Upper floor domestic extensions for all three dwellings; raising roof line to form additional living accommodation and roof terrace for each
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Open Space
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 March 2025
by A Dawe BSc (Hons), MSc, MPhil, MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 March 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/P0119/D/24/3357072
31 a, b and c Gloucester Road, Almondsbury, South Gloucestershire BS32 4HH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Darren Lloyd of Panorama Place Limited against the decision of South
Gloucestershire Council.
• The application Ref is P24/01692/HH.
• The development proposed is upper floor domestic extensions for all three dwellings; raising roof line
to form additional living accommodation and roof terrace for each.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The description of development in the above header is taken from the original
application form. I note that this is different to the wording in the Council’s decision
notice and on the appeal form. However, I am satisfied that the above description
adequately describes the proposed development.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
i) the character and appearance of the surrounding area;
ii) the living conditions of the occupiers of 33a Gloucester Road (No 33a) with
particular regard to privacy.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The proposed development would have a design consistent with that of the
existing dwellings at 31 a, b and c Gloucester Road. However, the nature of the
proposals, involving upward extensions, would add an additional storey to those
dwellings, albeit with the proposed new rooms being restricted to above the
existing south-east wing of each dwelling. As such they would be set back from the
north-west facing elevations and would have a degree of separation between the
respective new rooms of each dwelling.
5. The dwellings are currently set in the context of other surrounding houses of
varying sizes and designs, some more prominent than others, sporadically located
on the broadly north-west facing escarpment and along the ridgeline, and where
there are varying degrees of mature tree cover, likely to be more of a feature in the
Appeal Decision APP/P0119/D/24/3357072
2
months of greater leaf cover. Those existing dwellings include others in the
immediate vicinity that are at a higher level on the escarpment than 31 a, b and c.
The dwellings concerned, at 31 a, b and c, are set further forward on the
escarpment than most others in the immediate vicinity that are at a similar or
higher level. However, their part one part two storey design, setting them into the
escarpment slope, minimises their protrusion from the general topography and
above the foreground vegetation to the immediate north-west. That combined with
the degree of surrounding containment by other nearby dwellings, enables them to
adequately sit in that context without appearing unduly prominent.
6. The existing dwellings on the site are visible to varying degrees from lower level
public vantage points to the south-west, west and north-west. Those from the
south-west are at a short range from Forest Hills and a little further away from
Scop Field. Views from a more westerly direction include those from a public
footpath set away from the escarpment that runs through the orchards below the
site, and roads beyond, comprising Tockington Lane, albeit glimpses and generally
sideways from vehicles, and then Moor Lane beyond that with varying degrees of
clarity.
7. The extent to which the dwellings are visible from those vantage points varies
depending on the precise viewing locations and the extent of intervening
vegetation. Nevertheless, they are currently seen as being contained within that
existing context of other dwellings, including at higher levels, and varying degrees
of softening from intervening vegetation depending on the viewing point.
8. I acknowledge that the room extensions would only be over part of the existing
houses and the intention for a retained uniformity and rhythm to the three
dwellings together, including in terms of design features. However, the proposed
upward extensions would be sufficient to have a noticeable additional massing
effect.
9. That additional height and massing would noticeably increase the degree of
protrusion of the dwellings away from the escarpment slope. This, together with
the forward location and raised position of the dwellings on the escarpment, would
noticeably increase the degree of prominence of the dwellings. From those
vantage points referred to above, there would still be varying degrees of
intervening vegetation screening or softening. However, the effect of that would be
lessened to varying extents due to the proposed increased height and massing,
and the dwellings concerned would also rise more distinctly above the vegetation
immediately to the north-west of the site.
10. As a result, to varying degrees, it is likely that the dwellings concerned would no
longer be seen as comfortably sitting into the escarpment slope and contained by
those surrounding dwellings, even if backdrop trees and buildings may still be
visible to some, albeit a lesser, extent. As such, the proposed development would
cause the dwellings to stand out as dominant and obtrusive features in the
landscape as seen from those various vantage points, including those at more of a
distance away.
11. I acknowledge that there are large modern houses along Forest Hills which are
prominent features. However, they are at a lower level and so less prominent in
the wider landscape than would be the case with the proposed extended
dwellings.
Appeal Decision APP/P0119/D/24/3357072
3
12. For the above reasons, the proposed development would cause unacceptable
harm to the character and appearance of the surrounding area. As such, the
proposed development would be contrary to policy CS1 of the South
Gloucestershire Local Plan: Core Strategy 2006 – 2027 (the Core Strategy) and
policies PSP1, PSP2 and PSP38 of the South Gloucestershire Local Plan:
Policies, Sites and Places Plan, adopted November 2017 (the PSPP) which
together, amongst other things, set out a requirement for the highest possible
standards of design; siting, form, scale, height, massing, detailing, colour and
materials to be informed by, respect and enhance the character, distinctiveness
and amenity of both the site and its context; and that development proposals will
be acceptable where they conserve and where appropriate enhance the quality,
amenity, distinctiveness and special character of the landscape, including
distinctive or characteristic topography and landforms.
Living conditions
13. The proposed upper floor extension to No 31c would include windows serving
what is annotated on the plans as an entertainment room. Those windows would
directly face towards the rear garden of No 33a. No 33a has a single storey
pitched roof outbuilding alongside a significant section of the shared boundary with
No 31c which would therefore prevent overlooking of a large proportion of
No 33a’s rear garden area from those windows. However, importantly, there would
still be lines of sight either end of the outbuilding to parts of that rear garden.
14. Due also to the additional height of the proposal, there would therefore be direct
overlooking, over the intervening boundary wall, from the largest of those
proposed new windows to No 33a’s private garden area closest to the rear of that
house. Furthermore, when looking from the other smaller window there would be
direct overlooking, over the intervening boundary fence and vegetation, of a small
section of the lower level private garden area of No 33a. In both cases, whilst the
proposed new room would be set away from the boundary with No 33a, that
degree of overlooking would nevertheless be at a close range, to an extent that
would be likely to cause a significant loss of privacy to the occupiers of that
neighbouring dwelling.
15. Additionally, the proposed new roof terrace to No 31c would be positioned
alongside and very close to the side boundary of No 33a. There is proposed to be
a wall surrounding that space, shown on the plans to be 1300mm above the new
roof terrace. However, at that height, it is highly likely that it would not be sufficient
to prevent people comfortably looking over it. As such there would be direct
overlooking from that space, at close proximity, of the lower private garden space
of No 33a, albeit to varying extents due to existing intervening boundary
vegetation. From that terrace there would also be clear overlooking towards the
upper garden level of No 33a nearest to that house, including a covered seating
area open to the rear. As such, again, that level of overlooking would be likely to
cause a significant loss of privacy to the residents of No 33a.
16. I note that the Appellant claims in the Appeal Statement that the total screen
height of the proposed roof terrace wall would be 1.6 metres. However, it appears
that the reference line used relates to the existing roof level, as shown on the
submitted elevation plan Drawing No A16, and not the finished floor level of the
proposed new roof terrace.
Appeal Decision APP/P0119/D/24/3357072
4
17. For the above reasons, the proposed development would cause unacceptable
harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of No 33a with particular regard to
privacy. As such, it would be contrary to policy PSP8 of the PSPP which, amongst
other things, sets out that development proposals will be acceptable provided that
they do not have an unacceptable impact on the residential amenity of nearby
properties which could result from loss of privacy and overlooking.
Planning balance
18. The proposed development would provide additional amenity space for the
proposed houses which would be a likely benefit in the context of there being no
existing garden space. Nevertheless, the existing terraces provide a good degree
and quality of outdoor space, and I have no substantive evidence to indicate that
to be inadequate in terms of the living conditions of the occupiers. In that context,
the benefit of added amenity space would not be sufficient to outweigh the harm I
have found would be caused in respect of the main issues.
Conclusion
19. For the reasons given above the appeal should be dismissed.
A Dawe
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.