Appeal development is described as: Proposed two storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 April 2025
by E Heron MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 June 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/C4615/D/24/3357622
70 Southerndown Road, Sedgley, Dudley DY3 3NA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs D Christie against the decision of Dudley Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is P24/0791.
• The appeal development is described as: Proposed two storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. The description of development in the heading above is taken from the application
form. Whilst the Council’s description is more detailed, I am satisfied that the
above adequately describes the development proposed.
Main Issues
3. Based on the Council’s decision, the main issues are the effect of the proposed
development on:
• the character and appearance of the area; and
• the living conditions of the occupants of 72 Southerndown Road with
particular regard to outlook.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
4. The site is within a quiet residential estate that comprises a mix of single-storey
and two-storey, modern dwellings. Whilst the site is not in a Conservation Area or
other special designation, there is a distinctive prevailing character on the west
side of Southerndown Road. This is the gently staggered row of gable fronted
dwellings, and a pleasant mixed material palette of render, cladding, and tile-hung
panels on the front elevations.
5. The appeal property sits at the end of the row of dwellings between No 68 and
No 72. It is distinctive as it is the sole example of an originally designed house as
it is taller with a steeper roof pitch and prominent side dormer. However, it also sits
comfortably within the street scene as it conforms to the staggered building line
and is gable fronted. In addition, its design features take their cue from the
Appeal Decision APP/C4615/D/24/3357622
2
adjoining row of dwellings. It is prominent from the north on the approach into the
estate from Gospel End Road, and in this context the long run of gable-fronts and
dual-pitched roofs, including the appeal property, is particularly visually
pronounced. This is due in part to the ground level of No 72, and its separation
from the appeal site by way of a low-key and lengthy, side element.
6. The Dudley Council Residential Design Guide, Supplementary Planning Document
(2023) (SPD), advises that new development should be subordinate in terms of
scale to retain the general proportions of the dwelling, and that dormer windows
would only be permitted exceptionally, where they would be in keeping with the
architectural style of the property and would complement existing features in terms
of proportions and positioning, amongst other things.
7. The ridge of the proposed side extension would be flush with the main ridge of the
house, such that the roof slope would be an expansive feature orientated towards
the site frontage, at odds with the prevailing roof slopes in the street. The dormer
window would draw further attention to this roof slope due to its dual-pitched roof
design and position on the roof of the extension. These elements of the proposal
would not be subservient to the simple appearance and massing of the host
dwelling and would detract from the prevailing gable-front characteristic of the
street scene.
8. In respect of the side aspect facing north, whilst the dormer would be removed, a
tall gable feature with prominent eaves would be introduced. This would also be an
incongruous and discordant feature within the street scene, where gables to the
front elevations predominate. Overall, I find that the proposal does not accord with
the design principles in the SPD.
9. The appellant has referenced the SPD guidance insofar as it relates to additional
stories. However, I have attributed limited weight to this argument as this section
of the SPD refers solely to the Prior Approval procedure under the Town and
Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order, (2015), (as amended).
10. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would be harmful to the
character and appearance of the area. As such, in this regard, the development
conflicts with the relevant provisions of Policies S6, S8, and L1 of the Dudley
Borough Development Strategy (2017) (DS), and Policy ENV2 of the Black
Country Core Strategy (2011) (CS). Amongst other things these require
development to respect, protect, and respond to locally distinctive character, and
the visual qualities of local areas, amongst other things.
Living Conditions
11. The neighbouring property, No 72, is positioned at a lower level and has windows
facing the appeal site, and an outdoor private area in the intervening space. The
proposed roof of the side extension is angled away from this boundary and is also
separated from the bulk of No 72 by two outbuildings. The side gable feature
would face towards the appeal site’s own parking and turning area. The proposal
would also not extend further towards the rear than the existing, and as such
would not encroach further towards the neighbour’s window or outdoor space.
Finally, the side dormer would be removed, replaced with a rooflight, the sole
additional window would be obscure glazed, and there would be a net reduction in
the side fenestration overall. Taking all of these factors into account, the proposal
would not appear overbearing or create an oppressive boundary. In addition, there
Appeal Decision APP/C4615/D/24/3357622
3
would be no detrimental loss of light. These factors are consistent with the
Council’s report.
12. As such, I conclude that the development would not harm the living conditions of
the occupants of 72 Southerndown Road with particular regard to outlook. As
such, in this regard, I find no conflict with Policies L1 and S6 of the DS. These
require, amongst other things, that development should not cause unacceptable
harm to living conditions of neighbouring occupiers and requires adherence to
design quality principles. In respect of this main issue, my attention has been
drawn to Policy ENV2 of the CS and Policy S8 of the DS. However, it has not been
explained how these are relevant to this main issue and so I find they weigh
neither in favour of nor against the appeal development.
Other Matters
13. The appellant asserts that the development plan policies are not pertinent to the
design on the basis that the locality is not distinctive or historic, Policy S6 has been
misinterpreted and the CS policies are out of date. The policies in question refer to
local distinctiveness, and whilst historic environment is included within the wording,
it is not the defining justification for respecting local character. Moreover, I have
found that the development conflicts with Policy S6 as it does not respond
positively to the character of the local area. In relation to the age of the CS, this
remains an adopted development plan document, and the relevant policies align
with the principles contained within the National Planning Policy Framework.
14. I am satisfied therefore, that the quoted policies are relevant to the appeal. I have
based my assessment upon them together with the development plan as a whole,
and I have further determined that no other considerations have been identified
that would outweigh that assessment. This includes my findings in relation to the
second main issue.
Planning Balance and Conclusion
15. I have not found harm in respect of living conditions, and I acknowledge that the
net reduction in windows on the side elevation would be of benefit to the living
conditions of the occupants of No 72. However, I have found that this does not
outweigh the harm in respect of the effect of the appeal development on the
character and appearance of the area. In this case, I consider there would be
conflict with the development plan overall. There are no material considerations
that indicate the decision should be made other than in accordance with the
development plan. Therefore, for the reasons given, I conclude that the appeal
should be dismissed.
E Heron
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.