Two storey side extension with new basement plant room below. Replacement of existing windows and doors including new sliding doors to rear elevation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 December 2019
by John Dowsett MA DipURP DipUD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 7th April 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/N5090/D/19/3239926
25 Hill Crescent, London N20 8HB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Richard Calo against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Barnet.
• The application Ref: 19/3919/HSE, dated 16 July 2019, was refused by notice dated
11 September 2019.
• The development proposed is a two storey side extension with new basement plant
room below. Replacement of existing windows and doors including new sliding doors to
rear elevation.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed, and planning permission is granted for a two storey side
extension with new basement plant room below. Replacement of existing
windows and doors including new sliding doors to rear elevation, at 25 Hill
Crescent, London N20 8HB in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref: 19/3919/HSE, dated 16 July 2019, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: Site plan and Site location plan;
018/11/01; 018/11/02; 018/11/03; 018/11/04; 018/11/05; 018/11/06;
018/11/08; 018/11/09; 018/11/10; 018/11/11; 018/11/12; 018/11/13;
018/11/14; and 018/11/15.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Procedural matter
2. The planning application form describes the proposed development as ‘Two
storey side extension, new windows and doors to existing house’. The
submitted drawings also show the provision of a basement plant room below
the front part of the extension and this is reflected in the description on the
decision notice issued by the Council. This more accurately sets out the
development proposed, and I have, therefore, used this for the purposes of the
appeal.
Appeal Decision APP/N5090/D/19/3239926
2
Main Issue
3. The main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposed development on the
character and appearance of the area.
Reasons
4. The appeal building is one half of a pair of two storey, semi-detached, houses
each with a projecting, gabled, front addition with a pitched roof lower than
that over the main part of the house. This results in the pair of houses having
a u-shaped plan. To the side, both the appeal building, and the adjoining
property have an attached garage with a monopitch, lean to, roof. The appeal
building is neither a listed building, nor is it within a conservation area.
5. Policy 7.6 of the London Plan 2016 (the London Plan) expects new development
to be, amongst other things, of the highest architectural quality, to
complement but not necessarily replicate the local architectural character, and
to not unacceptably harm to the amenity of surrounding residential buildings.
Policies CS1 and CS5 of the Barnet Core Strategy 2012 (the Core Strategy) and
Policy DM01 of the Barnet Development Management Policies 2012 (DMDPD),
when taken together, seek to ensure that new development is of a high
standard of design that has regard to its context, taking account of the
appearance, scale, mass, height and pattern of the surrounding buildings.
More detailed design guidance in respect of extensions to houses is found in
the Council’s Residential Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document 2016
(the SPD) which is to be read alongside the more general design policies in the
development plan.
6. Hill Crescent is situated in a predominantly residential area comprised largely
of two storey, detached and semi-detached, houses. A small number of single
storey dwellings are present on the section of the street leading to the junction
with Totteridge Lane. The individual houses vary widely in design and
appearance and there are range of different roof forms present. The external
materials used include, brickwork, render, roughcast and mock Tudor detailing.
The street and the immediately surrounding area are characterised by this
architectural diversity.
7. The SPD sets out that side extensions should be no more than half the width of
the original house; first floor side extensions should normally have a pitched
roof and be set back by 1 metre from the main front wall of the original house,
with the roof to the extension set down by at least 0.5 metres from the ridge of
the main roof; and that there should normally be a minimum gap of 2 metres
between the flank walls of adjacent properties at first floor level. The Council
accepts that the appeal proposal meets all these guidelines, except for that
requiring the first floor element to be set back by 1 metre. The planning
officer’s report concludes that this would result in the proposed extension not
appearing subordinate to the original house, although it does not elaborate
further on this.
8. The SPD sets out that setting back the front wall of side extensions from the
front building line can help to reduce the visual impact on the street scene.
The appeal proposal would add a further 2.4 metres to the side of the existing
projection at the front of the house at first floor level, equivalent to the width
of the existing garage. Although a new section of hipped roof would be added
above this it would, nonetheless, be lower than the ridge of the main roof of
Appeal Decision APP/N5090/D/19/3239926
3
the house. The hipped form of the new roof would also retain the proportions
of the existing gable end to the front projection. The perceived massing of the
resulting building would be broken up due to the proposed use of brickwork on
the ground floor and mock Tudor detailing above, and combined with the
presence of a double height bay window on the existing front projection that
adds a further level of articulation to the façade, the part of the house closest
to the street would not appear excessively wide or visually dominant. As such
it would be a subordinate addition to the original house.
9. Within the street the spacing between dwellings is irregular and the addition of
the side extension would retain the 1 metre separation from the common
boundary with the neighbouring house. I note that the Council has not raised
concerns regarding the extension creating a terracing effect. Hill Crescent
slopes upward from east to west and, due to the change in level between the
appeal building and its neighbour at number 23, I would agree that this would
minimise any perceived terracing effect resulting from the increased width of
the façade at first floor level. The Council also does not object to the proposal
to replace the windows or incorporate glazed, sliding, doors in the rear
elevation. Again, I have no reason to disagree with this position.
10. The SPD is guidance rather than being prescriptive. From the submitted
drawings and from what I saw when I visited the site, I do not find that the
proposed extension would appear overly dominant and would not have the
adverse effect on the street scene that the SPD seeks to avoid by advising first
floor extensions be set back.
11. My attention has been drawn to the existing first floor, side, extensions at 21
and 23 Hill Crescent which are adjacent to the appeal building. I saw that
these do not incorporate a set back at first floor level, but I also note the
Council’s point that different planning policies were in place at the time that
these were granted planning permission. They are, nonetheless, part of the
current street scene. I also observed during my site visit that there are other
properties in the street that have been extended and which do have stepped
back upper floors. I do not have the full details of any of these schemes, or
the circumstances that led to them being accepted, and so cannot determine
whether or not they are similar to those in respect of the proposal that is
before me. In any event, each application and appeal should be considered on
its own merits. As a result of the architectural diversity of Hill Crescent and the
range of house designs, the differences in façade treatment are part of the
character of the street and there is no one, dominant, approach that has been
adopted to extending the houses. As I have found above, the appeal proposal
would not result in an extension that would appear over-dominant or
disproportionately large in respect of the original house.
12. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would not cause harm to
the character and appearance of the area. It would comply with the relevant
requirements of Policy 7.6 of the London Plan; Core Strategy Policies CS1 and
CS5; and Policy DM01 of the DMDPD. It would also conform broadly to the
requirements of the SPD.
Other matters
13. The Council has not raised any concerns regarding the effect of the proposed
extension on the living conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring houses.
From what I have read, my consideration of the submitted drawings, and from
Appeal Decision APP/N5090/D/19/3239926
4
what I saw when I visited the site, I have no reason to reach a different
conclusion.
Conditions
14. I have had regard to the conditions that have been suggested by the Council.
In order to provide certainty as to what has been granted planning permission,
I have attached a condition specifying the approved drawings. In the interests
of the appearance of the building and the surrounding area it is also necessary
to impose a condition requiring that the approved development be constructed
using materials that match the existing building.
15. Although the Council has not included it as a suggested condition on the appeal
questionnaire, Section 8 of the Council officer’s report lists suggested
conditions in the event of an appeal that include, in addition to the above
conditions, a suggested condition which would remove the permitted
development rights to create new door or window openings in the side
elevation of the extension facing 23 Hill Crescent. The reason given for this
condition is to safeguard the privacy and amenities of occupiers of adjoining
residential properties. The National Planning Policy Framework states that
planning conditions should not be used to restrict national permitted
development rights unless there is clear justification to do so. From the
evidence, and from what I saw when I visited the site, there are no windows
serving habitable rooms in the side elevation of number 23 Hill Crescent.
Whilst DMDPD Policy DM01 expects new development to be designed to allow
for adequate privacy for adjoining occupiers, there is no substantive evidence
that indicates that the development as currently proposed would not do so.
16. All the new and extended rooms within the proposed extension have windows
on either the front or rear elevations of the building, apart from a downstairs
shower room and a first floor ensuite bathroom, both of which would as a
matter of course have opaque glazed windows. There is no evidence that
would suggest that the rooms within the proposed extension would not receive
adequate daylight. The suggested condition appears to arise from a
generalised concern rather than to address a specific reason that would
otherwise make it necessary to refuse planning permission. Consequently, I do
not find that such condition is necessary, and have not imposed it.
Conclusion
17. For the above reasons, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
John Dowsett
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.