Removal of existing garage, construction of 2-storey side extension and loft conversion, new side entrance
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 January 2020
by Martin Small, BA (Hons), BPl, DipCM, MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17th January 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/A2280/D/19/3236155
20 Slade Close, Lordswood, Chatham, ME5 8RD
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs M Negus against the decision of The Medway Council.
• The application Ref: MC/19/0124 dated 16 January 2019, was refused by notice dated
12 July 2019.
• The development proposed is the removal of existing garage, construction of 2-storey
side extension and loft conversion, new side entrance.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the area, with particular regard to trees.
Reasons
3. The appeal property has a number of trees and shrubs within the garden,
including 3 mature beech trees and 2 common yews. These trees contribute
significantly to the character and appearance of the area due to their form and,
in the case of the beech trees, substantial height. The trees are very visible
from Slade Close and, together with the woodland to the rear of the appeal
property, provide a sylvan setting for the property and that part of Slade Close
in which it is located.
4. The contribution of the 3 beech trees to the amenity of the area is recognised
by their being covered by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO). In accordance with
Table 1 Cascade chart for tree quality assessment in BS5837:2012 ‘Trees in
relation to design, demolition and construction – Recommendations’ (BS 5837),
these trees are assessed as Category B in the Arboricultural Impact
Assessment (AIA) by Greenwood Arboriculture submitted by the appellant. A
yew in the front garden is also categorised as B.
5. Category B trees are those that are of moderate quality with an estimated
remaining life expectancy of at least 20 years. These four trees therefore have
the potential to continue contributing positively to the character and
appearance of the area for many years to come and their retention and
protection is thus important.
Appeal Decision APP/A2280/D/19/3236155
2
6. The proposed development includes the demolition of an existing garage
attached to the side of the main dwelling between the dwelling and the closest
of the 3 beech trees, and the construction of a 2-storey extension in its place.
The submitted plans indicate that the extension would be constructed within
the footprint of the existing garage with the side wall of the extension slightly
further away from the beech trees.
7. Nevertheless, although the 3 beech trees are not indicated as being to be
removed on the Tree Protection Plan, the Plan shows that the proposed
extension would be within the Root Protection Area (RPA) of each of the 3
trees, and that of the yew to the front of the property, as is the existing
garage. Paragraph 2.3.1 of the AIA indicates that the RPA should be regarded
as a ‘construction exclusion zone’, which should be considered ‘sacrosanct’.
Table 2 ‘Summary of Arboricultural Impacts’ of the AIA identifies only the
erection of protective fencing within the RPA as potentially affecting the
Category B trees.
8. However, from the evidence before me, excavation will need to take place
within the RPA to construct the foundations of the proposed extension. The
email from the appellant’s architect dated 12 June 2019 confirms that the
intention is to retain the footings of the garage in situ and construct new
footings for the proposed extension closer to the dwelling. Paragraph 3.1.5 of
the AIA and Drawing 521 Rev A both refer to excavation within the RPA being
carried out following an arboricultural method statement and under
arboricultural supervision.
9. However, I have no detailed drawings of the existing foundations of the garage
or the proposed foundations of the extension or other information regarding
their nature and depth. Nor is there is any specific consideration within the AIA
of the potential effect on the trees on the site of the excavation for and
construction of the foundations for the proposed extension.
10. Table B.1 of BS 5837 advises on the appropriate level of information required
to enable a local planning authority to properly consider the implications and
effects of a development proposal. The advice is categorised as ‘Minimum
detail’ and ‘Additional information’, the latter being further details that might
reasonably be sought, “especially where any construction is proposed within
the RPA”. The ‘Additional information’ includes “Details for all special
engineering within the RPA and other relevant construction details”. From the
evidence before me, these details have not been provided.
11. The appellant suggests that details of the foundations could be the subject of a
condition were permission to be granted. However, BS 5837 indicates that
these details should be provided before an application is determined, and I
consider it necessary to do so to demonstrate satisfactorily that the
foundations of the proposed extension could be constructed without harm to
the trees on the site.
12. The appellant refers to “Building Near Trees”, which is Chapter 4.2 in the NHBC
Standards and contains guidance on foundations when building near trees. The
appellant has not drawn my attention to any specific guidance in this chapter
but I note that the guidance on tree roots in sub-section 4.2 - D3 (b) refers to
BS 5837 for further guidance. The guidance in this chapter does not provide
the specific information that I have identified above is required in relation to
the proposed development before me.
Appeal Decision APP/A2280/D/19/3236155
3
13. Whilst the Council has not provided its own arboricultural evidence that the
trees would be harmed, in my view the onus is upon the appellant to provide
sufficient information to demonstrate that the proposed development would not
significantly adversely affect the trees on the site in accordance with BS 5837.
This information should be provided so that an informed decision can be made
having regard to the potential effect on the trees, regardless of whether the
Council has the capability to assess such information in-house or would need
external advice to do so.
14. I have considered whether a planning condition requiring the proposed
development to be undertaken in accordance with the recommendations in the
AIA as suggested by the Council were planning permission to be granted would
provide adequate safeguards for the protected trees. However, in my
judgement, the advice on development in RPAs within the AIA is generic and
insufficiently specific regarding the foundations of the proposed development
for me to be confident that such a condition would be effective in protecting the
trees from possible harm arising from excavations within their RPA.
15. I therefore conclude that, notwithstanding the conclusion of Greenwood
Arboriculture that the overall impact of the proposed development would not be
detrimental to the retained trees’ condition or amenity value provided the
recommendations in the AIA are followed, the appellant has not satisfactorily
demonstrated how the proposed development would avoid significantly
adversely affecting these important trees through excavation and the
construction of foundations within their RPA.
16. Without that demonstration, I cannot be confident that the development would
comply with Policy BNE45 of the Medway Local Plan (2003), which requires
development to seek the retention of trees that provide a valuable contribution
to local character, and with paragraph 170 of the National Planning Policy
Framework, which requires planning decisions to contribute to and enhance the
natural and local environment by, amongst other things, recognising the
benefits of trees.
Other Matters
17. I note that the Council considered a site visit with the Council’s Tree Officer to
not be necessary as set out in the email from the Council’s Planning Officer to
the appellant’s architect dated 19 June 2019. I am not persuaded that a site
visit in the absence of the information requested by the Council would have led
to the proposed development being approved and I therefore give the refusal
for a site visit little weight in my determination of this appeal in this instance.
Conclusion
18. For the reasons given above, and having regard to the other matters raised,
the appeal is dismissed.
Martin Small
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.