Demolition of the existing detached garage and erection of a single rear and side extension to the existing building with internal alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Ecology & Biodiversity
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 February 2025
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 07 March 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/Y3615/D/25/3358437
Girtford, Tuckey Grove, Ripley, Surrey, GU23 6JG
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Wendy Boardman against the decision of Guildford Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 24/P/01282.
• The development proposed is demolition of the existing detached garage and erection of a single
rear and side extension to the existing building with internal alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are the effects of the proposal upon: - (i) the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and wider area, (ii) the living conditions at
Loxwood, with particular regard to visual impact, and (iii) protected species.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
3. The appeal property is a detached bungalow with a rectangular floor plan and
hipped roof with ridge running front to back. It occupies a large, wedge-shaped,
corner plot with a narrow frontage to Tuckey Grove where it turns through ninety
degrees. The area is a fringe urban location that is residential in character with the
appeal site, and other properties along the west side of Tuckey Grove, backing
onto open fields beyond. Houses in the immediate area comprise detached, two
and single-storey homes of mixed sizes, ages, and appearances with traditional
pitched or hipped roof forms. The proposal would see a majority portion of the
existing building’s fabric demolished along with a detached garage to one side.
Only the south side flank and front walls would be retained. These would be
incorporated into a remodelled bungalow with a rear addition projecting almost
18.5m deep beyond the existing rear wall, and which would wrap around part of the
existing side elevation, projecting around 2.7m to the side, and with a
comprehensive new hipped roof over.
4. The Council’s Residential Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning
Document (SPD) was adopted in 2018. It recognises that even small changes to
buildings can have a big impact. As a general principle the SPD advises, amongst
other things, that an extension or alteration should be subordinate to and in
Appeal Decision APP/Y3615/D/25/3358437
2
character with the existing dwelling and should not over-dominate. It further advises
that the optimum length of an extension should reflect the scale, proportion, and
mass of the existing property, that roofs should be appropriately integrated with the
existing property, and that extensions that face highways have active frontages.
5. I accept that the street scene is varied and as such, I do not consider the
appearance of Girtford to be oversensitive to change. I also agree with the
appellant that many properties along Tuckey Grove have benefitted from a variety
of changes and extensions. However, I saw the majority to have been successfully
undertaken in reasonably balanced and proportionate ways, with respect for the
architectural composition and form of the original dwelling and appearance of the
wider area. There are some examples where this is not the case, but these are by
far the minority and demonstrate how poor design considerations can be harmful.
6. In this instance, the proposed works would engulf the existing building, remodelling
its appearance beyond any recognition of the original, and increasing its size by a
vast degree, projecting the building deep into the rear garden. I find the changes
would not only be stark in terms of scale but would also result in a
disproportionately elongated building that would add an unreasonable degree of
sprawl over the site. This would be overtly out of keeping with the open and
spacious rear garden settings that characterise the area. Its incongruous presence
would be further exaggerated by an awkward chamfer along a significant length of
one side elevation towards the rear, coupled with an equally awkward shift in the
roof’s ridge alignment when seen in both plan and elevation. In addition, the front
facing double width garage would dominate the dwelling’s appearance within the
street scene in an uncharacteristically utilitarian manner.
7. Notwithstanding some positive attributes of the proposal, including the use of
materials that would be sympathetic to the local palette and sustainable
construction methods, by reason of its size, form, and appearance, I find the
proposal as a whole to be poorly conceived, without respect for the modest scale
and appearance of the host dwelling. By so being it would be incongruous in its
setting, to the detriment of the character, visual amenities, and spacious qualities of
the area. There would be conflict with a number of the SPD’s guiding principles, as
well as Policies H4 and D4 of the Guildford Borough Local Plan: Development
Management Policies (LPDMP), adopted in 2023, and Policy D1 of the Guildford
Borough Local Plan: Strategy and Sites 2015-2034 (LPSS), adopted in 2019, as far
as between them they seek to ensure that development displays a high quality of
design that respects and contributes to the existing context and local
distinctiveness. For the same reasons there would be conflict with the National
Planning Policy Framework’s objectives for achieving well-designed places.
Living Conditions
8. Loxwood is a two-storey neighbouring dwelling to the south side of the appeal
property. It occupies a similar front and rear building alignment to Girtford but is set
at a slight angle to it due to the turn in the road. The Council accepts that the
extension would not have any significant impact upon levels of daylight or sunlight
to any habitable rooms within Loxwood. Due to the single-storey form of Girtford
and the distance that would be maintained between both dwellings, I do not
disagree.
Appeal Decision APP/Y3615/D/25/3358437
3
9. I saw during my visit that there is a range of outbuildings to the rear of Loxwood
and which run in a linear form abutting the common side boundary with the appeal
site. These include a flat roof garage with two timber ‘shed-like’ buildings beyond,
all of which can be seen projecting above the height of the approximate 2m high
timber fence boundary enclosure. The plans show the extension would be set
almost 2m away from the boundary and would project just beyond the depth of the
first shed which sits behind the garage at Loxwood.
10. Although the remodelled Girtford would be single-storey with a diminishing ridge
height towards the rear, the development would present itself facing the
neighbouring rear garden as a disproportionately long and imposing mass of solid
built form. Its overall scale would be significantly larger than the modest size of the
outbuildings at Loxwood and I am not persuaded that their existence, nor the
separation distance of the extension from the boundary, would be sufficient to
mitigate the visually incongruous and dominant presence of the new build so close
and deep into the open, rear garden setting when viewed from the neighbour’s rear
first-floor outlook and back garden space. This would be harmful to the living
conditions at Loxwood. As such, there would be further conflict with Policy D4 by
the development’s failure to respond positively to the surrounding context. There
would also be conflict with LPDMP Policy D5 which seeks to ensure that
development avoids any unacceptable impact on the living environment of existing
residential properties, and similar aims of the SPD.
Protected Species
11. The Council is of the view that because the proposal would involve demolition of an
unoccupied roof within a suburban, large garden setting, there would be the
potential for a protected species habitat to be present. They argue that the absence
of any preliminary ecological assessment could risk harm to a protected species.
12. I note some anecdotal observations from neighbours that bats are seen flying at
dusk in rear gardens. However, the reasonable likelihood of a species being
present at the appeal property is not supported by any credible evidence from an
appropriately qualified or experienced source. Given the limited information before
me, including the absence of any standing advice from Natural England, I am
unable to firmly conclude that the proposal would risk harm to any protected
species or that there would be any conflict with LPSS Policy D6.
Conclusion
13. Notwithstanding my findings on the third main issue based on information available
to me, I find that the proposal would be harmful to the character and appearance of
the host property and wider area. There would also be harm to the living conditions
of neighbouring occupiers at Loxwood. I recognise that the application was
submitted in an attempt to overcome reasons for refusal that were given for an
earlier scheme, but this does not alter my findings as they relate to the merits of the
development that is before me. Accordingly, for the reasons given, the appeal is
dismissed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.