Erection of a two storey front gable extension, loft extension with front and rear dormer windows, front rooflights, timber bin shed to front and Juliette Balconies to the rear
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 July 2025 by F Bradford BA (Hons) MRTPI
Decision by Martin Seaton BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 January 2026
Appeal Ref: APP/P4605/D/25/3365612
34 Gilmorton Close, Harborne, Birmingham, B17 8QR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr A Singh against the decision of Birmingham City Council.
• The application reference is 2024/06272/PA.
• The development proposed is the erection of a two storey front gable extension, loft extension with
front and rear dormer windows, front rooflights, timber bin shed to front and Juliette Balconies to the
rear.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by a representative of the Inspector whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard before
deciding the appeal.
Main Issue
3. The main issue with the proposed development is its effect on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and wider area.
Reasons for the Recommendation
4. The appeal site comprises a single storey detached dwelling situated to the far end
of the cul-de-sac which is generally uniform in terms of its scale and design to 35
Gilmorton Close. The close itself is mixed in terms of the design of dwellings
however there is general visual consistency in terms of scale. It is this combination
of the general uniformity of the close with pockets of design uniformity which
contributes positively to the character and appearance of the area.
5. The proposed rear dormer would represent a substantial addition to the roof slope
of the appeal dwelling. The dormer would be located on the rear roof slope of the
appeal dwelling, and would be set down from the roof ridge, as well as being set
back from the eaves and in from the sides of the roof slope. It would not detract
from the architectural appearance of the dwelling in itself by way of being dominant
and would not be readily visible from within the public streetscape of Gilmorton
Close.
6. The detailed design of the dormer is a departure from guidance contained within
the Birmingham Design Guide Healthy Living and Working Places City Manual
(2022). However, I am mindful that this guidance, and I do find that it would accord
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/25/3365612
2
with the overarching policy objectives of the development plan in this instance.
Policy PG3 (Place making) of the Birmingham Development Plan 2017 (BDP), aims
to ensure development reinforces and creates a positive sense of place and
distinctiveness with design that responds to the site conditions and local area
context. Given that the positive sense of place to Gilmorton Close is afforded
through the uniformity from the public realm, any effects arising from the rear
dormer in terms of its appearance to the host dwelling, would be limited to the
private occupants of the appeal dwelling and neighbouring properties, when viewed
from their rear gardens.
7. Gilmorton Close is characterised by a generally consistent building scale, forming a
coherent streetscape. The appeal dwelling adopts this uniformity of design and
form with the adjacent property at No. 35 and also reflects the general proportions
of Nos. 33 and 32, which contributes to the sense of uniformity of the street. Whilst
several properties have undergone extension and alteration, and some later
dwellings have departed from the generally established uniformity in terms of
design, the overall sense of uniformity nevertheless prevails within the streetscene,
contributing positively to the character and appearance of the area.
8. The forward extension would be a prominent feature within the streetscene and
would create an uncharacteristic vertical design emphasis to the appeal dwelling.
This effect is worsened by the changes to the roof, as the new front ridge would be
lowered, making the front extension appear taller given that it would disrupt the
existing proportions. Whilst it may project only one metre above the existing
arrangement, because of the changes to the proportions of the front elevation, it
would appear to be significantly greater.
9. The change in proportion of the front elevation and the overall reduction in height of
the host dwelling which would arise from the changes to the roof, would materially
alter the appearance of the scale and bulk of the dwelling, which would be at odds
with that prevailing within the streetscape, and with specific regard to No.32, 33,
and 35, and the older dwellings within cul-de-sac.
10. Furthermore, by virtue of its siting within the otherwise unaltered roof, the front
dormer would appear as a prominent and incongruous feature to the host dwelling.
This incongruity would extend to the wider streetscape, worsened by the notable
absence of front dormers within Gilmorton Close. The proposed front dormer would
be a visually prominent addition, detracting from the established character and
appearance of the host dwelling and wider streetscape.
11. The proposed bin store would be located to the front elevation and would be
constructed of timber. It would be of a design typical to bin stores sited within a
general suburban context. By virtue of its limited scale, I am satisfied that it would
be an addition to the host dwelling that would neither harm the character and
appearance of the host dwelling, nor Gilmorton Close.
12. For the reasons above, I conclude that the proposed development would result in
harm to the character and appearance of the appeal dwelling and streetscape. I
therefore find conflict with the local development plan with particular regard to
policy PG3 of the BDP 2017, which among other things, aims to ensure that new
development contributes to a strong sense of place and responds to site conditions
and the local area context.
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/25/3365612
3
13. The council has referenced Policy DM2 of the Development Management in
Birmingham Development Plan Document 2012 within their reason for refusal,
stating harm to character and appearance is found against this policy. However,
DM2 primarily addresses impacts to amenity (by way of living and working
conditions), and not character and appearance. Whilst I have given the policy
extremely limited weight in assessing character and appearance, the proposed
development nevertheless conflicts with other policies contained within the local
development plan. As such, the council’s reference to this policy does not alter my
recommendation.
Other Matters
14. The appellant has referred me to various other developments within the vicinity of
the appeal site. Although I note that the extensions approved at No. 27 Gilmorton
Close have not been constructed, the overall approved development involved
extensions of a scale that were similar to the existing character and appearance of
the host dwelling by virtue of their design and scale, rather than those proposed by
this appeal.
15. Turning to No. 7 Gilmorton Close, the development in this case was for a new
dwelling rather than the alteration of an existing dwelling. Furthermore, the context
within which the appeal dwelling is sited differs significantly with No. 7 located in a
position bordered on either side by rear gardens rather than the design uniformity
of similar development in the case of the appeal scheme. The circumstances are
not therefore directly comparable.
16. Whilst I recognise that the features of No. 30 Gilmorton Close are reflective of the
proposed development, no evidence has been provided that demonstrates the
extents of the extension from the original dwelling and I am therefore unable to
draw a direct comparison to the appeal scheme. As such, I attach limited weight to
this.
17. I acknowledge with the motivation of the appellant to create additional living space.
However, this would be a private benefit of the proposed development limited to the
occupiers of the appeal dwelling. Whilst some economic benefit would arise
through employment opportunities during the construction phase, the scale of the
proposed development would mean that any benefits would be limited.
18. Whilst I acknowledge no objections have been made to the scheme, the proposed
development represents a permanent alteration to the appeal dwelling on which
harm and subsequent conflict with the development plan has been found.
Conclusion and Recommendation
19. I do not find that the benefits of the proposed development would attract greater
weight than the permanent harm as identified above to which I attach significant
weight in this recommendation.
20. Therefore, for the reasons given above and having had regard to all other matters
raised, I recommend that the appeal should be dismissed.
Finlay Bradford
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/25/3365612
4
Inspector’s Decision
21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and my representative’s report and on
that basis the appeal is dismissed.
Martin Seaton
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.