Boundary fencing and foundation/base for replacement outbuilding
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Rural Impact
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 July 2025
by S Leonard BA (Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 August 2025.
Appeal Ref: APP/D1265/D/25/3361945
Gilleve, Wareham Road, Corfe Mullen, Dorset BH21 3RU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Burnard against the decision of Dorset Council.
• The application Ref is P/HOU/2024/03382.
• The development is the erection of boundary fencing and foundation/base for replacement
outbuilding.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The planning application was submitted retrospectively, and on my site visit I saw
that boundary fencing and a foundation/base for a future building have been
carried out. The appellants have drawn my attention to an error in respect of the
planning application in that the height of the fencing as erected, at 2.3m, is lower
than the height of 3m as stated on the application drawing Ref SP02-542-YPP 1.
3. The appellants have not submitted a revised plan to replace the above drawing.
Notwithstanding the fencing that has been erected, the decision notice specifically
confirms which drawings were considered by the Council in reaching the decision.
These include the aforesaid drawing. Moreover, the officer report refers to the 3m
height stated on this drawing.
4. The planning appeals procedural guidance1 advises that the appeal process
should not be used to evolve a scheme and there are no provisions within the
Rules for amendments to be submitted. It is important that what is considered by
the Inspector at appeal is essentially the same scheme that was considered by the
local planning authority and by interested parties at the application stage.
5. Having considered the change against the substantive and procedural tests set out
in the relevant judgement2, I do not consider that there is justification for
exceptionally accepting the change. Accordingly, I have determined the appeal
based on the scheme which was refused by the Council and the plans listed on the
decision notice.
6. For the avoidance of further doubt, in accordance with Informative notes 2 and 3 of
the Council’s decision notice, my decision is based upon drawings LP01-542-YPP
1 (Location Plan) and SP02-542-YPP 1 (Site Plan Fencing) only. It takes no
1 Procedural Guide: Planning Appeals – England (updated 30 June 2025)
2 Holborn Studios Ltd v The Council of the London Borough of Hackney (2018)
Appeal Decision APP/D1265/D/25/3361945
2
account of additional illustrative plans which were submitted with the planning
application in respect of a proposed outbuilding.
7. In addition, the Council’s reasons for refusal specifically relate to the boundary
fencing element of the appeal scheme. It has found no conflict with Green Belt
policy or any other harm in respect of the foundation/base located in the south-
east corner of the site, which is intended to support a proposed replacement
storage outbuilding which is the subject of a separate planning application.3
8. Considered in isolation, the Council’s view is that the foundation/base comprises
an engineering operation, which, under Paragraph 154 (h) ii of the Framework, is
not inappropriate development within the Green Belt provided it preserves its
openness and does not conflict with the purposes of including land within it. On the
basis that the foundations are sited at ground level and are within the existing
residential curtilage, the Council is satisfied that these criteria are met. Based on
the evidence before me, and my site inspection, I have no reason to disagree. In
any event, given my conclusions below, in respect of the fencing element of the
appeal scheme, there is no need for me to consider this matter further, since it will
not alter the outcome of this appeal.
Main Issues
9. The main issues are:
• Whether or not the fencing constitutes inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the Framework and any relevant development plan
policies;
• The effect of the fencing on the openness of the Green Belt and the purposes of
including land within it;
• The effect of the fencing on the character and appearance of the area; and
• If the fencing is inappropriate, whether harm by reason of inappropriateness, and
any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other considerations. If so, would this
amount to the very special circumstances required to justify the fencing.
Reasons
10. The appeal site lies within open countryside to the south-west of Corfe Mullen
within the Bournemouth Green Belt. The site is occupied by a residential bungalow
with a soft-landscaped garden area adjacent. The remainder of the site is largely
given over to hard standing and includes a mobile home, storage buildings and an
area where a number of vehicles are parked. Vehicular access is via Beacon Hill
Lane which runs from the south side of Wareham Road.
Whether inappropriate development
11. The Act defines “building” as any structure or erection, and any part of a building.
For the purposes of the consideration of Green Belt policies, this includes fencing.
Having regard to the nature of the appeal scheme, Paragraph 154 of the
Framework is relevant and states that development in the Green Belt is
inappropriate unless one of the stated exceptions applies.
3 : LPA Ref P/HOU/2025/00786
Appeal Decision APP/D1265/D/25/3361945
3
12. The evidence before me is that the appeal site has a residential use. As such, the
fencing does not meet any of the Paragraph 154 listed exceptions and is therefore
inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
13. The appellants’ view is that the fencing falls within the remit of Paragraph 154 b).
However, this exception specifically relates to appropriate facilities, including
buildings, for outdoor sport, outdoor recreation, cemeteries and burial grounds and
allotments. Having regard to the use of the appeal site, this does not apply to the
appeal scheme fencing.
Openness and purposes
14. The Framework identifies that a fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to keep
land permanently open, and that the essential characteristics of Green Belts are
their openness and permanence.
15. The appeal scheme 3m high metal fencing would extend around a long part of the
appeal site boundary, comprising the whole length of the southeast side boundary
and a significant proportion of the length of the front and rear boundaries.
16. Green Belt openness has both spatial and visual dimensions. The fencing
introduces built development onto parts of the site which did not historically exist.
Notwithstanding the spaces between the galvanised metal bars, it nonetheless
comprises a substantial physical boundary treatment. As such it has an impact on
the spatial aspect of openness.
17. The fencing design is such that it affords views through it, in contrast to some
other more solid means of boundary treatment such as a wall or close-boarded
timber fencing. However, due to the relatively narrow spacing between the vertical
bars, together with the inclusion of horizontal bars, the fence would still clearly be
perceived as an enclosing structure when viewed from within the appeal site, from
neighbouring land and from Beacon Hill Lane. This effect is magnified on the front
element of the fencing which has had a green mesh membrane added.
18. Mature vegetation would partly screen the visual impact of the fencing along some
of the site boundary, but for a large part, including along the front and rear
boundaries, it would be highly visible in wider views.
19. Having regard to the domestic scale and the nature of the development, I find that
the aforesaid impact on the openness of the Green Belt in both spatial and visual
terms would be localised and modest. Nonetheless, this would be contrary to
Paragraph 142 of the Framework which states that an essential characteristic of
Green Belts is their openness.
Character and appearance
20. The vicinity of the appeal site is rural and verdant in nature and is characterised by
sporadic built development set amongst large open fields. The fields are often
bounded by mature trees and hedging, or in the case of the equestrian land
adjacent to the appeal site, by low post and wire fencing which is in keeping with
the countryside location and maintains the openness of the fields.
21. Moreover, this part of Beacon Hill Lane comprises a typical narrow rural road with
no pavements, and it is edged with treed, hedged and grassed roadside verges
and property frontages which are defined by mature soft landscaping.
Appeal Decision APP/D1265/D/25/3361945
4
22. The green colour of the fencing and its open mesh design which allows some soft
landscaping around it to be partially visible through the structure, would go some
way to aiding its visual assimilation into its rural surroundings as well as providing
a visual connection with the existing green on-site storage building in the northern
corner of the site.
23. However, notwithstanding this, the galvanised steel fencing is noticeably industrial
in nature and is strongly at odds with the distinctly rural character of the area and
the aforesaid typical existing boundary treatments. Its design is more appropriately
suited to that of a commercial site, and it appears incongruous within the otherwise
verdantly edged Beacon Hill Lane. Its height and length combine to exacerbate the
visual impact of the scheme, particularly in views from the public realm of Beacon
Hill Lane when approaching the site from the southeast direction due in part to
rising ground levels to the east of the appeal site.
24. I have noted the appellant’s proposal to extend the existing frontage Laurel
hedging and plant either in front of or behind the frontage fencing to soften its
visual impact. However, notwithstanding the proposed use of a landscape
condition to secure this planting, I am not persuaded on the basis of the evidence
before me that there would be sufficient space or appropriate growing conditions to
enable such planting to be successfully carried out. In coming to this view, I have
noted the proximity of the frontage fencing to the hard surfacing located on the
highway and on the appeal site, including that associated with the recently laid
foundation/base for a future new outbuilding.
25. Moreover, even if it were proven to be possible to undertake such planting, I
cannot be certain that the landscaping would be implemented and thereafter
retained, and this is not a reason to allow development that is otherwise
unacceptable.
26. My attention has been drawn to the previous presence of visually prominent close-
boarded fencing along part of the front boundary. However, the evidence before
me is that this fencing only occupied a relatively short section of the site frontage
in comparison to the appeal scheme. Moreover, it has been removed, and I have
no evidence that it was lawfully erected. As such, this does not alter my views in
respect of the visual impact of the appeal scheme.
27. For the above reasons, I conclude that the appeal scheme fencing results in
material harm to the intrinsic rural character and appearance of the countryside.
As such, it is contrary to Policies HE2 and HE3 of the Christchurch and East
Dorset Local Plan: Part 1 Core Strategy (2014) in so much as these policies,
amongst other things, seek to ensure that new development protects and seeks to
enhance the landscape character of the area and is compatible with or improves
its surroundings in terms of, inter alia, scale, height, materials and visual impact.
28. This accords with Chapter 12 of the Framework which seeks to achieve well-
designed places.
Other considerations
29. The appellants’ cited primary reason for requiring the boundary fencing is to
improve the security of the property. I accept that to serve this purpose, the
boundary treatment needs to be higher than that allowed under Permitted
Development. Also, I have no reason to doubt that the appeal site has been
Appeal Decision APP/D1265/D/25/3361945
5
subject to previous break-ins, noting its location bounded by open fields to the
rear and side and fronting onto a quiet rural lane where built development is
sporadic with gaps in between.
30. In the absence of cogent evidence of actual incidents, and details of the number
and nature of the occurrences, I attach moderate weight to this benefit of the
appeal scheme fencing. In apportioning this weight, I also take account of the
residential use of the site, noting that there are other residential properties
nearby, and there is no evidence before me that these dwellings require a similar
design of security boundary fencing.
31. The appellant has not cited any public benefits associated with the appeal scheme
fencing.
Green belt balance
32. The appeal scheme fencing represents inappropriate development in the Green
Belt as defined by the Framework. The Framework indicates that this is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. Moreover, the development results in a modest loss of
spatial and visual openness, thereby adversely impacting upon one of the
essential characteristics of the Green Belt and one of its main purposes of
safeguarding the countryside from encroachment. I have also found harm to the
character and appearance of the area because of the appeal scheme fencing. I
attach moderate weight to this harm, having regard to the minor level scale and
nature of the development.
33. Very special circumstances will not exist unless the potential harm to the Green
Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm resulting from the
proposal, is clearly outweighed by other considerations. Government policy
dictates that, in carrying out the balancing exercise, substantial weight is to be
given to any harm caused to the Green Belt, including harm to its openness.
34. I conclude that the security benefits cited in support of the appeal scheme fencing,
to which I have attributed moderate weight, do not clearly outweigh the substantial
harm that the development causes to the Green Belt. Consequently, the very
special circumstances necessary to justify the development do not exist. As such,
the development conflicts with Chapter 13 of the Framework which aims to protect
the Green Belt.
Conclusion
35. Therefore, for the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be
dismissed.
S Leonard
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.