Proposed solid fuel flue. Proposed extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 September 2025
by Ann Veevers BA(Hons) PGDip(BCon) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 21st October 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/24/3357908
Middle Harper Royd Farm, Hollin Lane, Norland, Sowerby Bridge HX6 3QR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by A. Denham against the decision of Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 24/00555/HSE.
• The development proposed is described as ‘Proposed solid fuel flue. Proposed extension’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. I have used the postcode provided on the Council’s decision notice rather than that
given on the application form as it more accurately identifies the site.
3. The appeal concerns part of a Grade II listed building referred to on the National
Heritage List for England as ‘Middle Harper Royd Cottages Middle Harper Royd
Farmhouse’1. I have therefore had regard to my statutory duty under section 66(1)
of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) to
have special regard to the desirability of preserving a listed building, or its setting,
or any features of special architectural or historic interest which it possesses.
4. An associated application for listed building consent Ref 24/00556/LBC for the
same scheme was not determined by the Council within the statutory timeframe.
An appeal under section 20 of the Act against a failure to give notice within the
prescribed period of a decision on an application for listed building consent was
subsequently submitted by the appellant2. The appeal was dismissed and listed
building consent refused. Whilst I have had regard to that appeal decision, for the
avoidance of doubt, my decision relates solely to this appeal made against the
refusal of planning permission for the proposed development.
5. A similar scheme for an extension and solid fuel flue has previously been granted
planning permission3 and listed building consent4. However, the appeal scheme
differs because it includes the removal of an area of masonry wall. This is the only
part of the scheme in dispute, and my decision will therefore focus mainly on this
matter.
1 National Heritage List for England, List Entry Number: 1134513.
2 Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/Y/24/3354399
3 LPA Ref 23/00756/HSE
4 LPA Ref 23/00757/LBC
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/24/3357908
2
Main Issue
6. The main issue is whether the proposal would preserve the Grade II listed building,
or any features of special architectural or historic interest which it possesses.
Reasons
7. Middle Harper Royd Farm comprises the end dwelling in a row of two storey stone
properties that occupy a commanding hillside position overlooking the valley
below. The whole row forms the single Grade II listed building. The list entry
describes the listed building as a farmhouse, now house, part a separate dwelling,
and a pair of attached cottages. The oldest part of the building dates from the 17th
Century and sub-divisions occurred along the row to form several cottages in the
early 19th Century. Evidence suggests Middle Harper Royd Farm was converted
from a barn to a dwelling in the late 20th Century. The listed building is constructed
of coursed gritstone with stone slate roofs.
8. The listed building as a whole has been significantly altered over time by sub-
divisions and extensions. Nevertheless, from the limited information before me and
my own observations, insofar as is relevant to the appeal, the building’s special
interest and significance derives from its architectural and historic interest as an
illustration of the development of domestic properties in an agricultural context
during the 18th and 19th Centuries to house workers. Its traditional construction and
use of local materials are important factors in these regards.
9. The catslide roof, horizontal alignment of windows, some with mullions, stone
quoins, chimney and roof edgings contribute considerably to the significance of
Middle Harper Royd Farm as part of the cohesive character of the whole listed
building. While the relatively recently added southern bay, rear dormer, single
storey utility room and timber sun room have somewhat diminished the ability to
appreciate the special interest and significance of the building, its historic plan
form is clear.
10. Paragraph 212 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) sets
out, when considering the impact of a proposed development on the significance
of a designated heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s
conservation. Paragraph 213 further advises that any harm to, or loss of, the
significance of a designated heritage asset should require clear and convincing
justification.
11. Much of the side wall of the catslide projection at Middle Harper Royd Farm would
be removed to create direct access from the existing kitchen to the proposed
extension. Both parties agree that this wall was rebuilt at the time the building was
converted from a barn to a dwelling. Photographs submitted by the appellant
indicates the wall was rebuilt in block work with a stone outer leaf and thus is not
of historic fabric. However, that does not mean that the wall is not of value in
demonstrating the historic plan form of the building, which contributes to its
significance. Furthermore, the proposed wide opening would be a clearly modern
alteration which would be discordant with the historic pattern of internal openings.
12. While I find the proposed extension in and of itself would be acceptable as a
replacement for the existing timber sun room, from the information before me, the
removal of the side wall of the catslide projection would weaken the special
interest in the evolution of the building and its historic plan form. As such it would
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/24/3357908
3
further diminish the special interest of the listed building as a whole and harm its
significance as a designated heritage asset.
13. In finding harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, the magnitude of
that harm should be assessed. Given the nature and extent of the development
proposed, I find the harm to the significance of the listed building would result in a
low level of ‘less than substantial’ harm. Nevertheless, this is of considerable
importance and weight. In such circumstances, paragraph 215 of the Framework
confirms that the harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the
proposal, which includes securing the asset’s optimum viable use.
14. The proposal would be likely to generate economic benefits while the works are
carried out, and social benefits in the improvements to the local housing stock.
There would also be a small heritage benefit to the removal of the existing
relatively unsympathetic lean-to sun room extension and its replacement with a
modern glazed extension. These outcomes would flow from the proposed
development and are of a nature to be of benefit to the public at large. The weight
they carry in the balance is moderated by the limited extent of the proposed
development but, nonetheless, weigh in favour of the appeal.
15. However, from the limited information presented, I am not persuaded that the only
way of securing such public benefits is by means of the opening as proposed.
Moreover, no substantive evidence is before me which demonstrates that such an
intervention would be necessary for the continued viable use of the dwelling. In
these respects, clear and convincing justification for the harm to the listed
building’s significance arising from the proposal has not been provided.
16. In giving considerable importance and weight to the harm to the significance of this
designated heritage asset, I find that this would not be outweighed by the public
benefits that the proposed development would generate.
17. Drawing all of the above together, I conclude that the proposed development
would not preserve the Grade II listed building known as Middle Harper Royd
Cottages Middle Harper Royd Farmhouse or any features of special architectural
or historic interest which it possesses. As such, it would harm the significance of
this designated heritage asset, and this would not be outweighed by the public
benefits generated by the proposal. Consequently, there would be conflict with the
statutory presumption set out in section 66(1) of the Act. There would also be
conflict with Policy HE1 of the Calderdale Local Plan 2018/19 – 2032/33, adopted
March 2023 which sets out, amongst other things, that development proposals will
be expected to conserve heritage assets in a manner appropriate to their
significance. It would also not comply with the provisions within the Framework
which seek to conserve and enhance the historic environment.
Conclusion
18. For the reasons set out above, the proposed development conflicts with the
development plan and the material considerations do not indicate that the appeal
should be decided other than in accordance with it. Accordingly, the appeal is
dismissed.
Ann Veevers INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Technical Appeal Representation
This Other minor developments requires a bespoke technical strategy to succeed.
Contact Planzo for a professional review and quotation.