Demolish existing garage and rebuild new two storey side extension and single storey rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
1
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 April 2025
by J Somers BSocSci (Planning) MA (HEC) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 May 2025.
Appeal Ref: APP/P1045/D/25/3361114
19 Paxton Close, Matlock DE4 3TD
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal
to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Hadleigh & Charlotte Johnson-Harvey against the decision of
Derbyshire Dales District Council.
• The application Reference is 24/00940/FUL.
• The development proposed is described on the Application Form as ‘Demolish existing garage and
rebuild new two storey side extension and single storey rear extension.’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development upon the existing
dwelling and the character and appearance of the locality.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is located along Paxton Close, a residential cul-de-sac leading
from Megdale. Development along Paxton Close appears to have been undertaken
as a speculative development during the mid-late twentieth century. As a result,
many of the dwellings have similar materials and design with simple two storey
construction with pitched and gable roof forms, the use of buff brick, concrete roof
tiles with feature boarding to front facades. Development along Paxton Close is
quite unique given that dwellings have been constructed to fit the steep topography
of the land and the road that slopes from Megdale in the east towards the west.
4. As one travels down Paxton Close the Matlock Hills along the River Derwent are a
prominent characteristic which can also be experienced between the gaps between
dwellings above single storey garages that separate dwellings. Whilst there are
detached properties on the opposite side of the road, to the south of Paxton Close
where the appeal site is situated lies semi-detached dwellings. The dwellings are
interesting as they do not follow the conventional layout of a pair of semi-detached
dwellings. Each pair of semi-detached dwellings are staggered to the topography of
the land, with the western half of the pair of semi-detached dwellings setback from
the front façade of the eastern half with the topography causing the eastern half to
have a lower apex, setback and ground level from its neighbouring half. There is a
regimented layout in terms of design and placement with many of the dwellings
maintaining a similarly sized front garden with vegetation and driveway to the side
of the property leading to a single storey garage which enables a visual gap
between the properties to the landscape beyond. These are some of the positive
Appeal Decision: APP/P1045/D/25/3361114
2
qualities that make up the local distinctiveness, character and appearance of the
locality.
5. The appeal dwelling contains many of these positive characteristics, being one of
the characteristic halves of the semi-detached dwellings that is setback from the
eastern half in terms of front façade and apex which is deliberately staggered to
follow the topography of the land in relation to Paxton Close. To the side of the
appeal dwelling is a single storey garage with the dwelling contributing to the
positive elements of the character and appearance of the area and enables one to
acknowledge the original design as part of the planned development.
6. In undertaking an assessment of design and character, the Derbyshire Dales Local
Plan (LP) Policy PD1 lists a number of design related principles to be assessed
such as ensuring high quality design, having regard to the local context and
character in terms of scale, height, density, layout and relationship to landscape
features, amongst others. LP Policy HC10 is specific to residential extensions and
seeks that proposals consider height, scale, form, design and character of the
existing dwelling, including the site’s wider setting and location, amongst others.
7. Given that the overriding character of Paxton Close and the staggered nature of
development to follow the topography of the site, the proposed elongation of the
façade with a two storey side extension would look awkward in this particular
context as it does not follow the regimented pattern of development. The larger
setbacks of front facade together with the lower apex assists in reducing the scale
and massing of properties in this particular location. Consequently there is much
more prevalence in design functionality here than a more traditional arrangement
when extending a semi-detached dwelling without the topographical considerations
and within this particular context where there is a characteristic layout and design
treatment of the dwellings.
8. I disagree with the Appellant’s Statement of Case (SoC) that the proposal should
be treated or assessed as a ‘cohesive new building’ as to do this would ignore the
surrounding context, design and relationship of the dwelling and the wider
environment as per LP Policies HC10 and PD1, which places an emphasis of
ensuring development adheres to the character and context of the surrounding
locality. The lack of setback or staggered nature of the proposal would provide an
elongated appearance that has a domineering presence which would unbalance
the pair of semi-detached dwellings and have an awkward juxtaposition within the
street scene that does not reinforce the positive qualities or characteristics as
described previously.
9. I acknowledge comments in the Appellant’s SoC with regards to No.7 Paxton Close
where a two storey extension has been constructed to the side and has a similar
relationship to the Appeal site and where the Appellant considers that the small
setback is of little visual value. In my opinion the visual value and articulation of the
setback of the extension for No.7 could have been increased by a larger setback
that mimicked the original setback, but despite this, the small setback does assist in
breaking up the built form and making the extension more subservient. A similar
assessment is also made with the examples along Megdale, Prospect Drive and
Collingwood Crescent as presented in the SoC. Whilst these dwellings in
surrounding streets do not have the same regimented staggered layout as Paxton
Close, the setbacks of the extensions are quite shallow and a greater depth may
have increased their visual contribution. Despite this, a shallow setback in my
Appeal Decision: APP/P1045/D/25/3361114
3
opinion would be better in this particular case than an elongated façade without any
articulation as present on the appeal proposal.
10. Consequently, and in conclusion of this matter, the proposed extension would
present as an incongruous form of development which harms the character and
appearance of the existing building and the greater locality and would be contrary
to LP Policies HC10 and LD1 as described previously.
Conclusion
11. For these reasons, and having considered all matters raised in evidence and from
what I saw during my site visit, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
J Somers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.