Replacement of 13 no. windows, a front door and a pair of French doors
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Sustainability
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 February 2025
by R Catchpole BSc (hons) PhD MCIEEM IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 24 February 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/A2470/D/24/3349765
Jacobs Barn, Rookery Lane, Stretton, Rutland, LE15 7RA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Amanda Clare Skelton against the decision of Rutland County Council.
• The application reference is 2024/0592/FUL.
• The development proposed is the replacement of 13 no. windows, a front door and a pair of French
doors.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The proposed works have already been carried out and this appeal is
consequently retrospective. I have seen the effect and I am satisfied that the
works have been carried out according to the plans that are before me. This is the
basis upon which this appeal has been determined.
3. As the works are in a Conservation Area, I have had special regard to section
72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (as
amended) (the Act).
4. The Council has shortened the description of development in its decision notice
but did not include the front door. For the sake of brevity and clarity, I have used a
modified version of the shorter description for the purposes of this appeal.
Main Issue
5. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on character and appearance with
special regard to the extent to which it would preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Stretton Conservation Area (the CA).
Reasons
6. The CA covers a compact area which includes a limited number of historic
buildings which are interspersed with modern, infill development. The historic
buildings include the church of St Nicholas which is located adjacent to the open
countryside to the south. The western boundary abuts the Great North Road and
the A1 with the continuous traffic noise forming an audible backdrop to the village.
The agricultural origins of the settlement remain legible from the presence of its
coursed stone rubble cottages and the manorial, farm complex on Manor Road.
This character is further reinforced by a prominent historic barn at the eastern end
Appeal Decision APP/A2470/D/24/3349765
2
of Rookery Lane. Boundary treatments vary but stone rubble is characteristic
within the central core. Plot size and the orientation of historic buildings is irregular
and suggestive of organic rather than planned development. Frequent mature
trees give the village a verdant quality.
7. Given the above and insofar as this appeal is concerned, I find its significance to
be founded on the use of a distinctive palette of materials and building techniques
associated with the traditional, vernacular form and materials of its historic
buildings.
8. Jacob’s Barn is an L-shaped, single storey building near the westernmost extent of
the CA with a gable end abutting Rookery Lane. It was converted to residential
use around 25 years ago. It is closely juxtaposed with another converted farm
building known as Erskine Barn where the same windows have been approved by
the Council. The proposal has replaced modern, wooden windows that were
associated with this conversion with ‘Residence 9’ uPVC windows of similar design
and colour. Additionally, the front door on the eastern elevation has been changed
as well as French doors on the northern elevation, which are viewable from the
public domain. Although the northern elevation is set down, the height of the
hedge and sporadic planting along the palisade fence are such that both the
northern and the western elevations are visible from multiple viewpoints along
Rookery Lane.
9. Whilst I observed the frequent use of double glazing throughout the CA, the use of
uPVC appeared limited. Although present in Erskine Barn, this building has a
much lower level of prominence and is therefore not capable of having a tangible
visual impact. As is common with such windows, I find the casement frame
around the individual windows to be overly thick which gives them a heavy,
inelegant appearance at odds with the typical form of historic, single glazed
windows. The plastic trickle vents at the top of the windows also detract from their
appearance. Additionally, the glass has a greater reflectivity in comparison to
single glazed windows which further adds to their incongruity. However, I note that
this was also the case for the windows that were replaced and is common
elsewhere in the CA. Whilst a like-for-like replacement could have been seen as
having a neutral effect on the significance of the CA, I find the replacements
detrimental due to their heavier frames and non-traditional materials. Although I
note the fine-grained, impressed wooden pattern, the windows are clearly of uPVC
construction despite having a smart appearance.
10. The appellant maintains that it is not out of character given the ‘bright white uPVC
windows’ that can be seen elsewhere in the village. As I have already noted, the
use of this material is limited. I also do not have the full circumstances of those
installations before me and in any event, the presence of existing harm is not a
justification for further harm to be caused.
11. The appellant also draws my attention to the poor condition of the windows that
have been replaced and has submitted photographs as evidence. I note that there
was some rot, particularly at the base of the doorways. However, the effect this
had on the overall appearance of the CA and whether or not less harmful repairs
could have been carried out cannot be judged because of their premature
replacement.
Appeal Decision APP/A2470/D/24/3349765
3
12. Given the above, I find that the proposal has harmed the significance of the CA
through the use of inappropriate materials and has consequently failed to preserve
or enhance this designated heritage asset.
13. Paragraph 212 of the National Planning Policy Framework 2024 (the Framework)
advises that when considering the impact of development on the significance of
designated heritage assets, great weight should be given to their conservation.
Paragraph 213 goes on to advise that significance can be harmed or lost through
the alteration or destruction of those assets and that any such harm should have a
clear and convincing justification.
14. Given the limited scope of the visual impact, I find the harm to be less than
substantial in this instance but nevertheless of considerable importance and
weight. Where a proposal leads to less than substantial harm to the significance
of a designated heritage asset, paragraph 215 of the Framework advises that this
harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
15. The appellant is of the opinion that the proposal is beneficial because it improves
the long-term energy efficiency of the property. I accept that this is a public
benefit. Although paragraph 167 of the Framework stresses the need to support
energy efficiency, I only give this benefit limited weight because the new units
replaced existing double glazing which would have had similar benefits had they
been properly maintained. Consequently, I do not find that the public benefits are
sufficient to outweigh the harm that I have identified in this instance.
16. Given the above and in the absence of public benefits that would outweigh the
harm that would be caused, I conclude that the character and appearance of the
Stretton Conservation Area has neither been conserved nor enhanced.
17. This would fail to satisfy the requirements of the Act, paragraph 210(a) of the
Framework and conflict with policy CS22 in the Rutland Core Strategy DPD (2011)
and policy SP20 of the Rutland Site Allocation and Policies DPD (2014) which
seek to protect the character and appearance of conservation areas.
Other Matters
18. The appellant has highlighted the Council’s willingness to allow some uPVC but
that insufficient time was provided to respond to this suggestion. Whether or not
sufficient time was given is an internal matter. I also note that the appellant was at
liberty to withdraw the application and resubmit a more suitable proposal but chose
not to do so.
19. The appellant notes that approval was given for an extension with prominent
aluminium windows (Ref: 2022/0842/FUL) and takes issue with inconsistency in
the Council’s decision-making. I do not have the details of this proposal before me
in order to come to a view on this matter and each case must, in any event, be
judged on its individual merits.
20. The appellant highlights community-based activities as being indicative of a
positive regard for the village. Whilst commendable, this is not a planning matter
and is not material to my decision-making.
21. I have had due regard to the Public Sector Equality Duty set out under s149 of the
Equality Act 2010 (as amended). The harm caused by permitting the replacement
doors and windows would not outweigh their benefits in terms of eliminating
Appeal Decision APP/A2470/D/24/3349765
4
potential discrimination against a person with the protected characteristic of age1,
advancing equality of opportunity for those persons and fostering good relations
between them and others.
Conclusion
22. Given the above and considering all other matters raised, the appeals should be
dismissed.
R Catchpole
INSPECTOR
1 Appellant’s 95-year old mother.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.