Erection of two storey side, front and rear extension, single storey extension to existing garage and its conversion to habitable accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Fallback Position
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
- Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/24/3347162
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 September 2024
by C Shearing BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 September 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/D3640/D/24/3347162
20 The Avenue, Chobham, Woking, Surrey GU24 8RU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act
1990 (as amended) against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Van der Sloot and Harris against the
decision of Surrey Heath Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 24/0366/FFU.
• The development proposed is described as ‘erection of two storey side, front
and rear extension, single storey extension to existing garage and its
conversion to habitable accommodation’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The description of development in the banner heading above is taken from the
application form.
3. On 30 July 2024 the Government published a consultation on proposed
reforms to the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) and other
changes to the planning system. The policies that are material to this decision
are not subject to any fundamental changes, and I am satisfied that this has
not prejudiced any party. Consequently, in reaching my decision I have had
regard to the Framework published in December 2023.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
- Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the Framework and any relevant development plan
policies;
- The effect on the openness of the Green Belt, and;
- Whether any harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm,
would be clearly outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to
the very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
- Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/24/3347162
Reasons
Whether Inappropriate
5. The Framework, at paragraph 142 identifies that the fundamental aim of
Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently
open. It goes on to state that inappropriate development is, by definition,
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances.
6. The Framework establishes that the construction of new buildings in the
Green Belt should be regarded as inappropriate development, but lists
exceptions in paragraph 154. One such exception is the extension or
alteration of a building provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building.
7. The existing building, which is largely in its original form, is a modest sized
detached house positioned centrally on its plot. It has varied roof forms
including a hip-to-gable feature to the front elevation within which some of
the first floor rooms to the front of the house are contained. The appellant
does not dispute that the proposal would entail a 96% increase in floorspace,
and an 83% increase in footprint from the original building. The two storey
extensions would wrap around much of the original building and, together
with the single storey element to the northern side, would notably increase
the width of the house on its plot. As a consequence of the proposal, the
main part of the house would have a consistent eaves level above the first
floor and the bulk of the roof form would be substantially increased to
include new prominent gable features to the front and rear, as well as a
central section of flat roof above. Overall, the proposal would result in a very
substantial increase in the size of the property.
8. While the house is located on a generous plot and surrounded by houses of
varying size, including some larger properties, these do not provide reasons
to alter the above assessment under the Framework, which relates to the
size of the extensions relative to the original building. The appellant has
evidenced an appeal decision where extensions were concluded to be
proportionate1. However, that Inspector found those extensions would not
dominate, but would complement the size of the original building, which
would not be the case here.
9. For the reasons given, the proposal would result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building. It would not
conform to the exception to inappropriate development given by the
Framework and would be inappropriate development by definition.
Openness
10. The courts have established that the openness of the Green Belt has a
spatial aspect as well as a visual aspect2. Therefore, the absence of visual
intrusion does not in itself mean that there is no impact on the openness of
the Green Belt.
1 APP/D3640/D/20/3261867- Manx Farm
2 Turner v SSCLG & East Dorset Council [2016] EWCA Civ 466
- Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/24/3347162
11. The Avenue is a residential road with houses of varying scale and design set
within predominantly generous plots. Open countryside surrounds The
Avenue to the east and south. The openness of the surrounding area is
derived from the generous plots of the houses including the spaces around
them and their set backs from the road.
12. The proposal would decrease the spatial aspect of the site’s openness
through increasing the size of the property and the extent of built form on
the site. While limited to localised views from The Avenue, the proposal
would also have visual effects on the Green Belt’s openness due to the
increase in the scale and prominence of the building, including its roof form,
width and coverage of the plot. The proposal would therefore cause harm to
both the spatial and visual aspects of the Green Belt’s openness, and would
conflict with the Green Belt purpose to assist in safeguarding the countryside
from encroachment.
Other Considerations
13. The Framework makes clear that inappropriate development is, by definition,
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. Very special circumstances will not exist unless the potential
harm to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm
resulting from the proposal, is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
14. The appellant has presented a ‘fallback’ position as an alternative should the
appeal scheme be dismissed. This involves exercising permitted development
rights to construct a number of extensions and additions to the site,
including outbuildings. The appellant has obtained relevant lawful
development certificates, and confirmation that prior approval would not be
required3, and I have no reason to believe that these schemes would not
otherwise be implemented if the appeal were to be dismissed. As such there
is a real prospect of the fallback position being implemented.
15. Compared against the original building, together the fallback position,
including outbuildings, would increase the footprint of the building by 246%
and its floorspace by 142%. They would represent increased sprawl across
the site and encroachment into the open rear garden, particularly as a result
of the large proposed outbuilding. By comparison, the appeal scheme would
give a more cohesive design to the building, would focus on extensions
around the original house, and give improved interior spaces for the
occupants.
16. However, while more substantial in their footprint and floorspace, the
extensions of the fallback position would be predominantly single storey with
low eaves levels and located towards the rear of the house. The exception is
the two storey extension to the back of the house, however this would be
fairly modest in its width with a ridge height below the main roof. As a
consequence, the fallback position would have far less visual impact on the
Green Belt’s openness compared to the appeal scheme. In addition, a
significant proportion of the footprint of the fallback scheme would arise from
the large outbuilding. There are not reassurances that this part of the
3 21/0200/CES – two storey rear extension, garage conversion and porch; 21/0207/GPE – ground floor
extension; APP/D3640/X/22/3293629 and APP/D3640/X/22/3293630 – outbuildings.
- Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/24/3347162
fallback scheme could not be carried out as well as the appeal proposal. This
concern could not be adequately addressed by condition, since any condition
would only take effect once the permission were implemented. For these
reasons in combination, the fallback position attracts moderate weight.
17. The appellant has evidenced many other appeal decisions where fallback
positions have been considered4. However, I do not have details of those
proposals or the original buildings to which they related or their contexts. As
such I cannot be satisfied that the same circumstances exist here and those
decisions suggest there were important differences to the appeal scheme.
18. There would be benefits to the appellants arising from the quality of
accommodation which the appeal scheme would provide. However, there is
not substantive evidence to support that the quality of the existing
accommodation is unacceptable or that the proposal is necessary to achieve
an acceptable living standard. Consequently, this benefit attracts little
weight. As houses on The Avenue vary in their scale and design and there is
little consistency, the design of the proposal does not weigh in favour of the
development.
19. The Framework requires that substantial weight is given to any harm to the
Green Belt. Overall, while acknowledging there would be some benefits of
the appeal scheme compared to the fallback position and to the quality of
accommodation, together these do not amount to considerations of sufficient
weight which would clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt, as set out
in the Framework. As a consequence, the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development do not exist.
Other Matters
20. The Council’s case does not refer to any Green Belt policies of the
development plan. However, even if there were no relevant development
plan policies, the application of policies in the Framework which protect
Green Belts provide a clear reason for refusing the development proposed.
The proposal would not, therefore, benefit from the presumption in favour of
sustainable development set out in paragraph 11d) of the Framework.
Conclusion
21. For the above reasons, having taken account of the development plan as a
whole, the approach in the Framework, along with all other relevant material
considerations, the appeal is dismissed.
C Shearing
INSPECTOR
4 APP/Y3615/D/21/3281506- 4 Lime Close, APP/B3438/D/3251032- White Chimneys,
APP/U1240/D/19/3228676- 7 Beech Lane, APP/C1950/D/20/3260570- Heathfield and
APP/B3438/D/20/3246086- 69 Cellarhead Road
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.