in the
area, such that the fear of it could be considered as a material consideration.
Neither has it been demonstrated to me that other crime prevention measures
could not be implemented. This attracts limited weight.
21. I am aware that the appellant has applied for various retrospective planning
permissions for a garage in this location since 2022 but the specific details of
those refusals are not before me. Be that as it may, and whilst understanding the
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/25/3367455
4
stressful implications of the refusals, it does not justify permitting inappropriate
development in the Green Belt. Whether any alternative proposal could be
considered acceptable would be a matter for the Council.
22. The acceptability of the scheme in respect of the effect on the living conditions of
the host occupiers and neighbouring residents with regard to the provision of
garden space and outlook respectively, are neutral matters that weigh neither for,
nor against, the proposal.
Green Belt Balance and Conclusion
23. The proposal would amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt which
is, by definition, harmful and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. The Framework establishes that substantial weight should be
given to any Green Belt harm. Very special circumstances will not exist unless
harm to the Green Belt is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
24. In light of the substantial weight to be given to Green Belt harm, combined with the
other identified harm to the character and appearance of the area, and the limited
weight to be attached to other considerations, the harm would not be clearly
outweighed. The very special circumstances necessary to justify the proposal do
not exist. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
M Clowes
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.