Dropped kerb and parking space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Highways & Transport
Parking Provision
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 14 October 2019
by Graeme Robbie BA(Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 18 October 2019
Appeal A
Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/19/3236817
149 Halifax Road, Brighouse HD6 2EQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Helen Marsden against the decision of Calderdale
Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The application Ref 19/00273/HSE, dated 28 February 2019, was refused by notice
dated 3 July 2019.
• The development proposed is dropped kerb and parking space.
Appeal B
Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/19/3236818
151 Halifax Road, Brighouse HD6 2EQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Mark Nicholl against the decision of Calderdale Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 19/00380/HSE, dated 27 March 2019, was refused by notice
dated 3 July 2019.
• The development proposed is dropped kerb and parking space.
Decisions
Appeal A
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal B
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
3. I have adopted the development descriptions set out on the Council’s decision
notice and subsequently adopted in the appeal submissions as I consider them
to be notably more concise and accurate in describing the proposals than those
initially set out. I am satisfied that neither appellant, nor the Council, would be
disadvantaged by my doing so and I have determined the appeal accordingly.
4. The appeal properties are adjoining halves of a semi-detached property
fronting on to the A644 Halifax Road. The proposals were submitted to the
Council as two separate planning applications, each proposing a dropped kerb
and vehicular access to the front of the house. Each proposal relies upon land
beyond its application site boundary and thus within the adjoining property to
provide manoeuvring space and for access and egress.
Appeal Decisions APP/A4710/D/19/3236817 and APP/A4710/D/19/3236818
2
5. I am satisfied that whilst the proposals proceed under separate appeals and
relate to separate appeal sites they can nonetheless be dealt with together for
the purposes of my decisions due to their proximity to each other and the
appellants’ intended inter-relationship between and reliance of one upon the
other. Where necessary I will differentiate between the appeals by specific
reference to one or the other.
6. The application forms state that neither appeal proposal has commenced,
although the Council’s officer reports note that the boundary walls at the front
of both properties had been removed and materials delivered. At the time of
my visit to the site I saw that the front garden areas of the two properties had
been laid to hard surface with a planting border abutting the front of the house.
I have, for the avoidance of doubt, determined the appeal on the basis of the
submitted plans and details and not on the basis of the works carried out.
Main Issue
7. The main issue in relation to both appeals is the effect of the proposals on
highway safety.
Reasons
8. The appeal properties are one of four pairs of semi-detached dwellings along a
short stretch of Halifax Road, each pair separated from the next by a narrow
gap. In the case of No. 151 (and No. 153) this gap leads through to rear
gardens and provides access to a garage, parking and turning area at the rear
of No. 151. Although No. 149 has a similarly proportioned gap between it and
No. 147, there is a clear difference in ground levels between the two and,
whilst access to the rear exists, it is in the form of a footpath rather than a
shared drive.
9. Due to the relatively narrow nature of each of the appeal plots, I share the
Council’s concern that there would be insufficient space within each to
manoeuvre so as to be able to leave and enter Halifax Road in a forward
direction. Halifax Road was, I saw during my visit to the sites, a busy road.
Given the nature of the boundary walls and vegetation at the fronts of
neighbouring properties and the slight curve and gradient in the road a short
distance to the south which, together, restrict visibility in both directions, an
inability to leave and enter the highway in this manner would result in conflict
with other road users which would be detrimental to highway safety.
10. However, each of the proposals seeks to rely on land within the adjoining half
of the semi-detached plot to facilitate sufficient manoeuvring space. A swept-
path analysis in respect of both properties attempts to demonstrate the
practicalities of how this would be achieved. It is, as far as it goes, reasonably
successful in demonstrating how access and egress in a forward direction to
each of the properties could be achieved. It also demonstrates how it would be
possible to do so even with another vehicle parked at the neighbouring
property.
11. It does not however model every direction of acces and thus does not
demonstrate access to No.149 from the north or to No. 151 from the south.
Nor does it appear to allow for situations when there might be a second car
within each of the plots being accessed. In both of these instances, the
relative lack of width within each of the garden plots, and indeed cumulatively,
Appeal Decisions APP/A4710/D/19/3236817 and APP/A4710/D/19/3236818
3
is such that I am not persuaded that the proposals would allow forward access
and egress to each property in all circumstances. The indicated green inset on
the site layout plans would further impinge upon the available parking and
manoeuvring space and would further compromise the range of movements
possible within the proposed parking forecourt area.
12. Crucially however, each appeal proposal is dependent upon land beyond each
application site boundary to provide turning and manoeuvring space. Even if I
were to conclude that the swept-path analysis adequately demonstrates
unimpeded forward access and egress to both properties from both directions,
the applications are separate and I have no mechanism before me to be able to
ensure that the development is carried out as one scheme, and subsequently
maintained as such to ensure safe and convenient access. Nor, should I be so
minded, am I persuaded that a planning condition placed on any approval
would be reasonably enforceable so as to ensure both schemes are carried out
and implemented.
13. Policy BE5 of the Replacement Calderdale Unitary Development Plan (2006)
(RCUDP) states that, amongst other things, accesses should ensure the safe
and free flow of traffic. For the reasons I have set out above, it has not been
adequately demonstrated that the proposals would, or could, ensure the safe
and free flow of traffic. Thus, the proposals are contrary to RCUDP policy
BE5(i).
14. It is also evident from the limited swept-path analysis that access in the
manner proposed would be reliant on the majority of the width of both
properties’ frontages providing access to the forecourt areas. This, the
appellants argue, would improve visibility for neighbours and users of the
Sycamore View junction. However, whilst it is likely that this area is most
commonly used by the appellants as it lies directly outside their properties, this
cannot be guaranteed and any benefit would be limited and sporadic.
15. In any event, I saw that intervening vegetation and stone wall structures on
neighbouring properties, not to mention the possibility of cars parking between
the junction with Sycamore View and the appeal properties, would continue to
have a significant impact on visibility in a northern direction from this junction
and more so than potential gaps in parked vehicles further along Halifax Road.
This aspect of the appeal proposals would not result in a material improvement
in this respect.
16. I have noted the appellant’s1 stated desire to switch to an electric vehicle and
that the proposal would future proof the property by facilitating convenient
charging of an electric vehicle. Whilst this would weigh in support of the
proposal, it would only attract limited weight and would not be sufficient to
overcome the harm that I have identified above.
17. I saw, and was also referred to, other driveway accesses to nearby properties
on Halifax Road. However, these examples exhibited different access
arrangements to those proposed in the current appeal cases, nor do I have the
full details of those proposals before me. I have, in any event, determined the
appeals on the basis of the available evidence and on their own merits and so I
give the presence of other accesses limited weight in my consideration of the
matter.
1 Paragraphs 6.11 – 6.12 – Appellant’s Statement of Case in respect of No. 149 ( APP/A4710/D/19/3236817)
Appeal Decisions APP/A4710/D/19/3236817 and APP/A4710/D/19/3236818
4
18. The Council are concerned that the proposal would displace parking in an area
where on-street parking can be in high demand. I accept that there is no off-
street parking associated with Lane Head Park, but I saw that alternative
parking is available elsewhere along Halifax Road, and on less busy streets
such as Garden Road and other streets on the southern side of the park. There
may be times of the day (and year) when usage of the park is greater than
others, but I am not persuaded that the loss of on-street parking on Halifax
Road that would result from these proposals would be a determinative factor in
this instance.
Conclusion
19. For the reasons set out, and having considered all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeals should be dismissed.
Graeme Robbie
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.