Erection of car port/storage incorporating electric charging points
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 August 2024
by A Hickey MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16th September 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/J1915/D/24/3340988
9 High Street, Walkern, Hertfordshire SG2 7PD
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as
amended) against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Iain Budge against the decision of East Hertfordshire District
Council.
• The application Ref is 3/23/2275/HH.
• The development proposed is erection of car port/storage incorporating electric charging
points.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. At the time of my visit, there was a building to the front of the host property.
As this does not reflect the submitted plans, I have considered the appeal as a
proposed scheme and on the basis of the submitted drawings.
3. Reference to the proposed development being ‘part retrospective’ has been
removed in the banner above as this is not an act of development.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are the effect of the development on:
• the character and appearance of the area including the significance of 9 High
Street as a non-designated heritage asset (NDHA) and whether it would
preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Walkern
Conservation Area (WCA); and
• protected trees.
Reasons
Character and appearance and heritage assets
5. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) requires the effect of
an application on the significance of a non-designated heritage asset to be
taken into account when determining the application. A balanced judgement is
required regarding the scale of any harm and the significance of the heritage
asset.
6. 9 High Street (No 9) is a large, detached dwelling constructed of brick with
stone features and a slate roof. The property is set back from High Street by a
well-sized front garden and driveway, but it sits close to Church End. Despite
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/24/3340988
2
being set back from High Street the dwelling occupies a prominent position at
the junction on a main route through the village. The significance of No 9 as an
NDHA is largely derived from its prominent location within a large fairly open
plot to which its surviving historic fabric, pleasing architectural composition,
simple detailing and use of traditional materials all positively contribute.
7. The appeal site is located within the WCA. As such, I have had regard to the
statutory duty to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing its character or appearance. The significance of the WCA,
particularly this part in which the appeal site is located, is derived from the
historic linear pattern of development along the High Street. Along this
route are many listed historic buildings along both sides of the road.
Dwellings in the area are commonly set back from the road and footway
behind gardens with traditional low front boundaries allowing visually
permeable public and private spaces. Consequently, the generally unaltered
historic layout and forms of dwellings and buildings in the area add to the
architectural interest and character of the WCA.
8. The building would be partially screened by well-established trees and planting
but would be visible from short and medium-range views. The carport would
not appear overlarge relative to the overall plot size. Nonetheless, the building
is of a size that would still be a significant addition in this location.
9. Although it would be set back from High Street, the overall scale and form of
the proposed building would be out of character with the established pattern of
development in the area. It would compromise the sense of undeveloped open-
front gardens within the area. The building's scale, height, and location would
result in an incongruous addition in front of the host dwelling. It would thereby
compete visually with the existing property, which would harm the setting of
No 9 as an NDHA.
10. Furthermore, the prominence of the building in this location would be further
emphasised by seasonal leaf fall, gaps and pruning. It therefore follows that
the development proposed would erode the contribution the host dwelling as an
NDHA makes to the WCA, and as a consequence harm to the significance of the
WCA as a designated heritage asset would result.
11. Other detailing, such as the proposed materials, can be found within the area,
such as at Manor Farm and Bridgefoot Farm Barns. They would also be
sympathetic to the character and appearance of the host dwelling as an NDHA.
However, this does not outweigh the harm identified above as a result of scale,
height and location of the building close to the host property in the fairly open
front garden.
12. While additional landscaping could provide further screening, this would take
some time to mature, and it would not be appropriate to condition it. In any
event, should additional landscaping be removed, die or become diseased, the
building would be highly exposed, resulting in harm to the NDHA and the WCA.
Any replacement planting would also take time to mature.
13. For the purposes of the Framework, the WCA is a designated heritage asset.
The proposal would lead to less than substantial harm to the significance of the
WCA. The Framework indicates that such harm is to be weighed against the
public benefits of a proposal. However, great weight should be given to an
asset’s conservation.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/24/3340988
3
14. The appellant is seeking to create a carport and storage space for the occupiers
of No 9. My attention has been drawn to a carport allowed to the front
elevation of the appeal property. While I do not have full details, the evidence
indicates it was in a different location, had an alternative orientation and size
and is therefore materially different from the appeal scheme. Even if I were to
accept vehicles being shielded from view was a public benefit, given the scale
of the scheme, the benefit would be small, and as such, the public benefits do
not outweigh the identified harm in this case.
15. The appeal site is within the setting of several Grade II listed buildings.
Notwithstanding the harm I have already found, the carport would be a
sensitive form of development to these surrounding heritage assets, given its
size and location away from them. This would match the findings of the Council
who have not objected on these grounds.
16. In view of the above, the proposal would have a harmful effect on the
significance of No 9 as an NDHA and would not preserve the character and
appearance of the WCA or the surrounding area. The development would,
therefore, be contrary to East Herts District Plan (DP) Policies HOU11, DES4,
GBR2, HA1 and HA4. Amongst other things, these policies seek to ensure new
development reflects local distinctiveness, including the character and
appearance of the existing dwelling and surrounding area while preserving the
historic environment. The proposal would also conflict with the provisions of the
Framework in regard to conserving and enhancing the historic environment.
Protected trees
17. DP Policy DES3 requires, amongst other things, proposals to demonstrate how
they will retain, protect and enhance existing landscape features which are of
amenity and/or biodiversity value in order to ensure that there is no net loss of
such features.
18. There are mature trees within the appeal site close to the appeal building that
positively contribute to the area's verdant, somewhat rural character. Due to
the trees' substantial size, they likely have an extensive root system. However,
no arboricultural survey report or other appropriate form of evidence has been
submitted, to determine the root protection areas and any associated
mitigation which may be required.
19. During my site visit, I observed that close to the partially constructed building
onsite, the roots of a nearby tree were exposed close to the foundations. I also
observed what appeared to be lopping to branches on the same tree above the
building.
20. Given the proximity of the tree to the appeal scheme, it is not possible for me
to conclude that the proposal would not cause damage to the tree roots.
Furthermore, the loss of, or work detrimental to, the appearance of this
protected tree, which makes a substantial positive contribution, would, in my
view, result in harm to this existing landscape feature.
21. In reaching this view, I have taken the appellant’s comments into
consideration, stating that there has been no adverse impact on the overall
root protection area of surrounding trees given the building erected on site.
However, I cannot be sure there would be no longer lasting effects on the
health of the tree given the exposed roots I observed. Moreover, the proximity
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/24/3340988
4
of the appeal scheme may place future pressure on regularly or extensively
pruning the nearby trees or having them removed altogether.
22. As there is a degree of uncertainty around the effects of the proposal on the
protected trees, the use of conditions would not be appropriate in this case. I
therefore conclude that insufficient information has been provided to
demonstrate that the proposed development would not cause harm to the
protected trees. Accordingly, the proposal would conflict with DP Policy DES3.
Other Matters
23. The proposal is considered acceptable by the Local Planning Authority
regarding the lack of harm upon neighbouring properties and nearby listed
buildings. The appellant has also stated they have received compliments on the
design of the building. Nonetheless, these matters do not outweigh the harms I
have found above.
24. My attention has been drawn to a development on the opposite side of High
Street from the site. However, these buildings would be located close to and
share a similar building line to development found alongside this side of the
road.
Conclusion
25. The proposal conflicts with the development plan when taken as a whole and
there are no material considerations, either individually or in combination, that
outweigh the identified harm and associated development plan conflict.
26. Therefore, I conclude the appeal should be dismissed.
A Hickey
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.