Demolition of single-storey extensions, erection of two-storey and single-storey extensions, blocking up of existing access, proposed new vehicular access and parking area
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Highways & Transport
Character & Appearance
Ecology & Biodiversity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 January 2025
by B J Sims BSc (Hons) CEng MICE MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28 January 2025
Appeal Ref: APP/V3120/D/24/3347191
Box Cottage, Broadbrook Lane, Sparsholt, Wantage, Oxfordshire, OX12 9PJ.
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Peter Reynolds against the decision of Vale of White Horse District
Council.
• The application Ref is P24/V0102/HH.
• The development proposed is demolition of single-storey extensions, erection of two-storey and
single-storey extensions, blocking up of existing access, proposed new vehicular access and parking
area.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for demolition of single-
storey extensions, erection of two-storey and single-storey extensions, blocking up
of existing access, proposed new vehicular access and parking area at Box
Cottage, Broadbrook Lane, Sparsholt, Wantage, Oxfordshire, OX12 9PJ, in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref P24/V0102/HH, and subject to
the conditions set out in the Appendix to this Decision.
Procedural Matters
2. The description above is based upon that set out in the refusal notice.
3. The proposal was amended after initial submission and the application was refused
and this appeal is considered with respect to Drawings Refs:
2308-3_101 Rev B
2308-3_202 Rev B
2308-3_203 Rev B
2308-3_301 Rev B
4. However, a further Revision C of Drawing 2308-3_301, with illustrated access
vision splays added, is also taken into account.
5. At the time of my site visit, Box Cottage was under refurbishment but, if that
represents an early start on the appeal development, it has no effect on my
consideration of the planning issues arising in the appeal.
Main Issues
6. The main issues are: the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the appeal property and the wider surrounding Sparsholt
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/24/3347191
2
Conservation Area (CA); the safety of the proposed replacement vehicle access;
and the effect on biodiversity.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
7. The current proposed design for the extensions, as refused by the Council, would
result in a fifty percent increase in the internal floor area of the dwelling at Box
Cottage. The Council rejected the proposal largely on grounds that the two-storey
element, in particular, would appear disproportionate and out of keeping in its dark,
timber-clad finish with respect to the original Box Cottage, which is a small-scale,
traditional workers dwelling.
8. The original building was long ago extended to the rear, creating a twin pitched-roof
profile. A further flat-roofed extension, to be demolished to make way for the
present scheme, was added much later. However, the southern main frontage has
always remained in its original form, such that Box Cottage still appears from
Broadbrook Lane as a charming workers dwelling, in the red-brick common in the
village, making a positive contribution to the Sparsholt CA. Importantly, that
situation would not essentially alter as a result of the building works now proposed
and there would accordingly be no harmful impact on the immediate street scene of
Broadbrook Lane due to the proposed building works.
9. From the open area of the village to the west, the two-storey extension would be
visible above the 1.5m boundary wall. It would be almost as high as the present
twin gables but it would be set back and finished in dark-coloured timber cladding,
in contrast with the red brickwork of the gables. I consider that overall, the
extension would appear acceptably subservient to the main structure.
10. Clearly, the chosen finishing materials of dark timber walls and pre-weathered,
standing seam zinc roof sheeting would be different from those of the existing
building; but the zinc would visually complement the slate roof of the main Cottage.
Moreover, dark timber cladding finishes are much in evidence about the CA on
traditional agricultural buildings but also on some modern house extensions.
11. I have reached the opinion that, subject to a condition to ensure compliance with
the approved plans and the finishing materials therein specified, the proposed
extensions would have no adverse impact on the character or appearance of Box
Cottage in any view, despite a departure from some aspects of adopted
supplementary guidance on house extensions.
12. Before reaching an overall view on the issue of character and appearance, I
consider it necessary to assess the effect of the proposed access. This would
involve removing a length of boundary hedge and setting back the new entrance by
a car length from the road edge. The existing entrance would be closed in
compensation, but there would a slight net amount of urbanisation of the rural
street scene at this point, resulting in a minor degree of less than substantial of
harm to the character and appearance of the Sparsholt CA, to be weighed in the
planning balance.
Vehicle Access
13. The application was refused for the further reason of a lack of information to assure
the safety of the proposed vehicle access from a proposed parking and turning
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/24/3347191
3
area at the centre of the garden onto the classified, 20mph Broadbrook Lane.
There is no doubt that the vision splays available at the new entrance would be
substandard with respect to the accepted minimum dimensions of 2.4m set-back by
25m along the road edge. That is due to the location of the entrance in the inside of
slight curve. A plan illustrating 25m splays to the centre of the Lane was submitted
with the appeal but this is still technically substandard.
14. I am mindful though that this proposal is for a replacement entrance for one that
exists a little further east. That entrance is narrow and without any set-back or
vision splays. It appears little used but there is nothing to say that it could not give
rise to potentially dangerous access and egress manoeuvres at any time.
15. In contrast, the proposed entrance would be wider and recessed to provide a
refuge for vehicles entering, as well as improved visibility for those emerging. So,
although the vision available would be strictly substandard, the proposed entrance
would be less likely to cause dangerous vehicle conflicts and there would be a
significant net improvement in road safety over the present situation.
16. Therefore, subject to conditions to secure the provision of access, on-site parking
and turning space as proposed, I find no conflict between the access proposals and
the aims of VWHLP Policies CP35, CP37 and DP16, as well as national policy, with
respect to the provision of adequate parking and safe access.
Biodiversity
17. The application was also refused on biodiversity grounds, in the absence of a bat
emergence survey.
18. A specialist bat emergence survey was submitted with the appeal. This concludes
that, although there is some bat activity over the appeal site and in the immediate
area, including Noctule and Brown Long-eared species as well as the more
common Pipistrelle, there is no evidence of bats roosting within the appeal
property.
19. There is no other evidence of the presence of any protected species. However, in
the circumstances, I consider it sufficient to impose the broadly worded condition,
suggested without prejudice by the Council, to require the implementation of an
approved Construction Method Statement prescribing measures to safeguard any
bats or other protected species encountered.
20. With that condition in place, I consider that the proposed development would be in
accordance with Policy CP46 of the VWHLP with respect to Conservation and
Improvement of Biodiversity.
Other Matters
21. The Council is satisfied, and I agree, that there is no objection with regard to
residential amenity. The Parish Council has no objection to the current proposal
and there is no other matter in the written representations to affect my decision.
Planning Balance and Conclusion
22. I consider that the localised less than substantial harm to the street due to the new
access would be more than outweighed by the benefit I have identified to road
safety in Broadbrook Lane.
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/24/3347191
4
23. In view of my finding that the works to Box Cottage itself would cause no harm to
the character or appearance of the site or its surroundings, it follows that there
would be no harm to the character or appearance of the Sparsholt CA as a whole,
which would accordingly be preserved in accordance with established planning law.
24. I conclude, finally, that the proposed development is to be regarded as compliant
with the development plan as a whole, and that therefore this appeal should be
allowed and the permission sought granted, subject to the conditions discussed
above.
B J Sims
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/24/3347191
5
APPENDIX
PLANNING CONDITIONS
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years from the
date of this decision.
2) The development hereby approved shall only be carried out in accordance with the
following approved drawings:
2308-3_101 Rev B
2308-3_202 Rev B
2308-3_203 Rev B
2308-3_301 Rev C
3) Prior to the use or occupation of the new development, the new vehicular access
and visibility splays hereby approved and shown on approved drawing number
2308-3_101 Rev C shall be provided. Thereafter, the visibility splays shall be
permanently maintained free from obstruction to vision.
4) Prior to the use or occupation of the new development, the car parking spaces
shown on approved drawing number 2308-3_101 Rev C shall be constructed and
surfaced to prevent surface water discharging onto the highway. Thereafter, the
parking spaces shall be kept permanently free of any obstruction to such use.
5) Prior to the commencement of works on site, a Construction Method Statement
(CMS) for protected species shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the
Local Planning Authority. The CMS shall describe Reasonable Avoidance Measures
to be employed during construction to avoid impacts on: (1) badger, hedgehog and
other small animals (including measures to be employed to avoid these species
becoming trapped in excavations); (2) nesting birds (including vegetation clearance
timings and/or arrangements for ecological supervision); (3) great crested newt
(including details of a phased cut of the section of the southern boundary hedgerow
to be removed, using hand tools; rules for siting and storage methods of building
materials and site waste to minimise risks of newts using them as temporary refugia
(such as use of pallets for materials storage, avoidance of storage on grass and
vegetated garden areas, and prompt removal of waste); and the CMS shall give
details of the procedure to be followed if a newt is discovered during the works. The
approved CMS shall be strictly adhered to and implemented throughout the
construction period.
- End of Appendix -
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.