Erection of a rear roof extension with Juliet balcony, two roof windows to front elevation, erection of a rear outrigger roof extension and roof terrace
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Noise & Disturbance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 January 2020
by JP Tudor BA (Hons), Solicitor (non-practising)
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 January 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/F5540/D/19/3238849
138A Whitestile Road, Brentford TW8 9NW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Miss Joanna Hayes against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Hounslow.
• The application Ref: 01201/138A/P1, dated 4 June 2019, was refused by notice dated
30 July 2019.
• The development proposed is erection of a rear roof extension with Juliet balcony, two
roof windows to front elevation, erection of a rear outrigger roof extension and roof
terrace.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. I have taken the description of development in the banner heading above from
the Council’s decision notice, as it more fully and accurately describes the
development than that contained in the planning application form.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
• the character and appearance of the host building and the area; and,
• the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, with particular regard to
privacy, noise and disturbance.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal property is a modest two storey mid-terrace house located in a
residential area. The house has been divided into two flats. The proposal
relates to the first floor flat.
5. It is proposed to erect a rear dormer roof extension across much of the width
of the house. In addition, the existing flat roof of the outrigger would be clad
in timber decking for use as a sizeable roof terrace/garden, accessed via patio
doors from the new dormer. In order to protect the privacy of neighbouring
residents, the roof terrace would be surrounded by a 1.8m high opaque glazed
screen.
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/19/3238849
2
6. The Council refers to section 4.10 of its Residential Extension Guidelines:
Supplementary Planning Document (REG)1, which states that: ‘The Council will
normally refuse roof extensions that would be as wide as the house and create
the appearance of a large box.’ Referring to the specific guidance in the
relevant section of the REG, the Council Officer’s report states: ‘While the
proposed dormer would incorporate the recommended set-up from the eaves of
0.5m, and set-down from the ridge of 0.3m, it would not demonstrate set-in’s
from the side of the roof, therefore not complying with section 4.10’. While I
note that analysis, the submitted plans2 clearly show a set-in of 0.5m from the
sides of the roof, as recommended in the REG. Rather, the area of non-
compliance with the REG relates to the requirement for the dormer to be 0.5m
above eaves level. In this case, it appears that the proposed dormer would not
be ‘set-up’ from the existing eaves level, adjacent to the outrigger.
7. Notwithstanding the above, the Council indicated that, in any case, given the
number and variety of existing sizeable rear dormer extensions on nearby
houses many of which, it suggests, benefited from permitted development
rights, it did not consider that the dormer element of the proposal would cause
harm to the character and appearance of the area. Based on my site visit and
my own observations of other rear dormers along the terrace and in the area, I
take a similar view in that regard.
8. However, the more problematic aspect of the proposal relates to the proposed
1.8m high opaque glazed screen which would enclose the large roof terrace on
three sides. The terrace or roof garden would occupy the whole of the flat roof
of the existing outrigger which is sizeable, amounting to some 16.28m2
according to the Council. The extent and height of the screening, necessary to
prevent overlooking of neighbouring properties, would appear prominent at
second floor level and add to the height of the outrigger, diminishing its
subordination to the main building and causing visual harm.
9. Given the density of terraced housing in the immediate area, the extensive
screening would be visible from many surrounding properties and their
gardens, including that of the flat below. There would also be views, albeit
more distant, from the rear upper storeys and back gardens of houses to the
north. Although the screening would be at the rear of the property and not
affect public views, given the height and extent and the absence of similar
screening in the immediate area, those elements of the proposal would appear
discordant and be likely to draw the eye of neighbouring occupiers
10. While there are a variety of roof forms and large dormers in the area and many
of the outriggers are gable-ended rather than flat-roofed, I did not see any
screening of a similar type or scale to that proposed or, indeed, any roof
terrace gardens, and none have been cited by the appellant. Therefore, the
privacy screening would form a prominent and incongruous feature which
would adversely affect the host building and the area.
11. The minor set-back of the screens from the existing coping would not
sufficiently mitigate their negative effect. The appellant would accept a
condition requiring details of materials to be approved. However, given that
the height and opaque nature of the screens is necessary to prevent
1 Adopted 20 December 2017
2 Drawing No 2015JJ03
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/19/3238849
3
overlooking from an elevated outdoor position into neighbouring properties and
gardens, I do not see that such a condition could sufficiently mitigate the
adverse visual effects.
12. I conclude, therefore, that the proposed development, with particular reference
to the privacy screens, would harm the character and appearance of the host
building and the area. Consequently, the proposal would conflict with policies
CC1, CC2 and SC7 of the Council’s Local Plan 2015-2030 (LP)3, which seek to
promote high quality urban design and ensure that development, including
residential extensions and alterations, responds appropriately to the context
and character of an area. It would also be contrary to similar policy objectives
within the London Plan and the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework)4, such as paragraph 127(c).
Living conditions of neighbouring occupiers
13. The Council expresses concern that the proposed roof terrace would lead to a
loss of privacy and cause noise and disturbance to neighbours. It refers again
to LP policy SC7 which, amongst other things, seeks to ensure that residential
extensions and alterations do not harm the amenity of neighbouring residents.
Section 4.10 of the REG indicates that the Council will normally refuse roof
terraces because they can lead to loss of privacy for neighbours.
14. Although it recognises that the roof terrace would incorporate privacy screens,
the Council appears to consider that there would still be ‘the potential for loss
of privacy and perceived loss of privacy due to the proximity to neighbouring
properties’. While I note the Council’s assessment, I am satisfied that the
proposed opaque 1.8m high privacy screens would sufficiently prevent intrusive
overlooking from the roof terrace. Nor do I think that, given the prominence,
height and opacity of the screens and their second-floor location, nearby
occupiers would be left with any reasonable perception of being overlooked.
The retention of the privacy screens for the lifetime of the development could
be secured by condition.
15. As accepted by the Council, windows within the dormer would not significantly
increase the level of overlooking beyond that which might be reasonably
expected from upper floor windows of houses along terraces in suburban areas.
16. The Council also refers to potential noise and disturbance emanating from the
roof terrace, although little explanation is given to justify that concern. I do
not consider that there is any reason to suppose that the level of noise from
the use of the roof terrace should be any greater than that associated with
existing residential gardens, which serve the properties along the terrace. The
privacy screen panels should also mitigate any noise to some extent.
Moreover, other legislation is available to deal with excessive noise or
nuisance, should it arise.
17. Accordingly, I conclude that the proposed development would not have a
significant adverse effect on the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers,
with particular regard to privacy or noise and disturbance. Therefore, it would
not conflict with policies CC2 or SC7 of the LP or other local and national policy
3 Adopted 15 September 2015
4 February 2019
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/19/3238849
4
and guidance, insofar as they seek to ensure that development does not result
in harm to the living conditions of neighbouring residents.
Planning Balance and Conclusion
18. Although there would not be harm to the living conditions of neighbouring
occupiers, the harm caused by the scale and location of the privacy screens to
the character and appearance of the host building and the area, is decisive.
19. While I note that the extension would provide additional indoor and some
outdoor living space for residents of the first floor flat, those benefits are
essentially private benefits. The planning system is more generally focussed
on the wider public interest than personal or private benefits. In any case, the
benefits would not outweigh the harm caused. Furthermore, it may be that an
alternative scheme could secure similar advantages without causing harm.
20. The harm would result from the necessary privacy screens and neither the
Council nor I have significant objections to the dormer element of the
extension. However, the proposed design, with patio windows intended to give
access to the roof terrace, does not lend itself to the possibility of a split
decision, omitting the roof terrace element and screens. Nor has the appellant
expressed any interest in that possibility in her appeal statement, which seeks
to justify the scheme as proposed. Consequently, it would not be possible or
appropriate for me to exercise my discretion in that regard.
21. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
JP Tudor
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.