Proposed loft alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
No strong technical themes detected.
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 March 2025
by C Mayes CMLI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8th of April 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/C5690/D/24/3355672
76 Handen Road, Lewisham, London SE12 8NR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Joanne Pink against the decision of the Council of the London Borough
of Lewisham.
• The application Ref is DC/24/136544.
• The development proposed is described as: Proposed loft alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. Since the appeal was lodged the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) has been updated. I am satisfied there are no changes of any
consequence for the main issue in this appeal.
3. Notwithstanding the description of development set out above, which is taken from the
application form, it is clear from the plans and accompanying details that the
development comprises the addition of a dormer window to the side roof slope, a
dormer extension to the rear roof slope and 2 rooflights to the front roof slope. The
Council dealt with the proposal on this basis and so shall I.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Lee Manor Conservation Area (the Conservation
Area).
Reasons
5. As the appeal site is within a conservation area, I have a statutory duty under Section
72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) to
pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of the area. The Framework also requires great weight should be given to
the conservation of heritage assets. These include conservation areas.
6. I have drawn my description of the relevant aspects and heritage significance of the
Conservation Area below from the Lee Manor Conservation Area Character Appraisal,
March 2008. Observations during my site visit confirm the appraisal.
7. The Conservation Area encompasses an early example of planned housing in a
suburban location developed during the late 19th- and early 20th-centuries. Much of
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/24/3355672
2
the heritage significance, character and appearance of the area derives from the
survival of a consistent pattern of buildings with high-quality architectural detailing,
design and materials.
8. Domestic buildings in the area, and along Handen Road, are in a variety of styles and
materials. However, the area is characterised by 3 predominant domestic building
types developed in 2 phases. The late 19th-century phase of development
predominantly includes three-storey detached villas and three-storey semi-detached
villas, as seen adjacent to the appeal property. The early 20th-century phase of
development principally includes two-storey terraced rows. The appeal property is an
end terraced dwelling in the only terraced row constructed on Handen Road. While
there is variety in form, scale and materials along the street, the pattern of
development is consistent, harmonious and complementary.
9. Dormer windows are present on the side and front roof slopes of several detached
and semi-detached properties along the street. However, these are predominantly
original elements of the buildings. Dormer windows are not an element of the terraced
row. Apart from the two-storey extension to the rear of the host property, and several
rooflights along the rear plane of the terrace roof, the terraced row is largely
unchanged. While the two-storey extension alters the symmetry of the rear elevation
of the terraced row it complements the architectural language, massing and materials
of the terrace and remains subordinate to the form of the original development. As
such, the original form, proportions and architecture of the host building and terraced
row remain legible.
10. The proposed rear dormer extension would be sited above and to one side of the two-
storey extension to the host property. The rear dormer extension would add mass to
the upper level of the rear elevation of the host property. The windows of the rear
dormer extension do not align with the existing fenestration below it. Furthermore, the
proposed rear dormer extension would be constructed against the feature party wall
and chimney between the host property and neighbouring dwelling. As such, the rear
dormer extension would appear unbalanced and cluttered harming the proportions
and appearance of the host building and terraced row. The visual prominence and
legibility of existing architectural features would be harmed by the scale, mass and
siting of the rear dormer extension. While visibility of the rear dormer extension from
the public realm would be limited it would be a prominent feature at roof level from the
gardens and upper floor windows of several dwellings in the surrounding area.
11. The design of the proposed side dormer window reflects the dormer window in the
roof of the adjacent semi-detached villa in both form and materials. As noted above,
the neighbouring dwelling dates from the earlier phase of development in the area and
employs a different architectural language. As such, the proposed side dormer
window would be both out of context and a departure from the otherwise consistent
and unaltered roof of the terraced row. The proposed side dormer window would be
located centrally between 2 prominent chimneys. The chimneys, matched by a pair at
the other end of the terrace, bracket and terminate the roofline of the terrace. Rather
than being partially concealed behind one of the chimneys, as suggested by the
appellant, the proposed side dormer window would be a prominent feature that would
disrupt the form and symmetry of the roofline, as seen from the street, and challenge
the prominence of the chimneys. This would harm the visual and historical
significance of the building and the stylistic juxtaposition with the adjacent building.
12. Both the rear dormer extension and side dormer window fail to respond sensitively to
the architectural language and proportions of the host dwelling, terraced row and other
buildings when seen together. Therefore, the proposal, by nature of its form, massing
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/24/3355672
3
and siting, would fail to preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the host
dwelling and surrounding area and would result in less than substantial harm to the
heritage significance of the conservation area.
13. Notwithstanding the use of matching materials, the proposal would introduce
incongruous features to the host dwelling and terraced row. The appellant suggests
that the details of materials to be used could be made the subject of a condition of
permission. However, in this case the materials to be used make no difference to my
overall conclusion considering the harm identified above.
14. Paragraph 215 of the Framework states that less than substantial harm to the
significance of a designated heritage asset (in this case the conservation area) should
be weighed against the public benefits of the proposed development. I acknowledge
the proposal would provide additional space that would benefit occupants of the
dwelling. However, this is not a public benefit of sufficient weight to justify the harm
identified above. I also acknowledge the appellant’s reference to the contribution the
development would make toward the local economy, their personal circumstances and
desire to remain within the community, and subsequent community cohesion.
However, such benefits do not outweigh the harm to the Conservation Area.
15. I note the Council’s Alterations and Extensions Supplementary Planning Document
(2019) (SPD) provides specific guidance on dormer and roof extensions in
conservation areas. This includes guidance on, not only the siting of dormers within a
roof slope, but also the need to have regard for the existing architectural language of
the building and features of architectural interest, such as, chimneys and other
windows. The appellant refers to the SPD with regard to the general principles and
locational requirements for dormer windows and extensions. However, application of
the general principles makes no difference to my overall conclusion when considering
the proposal in the context of the conservation area and the specific harm identified
above.
16. Taking all the above into account, I conclude that the proposed dormer extension and
dormer window would neither preserve nor enhance the character or appearance of
the Lee Manor Conservation Area. They would fail to satisfy the Planning (Listed
Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 in this regard and the historic
environment policies of the Framework. Hence it would conflict with Policies 30, 31
and 36 of the Lewisham Development Management Local Plan, 2014, and Policies 15
and 16 of the Lewisham Core Strategy, 2011, and Policy HC1 of The London Plan –
The Spatial Development Strategy for Greater London, March 2021. Together these
seek to ensure that development proposals are of a high standard of design that
respond sensitively to their context, respect the form, setting, period and architectural
character and detailing of the original building, and preserve or enhance heritage
assets.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons given above the appeal is dismissed.
C Mayes
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.