Partial demolition and rebuilding of existing swimming pool building to form garage and ancillary residential annex
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 April 2025
by J Moore BA (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23 May 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/P4415/D/24/3356051
Wales Court, The Old Coach House, Manor Road, Wales, Rotherham S26 5PB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr S Fletcher against the decision of Rotherham Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is RB2024/1380.
• The development proposed is partial demolition and rebuilding of existing swimming pool building to
form garage and ancillary residential annex.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The evidence indicates that a change to the description of development from that
as stated on the planning application form was agreed. I have therefore used this
agreed description in my banner heading above.
3. On 12 December 2024, the Government published a revised National Planning
Policy Framework (the Framework). While this includes changes in respect of
proposals affecting the Green Belt, the provisions most relevant for determining
this appeal were not significantly changed. As a result, I consider that there is no
requirement for me to seek further submissions on the revised Framework, and I
am satisfied that no party’s interests have been prejudiced by my taking this
approach. The further amendments made in February 2025 to the Framework do
not change its policies and it is therefore not necessary to seek further
submissions on those amendments. Where I have referred to specific paragraphs
of the Framework, the numbering used is that of the present version.
Main Issues
4. The appeal site is within the Green Belt. The appellant draws my attention to the
wording of the Council’s reason for refusal, which clearly refers to inappropriate
development in the Green Belt, the effect upon openness and other harm caused.
However, it does not identify what such other harm might be. I have therefore
considered the full text of the Council’s Officer Report (OR) which considered the
application, and I am satisfied that no other harm was identified by the Council.
5. Furthermore, the reason for refusal does not expressly refer to Policy SP4 of the
Rotherham Local Plan: Sites and Policies 2018 (LP). This policy is clearly relevant
to the proposal and was referenced within the OR. I have therefore taken account
of this policy in my consideration of the appeal.
6. Therefore, and having regard to all the evidence before me, the main issues are:
Appeal Decision APP/P4415/D/24/3356051
2
• whether the proposed development would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt having regard to the Framework and relevant development plan
policies;
• the effect of the proposal upon the openness of the Green Belt; and
• if the proposed development would be inappropriate, whether the harm by
reason of inappropriateness would be clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances required to
justify the proposal.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
7. The Framework sets out that the government attaches great importance to Green
Belts; that the fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by
keeping land open; and the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their
openness and their permanence. Development in the Green Belt is inappropriate
unless one of certain exceptions apply, including that at paragraph 154 c) of the
Framework, which refers to the extension or alteration of a building provided that it
does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building. The Framework does not define what might be considered as
disproportionate, and the definition of an ‘original building’ in the Framework is as it
existed on 1 July 1948, or if constructed after that date, as it was built originally.
8. Taken together, Policy CS4 of the Rotherham Local Plan Core Strategy 2014 (CS)
and LP Policy SP2 set out that land within the Rotherham Green Belt will be
protected from inappropriate development as set out in national planning policy.
LP Policy SP4 sets out that the extension or alteration of an existing building in the
Green Belt may be appropriate, provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building; and that the Council
considers that an increase in excess of 33% in the external volume of an original
building would make the proposals disproportionate. These policies are in
conformity with the Framework.
9. Further guidance is provided in the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document:
Development in the Green Belt 2020 (SPD), which makes clear at paragraph 96
that the onus is on the applicant to submit plans and calculations of the increase in
volume with the application. The application and its accompanying information do
not demonstrate this.
10. The evidence indicates that both parties have been unable to calculate the size of
the original building, due to what is described as a complex planning history of the
site and the absence of certain records, including any drawings of the site as it
existed in 1948. The appellant’s evidence to the appeal includes an extract from a
1972 OS map which demonstrates a footprint at the site of the existing extension,
but this does not assist me in understanding the footprint or external volume of the
original building as it existed in 1948. No other historic mapping is before me, and
the evidence indicates the existing extension proposed for partial demolition was
built in 2001.
11. The OR clearly indicates that the appeal property has a further first-floor extension
and a recent ground floor extension to the rear, and this is not disputed by the
Appeal Decision APP/P4415/D/24/3356051
3
appellant. In the Council’s view, these extensions together with the appeal
proposal appear to exceed the 33% threshold of LP Policy SP4. The appellant
suggests that if the 33% increase is exceeded, the existing extension is not the
cause of such an increase. However, there is no substantive or compelling
evidence before me within the submitted application, the appellant’s submissions
or the OR to set out the volume of the existing building and/or each of its
extensions and any relevant calculations to demonstrate this.
12. The evidence indicates that the wider site has a long history dating back to its use
as a hospital before its subdivision into separate dwelling units in the 1980s. The
appellant suggests that it is arguable that account should be taken of the volume
of the whole building complex as it existed prior to its subdivision into separate
dwellings in any assessment against the policy threshold. However, no such
calculations are before me and the OR indicates that an outbuilding was built
within the wider grounds and has subsequently become a dwellinghouse in its own
right, with its own extensions and outbuildings.
13. While I appreciate the difficulties each party may have had in calculating a
cumulative increase, the fact of the matter is that on the evidence before me, it has
not been demonstrated that the proposal would result in a cumulative increase
within the policy threshold, and the SPD makes clear that the onus is on an
applicant to demonstrate such matters.
14. For the above reasons, and on the evidence before me, I can only conclude that it
has not been demonstrated that the proposal would not be inappropriate
development in the Green Belt. I must therefore proceed on the basis that the
proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt, which is, by
definition, harmful. The proposal therefore conflicts with CS Policy CS4; LP
Policies SP2 and SP4; and paragraph 154 c) of the Framework.
Openness
15. Given my findings above, the starting point is that the cumulative effect upon
openness cannot be reliably assessed. The Old Coach House has an extensive
footprint in an L shape and the long end of the L shape is perpendicular to the road
near the entrance gate. The building sits within a wider complex of other buildings
including taller forms towards the south. Towards the road, it is enclosed by tall
boundary walling and gates, but it is sited at a rising level from it.
16. The existing extension is a tall structure sited at the end of the long part of the
building towards the road. It is a predominantly glazed addition to include a fully
glazed irregular roof form. Due to its siting and sheer scale, its upper part is within
view from the road above the existing boundary wall and entrance gates and when
travelling along the road. In views from lower lying land towards the east, it
appears as part of the wider complex of buildings.
17. The appellant indicates that the proposal would result in a 1% increase to the
external volume of the dwelling as it presently exists, and the OR indicates the
appeal scheme would result in an increase of 40m3 in comparison to the existing
extension. However, the effect of the proposal would be to create a tiled gable roof
of a more regular shape about 1m taller, such that its upper part would extend
farther towards the road at the upper level than the existing extension.
Consequently, the spatial impact of the proposal would be to introduce further
Appeal Decision APP/P4415/D/24/3356051
4
volume, bulk and mass to the building at the upper level, resulting in a harmful loss
of openness, which weighs against the proposal, even if limited.
Other Considerations
18. The appeal site benefits from planning permission Ref: RB2023/0356 for a very
similar proposal to the appeal scheme, with the key difference being that the
approved scheme retains the shape of the existing extension, such that there
would be no change in external volume. This scheme represents a fallback
position, with no greater impact on the openness of the Green Belt, as the OR
acknowledges. The fallback scheme would therefore be less harmful to the Green
Belt than the appeal scheme.
19. The OR draws attention to the erosion of the character of the building by the large
expanse of glazing of the existing extension, and that the appeal scheme would
blend in with its host. I find no reason to disagree, but this would also apply to the
fallback scheme, which includes less extensive glazing. Both the appeal scheme
and the fallback scheme would be more sympathetic to the host property in terms
of their stone-built appearance and tiled roof, and the proposed roof design of the
appeal scheme would be a more satisfactory architectural solution in terms of the
relationship with the host building than the fallback scheme.
20. I note that paragraph 21 of the SPD sets out that extensions (within the Green
Belt) must be compact and fit in with, rather than take over the original building,
and extensions that increase the length of a building on its longest side should be
avoided. Clearly, the existing extension was built well before the SPD. However,
the appeal scheme would also fail to comply with this guidance, to a greater
degree than the fallback scheme.
21. A Grade II listed building: Wales Court comprising The Manor, Wales Place, Wales
House and The Mews is located to the south of the appeal property. The list entry
indicates it was originally a small country house, now four houses, built in 1629
and the late 18th century, with 20th century alterations. The Old Coach House
building is some distance from it. Mindful of my statutory duty under section 66(1)
of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, there is no
concern by any party that the proposal would result in harm to the setting of this
listed building, nor any features of special architectural or historic interest which it
possesses. I find no reason to consider otherwise.
Green Belt Balance and Conclusion
22. On the evidence before me, it has not been demonstrated that the proposal would
not be inappropriate development in the Green Belt, and there would be harm to
openness, even if limited.
23. Paragraph 153 of the Framework makes clear that substantial weight should be
given to any harm to the Green Belt, including harm to its openness, and that
inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should
not be approved except in very special circumstances, which will not exist unless
the potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other
harm resulting from the proposal, is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
24. The fallback scheme would be less harmful to the openness of the Green Belt than
the appeal scheme. Both schemes would be more sympathetic to the character
Appeal Decision APP/P4415/D/24/3356051
5
and appearance of the host property and the street scene. However, the roofscape
of the appeal scheme is more sympathetic to the host property than the fallback
scheme. The proposal would therefore be an improvement in design terms,
compared to the fallback scheme. I therefore attach limited weight in favour of the
appeal scheme. No other considerations have been put forward.
25. It is therefore clear that the substantial harm to the Green Belt would not be clearly
outweighed by other considerations in this case. Consequently, the very special
circumstances required to justify the proposal do not exist. The proposal conflicts
with the development plan, read as a whole and the provisions of the Framework.
Therefore, for the reasons above, the appeal is dismissed.
J Moore
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.