Ground floor rear extension, front porch and first floor rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 12 February 2025
by K E Down MA(Oxon) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 25 February 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/B1930/D/24/3353731
40 Windermere Avenue, St Albans, Hertfordshire, AL1 5QN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Terry Dempsey against the decision of St Albans City & District Council.
• The application Ref is 5/24/0912.
• The development proposed is a ground floor rear extension, front porch and first floor rear extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The one main issue is the effect of the proposed rear extensions on the living
conditions of occupiers of 42 Windermere Avenue with respect to outlook and light.
Reasons
3. The appeal dwelling is a post war semi-detached house. It is set on a generous plot
in a cul-de-sac of similar semi-detached and terraced dwellings and, on the
opposite side of the street, a primary school. The Council raises no objection to the
proposed front porch and I agree it would be acceptable. I shall therefore restrict
my further consideration to the rear extensions.
4. The proposed rear extensions would comprise a ground floor addition some 6.3m
deep with a first floor above, some 3.3m in depth. The extension would occupy the
full width of the rear elevation which is currently un-extended and would lie adjacent
to the shared boundary with No 42, the semi-detached pair. The rear gardens
which are extensive face slightly north of due west. The appeal dwelling lies
generally north of No 42.
5. The dwellings have rear windows that are arranged close to the shared boundary.
At ground floor these appear to serve habitable kitchens. At first floor the window in
No 42 appears to serve a bathroom and landing which are non-habitable areas.
6. The eaves height of the single storey element, which would have a flat roof is not
denoted on the plans but, extrapolating from the eaves height of the porch which is
shown and can be seen to be similar they would be somewhere in the region of
2.1m with the finished roof slightly higher. Whilst noticeable from the kitchen
window at No 42, the limited height of the single storey element, and the position of
No 42 generally south of the proposed extension, would ensure that outlook from
Appeal Decision APP/B1930/D/24/3353731
2
that window was not materially affected, despite the overall depth. Neither would
there be any material loss of light.
7. Nevertheless, the first floor element although shallower would, owing to its
proximity to the shared boundary, appear to loom over the rear of No 42 which
would result in an unacceptably overbearing effect when seen from the kitchen
window and garden immediately behind the dwelling.
8. I agree with the appellant that, owing to the orientation and relative position of the
two dwellings, there would be no material loss of sunlight. However, the extension
would contravene the 45° rule and as such daylight would be reduced from the
north, which would result in the outlook from the kitchen window and area of garden
behind the rear elevation at No 42 feeling gloomy and penned in, particularly during
winter months when the absence of sunlight would exacerbate the effect.
9. I therefore find that the single storey extension on its own would not materially harm
the living conditions at No 42 but, owing to the proximity of the first floor element to
the shared boundary, taken as a whole the extensions would materially harm
outlook and light when seen from the kitchen window and garden area close to the
rear of the dwelling.
10. The appellant draws my attention to other extensions in the vicinity which he
considers are similar. However, in most cases these comprise single storey
extensions, some with separate loft dormers. In one case where a first floor has
been built up to the shared boundary, the semi-detached neighbour has a deep
single storey extension which would mean that its ground floor rear windows were
not affected by the two storey extension.
11. The appellant also suggests that the extensions were intended to be 6m and 3m
deep to meet permitted development dimensions. However, a drafting error meant
that external dimensions are some 0.3m greater in each case and he would be
willing to reduce these. Firstly, the plans before me show the greater dimensions
and these are what I must consider. Secondly, the combined extensions could not
in any case be considered as permitted development. Moreover, a first floor
extension carried out under permitted development rights would need to be at least
2m from the boundary. Therefore, even if the extension was reduced in depth there
would be no permitted development fallback.
12. It is concluded on the main issue that, taken together, the proposed single and two
storey rear extensions would have a materially harmful effect on the living
conditions of occupiers of 42 Windermere Avenue with respect to outlook and light.
In consequence, they would conflict with Policies 69 and 72 of the City and District
of St Albans District Local Plan Review, 1994, and with the National Planning
Policy Framework, 2024. Taken together these expect new development to have a
high standard of design such that there is no unacceptable effect on adjoining
property with respect to light and amenity and, specifically in the case of two storey
rear extension, do not normally intrude into a 45° visibility zone of a neighbour’s
ground floor windows.
Appeal Decision APP/B1930/D/24/3353731
3
13. For the reasons set out above and having regard to all other matters raised,
including the lack of objection from the neighbouring occupier, I conclude that the
appeal should be dismissed.
K E Down
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.