First floor side extension; one dormer windows, a porch and three rooflights to front
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
No strong technical themes detected.
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 March 2025
by R Gravett BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28th April 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/N4720/D/24/3355057
36 Rakehill Road, Scholes, Leeds LS15 4AJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr A Germaine against the decision of Leeds City Council.
• The application Ref is 24/04101/FU.
• The development proposed is First floor side extension; one dormer windows, a porch and three
rooflights to front.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
• the character and appearance of the host dwelling and surrounding area;
and
• the living conditions of the occupiers of 34 Rakehill Road, with particular
regard to outlook and natural light.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. 36 Rakehill Road (No 36) is a detached dormer bungalow on the south side of
Rakehill Road, angled on its plot so that it broadly fronts the corner with Belle Vue
Avenue. It has an attached double garage and it is proposed to extend over this at
first floor to create a snug accessed from an existing bedroom.
4. Rakehill Road is identified as a non-designated heritage asset in the Barwick in
Elmet & Scholes Neighbourhood Plan 2017-2028 (2017) (NP). It is an attractive
residential street which is significant, in part, because of its open, long views
toward countryside to the east. It is characterised predominantly by detached
bungalows and houses which differ in their architectural design and detailing.
5. The guidance in the Council’s ‘Householder Design Guide Supplementary
Planning Document (2012)’ (SPD) for two-storey extensions, including those to
detached properties, is they should have some degree of subservience to their
host, recognising that the usual method of achieving this is to set the extension
back from the front wall and lower the ridge line. The proposal has been designed
as an ‘integrated’ extension so that the ridgeline and eaves (on the front elevation)
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/24/3355057
2
of the existing bungalow have been continued, with no set back from the front
elevation.
6. I accept that there are situations where an ‘integrated’ design would ensure the
extension remains subservient to its host. I note that the appellant has drawn my
attention to such a proposal at No 78 Belle Vue Avenue, where the first-floor
extension is over a very modest single garage. In contrast, I observed that the
existing double garage is roughly over half the width of No 36 and extending over
such a width at first floor, with no differentiation in ridge height, would dominate the
host bungalow. The proposal would therefore fail to achieve the degree of
subservience envisaged by the SPD guidance.
7. A dual pitched dormer window is proposed which would be sited broadly centrally
within the new roof of the first-floor extension. The dormer would be modest in
scale, set well off the sides and eaves of the host roof and just below the ridgeline.
It would not be dissimilar in size or design to the dormer windows on the
neighbouring property at 34 Rakehill Road (No 34), or the dormers recently
constructed at 7 Lyndhurst Close to which the appellant refers. In isolation, the
proposed dormer would not represent an unsympathetic or alien addition to its
host.
8. The ground floor of No 36 is offset from the flank of No 34 to the front, but this
tapers to the rear because of the respective orientation of the two dwellings. This
existing offset is broadly consistent with the spacing between other dwellings on
the south side of Rakehill Road, and I observed that this spacing, and the
openness between dwellings, contributes positively to the character and
appearance of the streetscene.
9. The offset between the ground floor of No 36 and its neighbour would not change,
but by extending over the garage at first floor the gable and overall massing of the
roof would be much closer to No.34. No 36 is sited forward of the building line of
its neighbour at No 34, and because of this, and its orientation on its plot, the
gable of the extension would appear unduly prominent in the significant long views
along Rakehill Road toward the east mentioned in the NP. It would also appear to
crowd its neighbour at No 34 to the detriment of the characteristic spacing and
openness of the surrounding area that I have described.
10. Further, the proposed first-floor extension would extend only the depth of the
garage retaining an existing conservatory to the rear. In order to continue the
profile of the main roof, there would be a small section of pitched roof to the rear,
with very high eaves and a vertical rear elevation. This section of pitched roof
would be visible from Rakehill Road and would appear an awkward, discordant
addition to its host.
11. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would cause harm to the
character and appearance of the host dwelling and surrounding area. It would
conflict with policies P10 and P12 of the Core Strategy (as amended by the Core
Strategy Selective Review 2019) (2019) (CS), saved policies GP5 and BD6 of the
Leeds Unitary Development Plan (Review 2006) (UDP) and NP Policy BE1.
These, amongst other things, require new development, including extensions, to
deliver high quality design which is of a size, scale and design appropriate to its
context and respects the character and quality of surrounding buildings and
townscapes.
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/24/3355057
3
12. The proposed development would further conflict with NP Policy LE1 which
requires any development proposals to pay due regard to the importance of
conserving non-designated heritage assets.
Living conditions
13. On the flank gable of No 34 are two ground floor windows which directly face the
common boundary with the appeal property. It is understood from the evidence
before me that, although both are obscure glazed, the larger of these windows
serves a bedroom which is a habitable room. This bedroom window is located
broadly centrally in the flank but because the building line of No 34 is set back
from its neighbour, the outlook from this window is principally toward the
conservatory of No 36 and the existing high boundary fence which is close. The
outlook from this window is also partly toward the rear corner of the existing
garage of No 36, which has a reasonably high parapet to its flat roof, however this
is at an angle.
14. The proposed first floor extension would project across the full width of the existing
garage and at its rear corner would be only around 3m from the flank of No 34,
extending the bulk and massing of the gable closer to it. It is acknowledged that
the extended gable of No 36, as well as the corner of the extension and part of the
new vertical elevation to the rear, would be visible from the bedroom window.
However, because it would be seen at an angle, and above the boundary fence, it
would not appear unduly dominant or result in a harmful loss of outlook.
15. Given its proximity, the lower part of the ground floor bedroom window is already
overshadowed by the close-boarded timber fence along the common boundary
with No 36. Because the proposed first-floor extension would be located to the
north-east, I am not persuaded, nor do I have any evidence to suggest, that it
would result in a discernible reduction in the level of daylight or sunlight to this
bedroom window.
16. I therefore conclude that the proposed first-floor extension would not cause harm
to the living conditions of the occupiers at No 34, with particular regards to outlook
and natural light. It would accord with CS Policy P10, saved UDP policies GP5 and
BD5 in so far as they require development to be designed with consideration given
to the amenity of their surroundings and to avoid a loss of, and protect, residential
amenity.
Other Matters
17. I acknowledge that the appeal property is within an existing residential area close
to amenities and transport connections. However, whilst benefits of the location,
these are not matters which would outweigh the harm that I have found above to
character and appearance.
Conclusion
18. I am satisfied that the proposed first-floor extension would not cause harm to the
living conditions of the neighbours at 34 Rakehill Road. Nevertheless, for the
reasons given above, it would cause harm to the character and appearance of the
host dwelling and surrounding area.
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/24/3355057
4
19. The proposal conflicts with the development plan as a whole and the material
considerations do not indicate that the appeal should be decided other than in
accordance with it. Therefore, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
R Gravett
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.