Conservatory to side of property (Revision to refused planning permission DC/24/69085)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 December 2024
by Eleni Marshall BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16 December 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/G4620/D/24/3351968
2 Kinsey Road, Smethwick, B66 4SN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Haroon Ahmed against the decision of Sandwell Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application reference is DC/24/69590.
• The development proposed is conservatory to side of property (Revision to refused
planning permission DC/24/69085).
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. I have utilised the Council’s description of the development as per the decision
notice as I feel it more concisely describes the development. I have also
utilised the site address, and postcode, set out within the Council’s decision
notice/appellant’s appeal form as the site address in the original application
form itself (section 4) appears to be incorrect.
3. The National Planning Policy Framework was revised on 12 December 2024;
however, the key changes are not considered to impact upon the determination
of this appeal in relation to the main issues noted below.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the impact of the proposal upon private amenity space and
the visual amenity of the street scene.
Reasons
5. The appeal site is a two storey, attached, residential dwelling located on a
corner plot within Kinsey Road. The proposal seeks to add a conservatory to
the side of the property, and I note, from my site visit and the planning history
noted within the Council’s delegated report, that the host dwelling appears to
have already been extended most notably via a two-storey side extension
which was granted under planning permission DC/20/64022 in May 2020. The
approved, and built, side extension does, however, leave sufficient private
outdoor amenity space to the side and front of the dwelling for the benefit of
occupiers. The proposed conservatory would be attached to this extension.
6. The proposal that is before me would measure in the region of 4.5 metres in
length and 6.32 metres in width with an overall height of 2.9 metres. As can
be seen, from the submitted proposed site location/block plans the proposal,
Appeal Decision APP/G4620/D/24/3351968
2
denoted by the black rectangle, would extend into the remaining amenity
space/garden which I find would significantly reduce the garden amenity space
to an unacceptable level. The proposal would result in a significant majority of
the appeal site being covered by built form with significant loss of private
amenity space. As a result of this I consider the proposal to be over
development and over intensification of the appeal site as well as unacceptable
in terms of residential amenity for occupiers of the host dwelling.
7. The application form states that the proposal would, in terms of materials,
utilise brick, tiles and UPVC to match the host dwelling which would ensure that
the materials are consistent with the remainder of the appeal site, however,
the proposal would result in a flat roof, largely glazed, conservatory which I do
not find would complement the street scene. The proposal would appear as out
of character when viewed from within the immediate vicinity. Views of the
proposal would still be available of the top of the proposal which would be
consistent with the eave height of the existing side extension where it would
join the existing kitchen. In this case I therefore find that the proposal would
both be inconsistent with the character and the appearance of the host dwelling
and the immediate locality. The proposal would have a significant detrimental
impact on the street scene and result in over intensification of the appeal site
which is sufficient to warrant refusal.
8. I note that the appellant outlines planning approval which is stated to have
been granted at 12 Barratt Street as well as having included the plans from
that proposal (drawing number P/20/11/7). Whilst I do not have a copy of the
decision notice itself, for that site, the plans provided are of limited comparison
to the proposal that is before me. The proposal appears to be for a single
storey rear extension and works to the boundary and, whilst this is a flat roof
structure, it is a brick structure which I find to be more appropriately designed
and in keeping with design in the locality. Furthermore, whilst site plans have
not been provided, I would assume, that if this has been approved as stated,
that this left sufficient garden space as a result of the proposals to be
considered acceptable from the perspective of the amenity of occupiers of that
site. Based upon the limited information before me I therefore find that the
proposal at 12 Barratt Street is of limited similarity, or weight, to the proposals
that are before me and each case should be considered on its own merits. In
this case, I find the appeal proposal is inconsistent with general design within
the locality and, most notably, would result in the vast majority of the plot
being the subject of built form resulting in over intensification.
9. I note, and acknowledge, the comments made by the appellant as to the need
for the space as well as their willingness to change layout or consider any
changes required to accommodate the concerns. Whilst I attribute great
weight to the need stated for the space, I do not find that, in this case, this
outweighs the substantial harm I have identified to the locality nor would this
overcome the fact that the appeal site, if this proposal were allowed, would
essentially be left with no garden which would be unacceptable for the lifetime
of the development.
10. The original dwelling has already benefitted from a two-storey side extension
and, cumulatively, proposed extensions would be disproportionate to the host
dwelling and unfortunately it is not the place for an appeal to consider changes
to the proposal – I must consider the proposal as determined by the Council
before me. I have considered, for example, whether a condition relating to
Appeal Decision APP/G4620/D/24/3351968
3
alternative materials could make the proposal acceptable, however, this would
not change the scale of the proposals or overcome the impact of loss of
garden/amenity space as outlined as a key issue.
11. The proposal would be contrary to Policy ENV3 of the Black Country Core
Strategy 2011 which seeks to delivery high quality design and Policy EOS9 of
the Site Allocations and Delivery Development Plan Document 2012 which
outlines that particular regard will be paid to how the development relates to
the street, its relationship with the public realm and the nature and height of
any buildings and their effect on the surrounding urban area. The proposal
also seeks to reject poor designs, particularly those that are inappropriate in
the locality, for example, those clearly out of scale or incompatible with their
surroundings.
12. The proposal would also be contrary to the Residential Design Guide
Supplementary Planning Document 2014 which states, in relation to
personalisation and domestic scale extensions, that extensions must be in
proportion to the scale of the existing dwelling and street scene, the
appearance and architectural detailing must respect established design codes
and that the over intensification of individual dwellings where it is proposed to
extend them to a scale that is considered unreasonable will be resisted.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons outlined above, and taking into account all other matters
raised, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Marshall
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.