Appeal Against Conditions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Noise & Disturbance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 24 June 2025
by R Cahalane BA(Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 21 August 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/K1128/D/24/3355216
4 Alma Terrace, Higher Town, Malborough, Devon TQ7 3RN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73A of the Town and Country Planning
Act 1990 (as amended) for the development of land without complying with conditions subject to
which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Mr Andrew Notton against the decision of South Hams District Council.
• The application Ref 1415/24/VAR, dated 27 April 2024, was refused by notice dated 16 August 2024.
• The application sought planning permission for variation of condition 2 (approved drawings) following
planning consent 2895/22/HHO, to introduce external access door onto right of way at rear of terrace
without complying with a condition attached to planning permission Ref 2895/22/HHO, dated 27
February 2023.
• The condition in dispute is No 2 which states that: “The development hereby approved shall in all
respects accord strictly with drawing number(s) 2644.SBP A received by the Local Planning Authority
on 26th August 2022 and 2644.03D received on 17th February 2023.”
• The reason given for the condition is: “To ensure that the proposed development is carried out in
accordance with the drawings forming part of the application to which this approval relates .”
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Background and Main Issue
2. Planning permission was first granted in February 20231 for development including
a replacement single storey rear extension. This original permission was then
amended in March 20242 under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act
1990, which varied the approved plans condition (condition 2).
3. This appeal relates to the Council’s refusal of a further proposal under Section 73,
as set out in the banner heading above. The submitted evidence shows that the
main parties are in dispute in respect of the installation of an external access door
on to the side elevation of the approved single storey rear extension. I have
therefore utilised the description of development from the decision notice rather
than the application form, as it refers specifically to this access door.
4. The application form confirms that development started on 01 August 2023. I was
able to see the single storey rear extension, and its side access door subject of this
appeal. I have therefore determined the access door as retrospective in nature.
5. The main issue is the effect of the external access door on the living conditions of
the occupiers of No 3 Alma Terrace, with particular regard to privacy and noise and
disturbance.
1 Council Ref: 2895/22/HHO
2 Council Ref: 0106/24/VAR
Appeal Decision APP/K1128/D/24/3355216
2
Reasons
6. The appeal site (No 4) comprises a two-storey end-terraced dwelling within the
centre of Malborough village. The terrace (Nos 1-4 Alma Terrace) faces the road of
Higher Town on an elevated position, which necessitates several steps up to No 4’s
front door.
7. The external access door subject of this appeal is on an extended ground floor side
elevation that projects at a right angle slightly beyond the adjoining rear outshot of
No 3. This door provides direct access to an open-plan living area of No 4, and
faces immediately on to a neighbouring rear garden decking area that is adjacent to
No 3’s rear elevations.
8. Although my site visit was a snapshot in time, I noted that this decking serving No 3
contained a table and two chairs towards its rear edge, near to No 4’s side access
door and a private access route from Hay Lane that runs across the decking. Whilst
the side access door does not contain any glazing, it can be opened at various
times and for varying time periods, and even when not used solely for access
purposes. This allows for direct views towards the primary area of No 3’s decking at
very close proximity. This amounts to an unacceptably adverse impact on No 3’s
living conditions in terms of privacy.
9. Even when this door is closed, its presence immediately facing No 3 would still feel
unsettling and intrusive, as it could be opened internally at any time, without prior
indication. This would unacceptably hamper the useability of No 3’s decking area
as a private outdoor seating area adjacent to the main dwelling in which it serves.
10. Whilst there is already a degree of mutual overlooking between these two adjoining
dwellings, including their rear elevations, the dense shrubbery along the side
boundary separating the two gardens significantly obstructs ground level views. By
comparison, installation of the side access door substantially increases the
opportunity for direct overlooking towards No 3’s decking area, and therefore has
an additional and adverse intrusive impact on No 3’s privacy.
11. I therefore conclude that the external access door subject of this appeal
unacceptably harms the living conditions of the occupiers of No 3 with particular
regard to privacy. It thus conflicts with Policy DEV1 (1) of the Plymouth and South
West Devon Joint Local Plan (JLP) 2014-2034 (adopted 2019). This policy
requires, amongst other things, new development to provide for satisfactory privacy
for both new and existing residents.
12. The proposal also fails to satisfy the relevant guidance set out in paragraphs 13.17
and 13.20 of the JLP Supplementary Planning Document 2020. This advises that
any alteration or extension should not have an unacceptable effect on the standard
of living offered to neighbouring properties, and that overlooking may be
unacceptable where it would result in an intrusive, direct and uninterrupted view
from a main room to the main sitting out area adjacent to the property of a
neighbouring house.
13. When compared to No 4’s front entrance door, the side access door provides a
more level route along the rear elevations of Nos 1-4 Alma Terrace. Access for less
able users is however somewhat restricted by a stepped change of level from the
path along the rear of No 2 to the raised decking of No 3. I also observed pinch
points caused by drain pipes on the neighbouring rear elevations, and some
Appeal Decision APP/K1128/D/24/3355216
3
overhanging shrubbery on the other side of the path. This rear access route
therefore also presents restrictions for less able users, and thus does not justify
allowing the appeal.
14. Existence of private legal rights, such as a right of way for access, does not in itself
justify the grant of planning permission. This is because the planning system
governs development having regard to matters of public interest, including
safeguarding living conditions.
15. The side access door contains a lock and is adjacent to a ground floor habitable
room window, which is at a right angle on the rear outshot elevation of No 3. The
submitted evidence refers to a smaller gate that already provided access to the rear
garden of No 4, prior to the construction of the existing extension and side access
door. Having regard to that previously established baseline situation, I do not
envisage an adverse additional impact in terms of noise and disturbance, even
when accounting for the potentially greater frequency of use of the side access
door when compared to the previous gated access.
Other Matter
16. The submitted evidence indicates that the Council assessed a proposed external
access door as part of a previous application3 that was ultimately withdrawn. For
clarity, that previous application has not had a bearing on my determination of this
appeal, which I have determined having regard to the current submitted evidence
and my site visit observations.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons given above, the proposal conflicts with the development plan as a
whole and the material considerations before me do not indicate that a decision
should be made otherwise than in accordance with it. The appeal is therefore
dismissed.
R Cahalane
INSPECTOR
3 Council Ref: 4768/21/HHO
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.