Erection of ancillary building to provide garages, storage and gym, together with new parking area
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 29 October 2019
by Patrick Hanna MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23rd December 2019
Appeal A Ref: APP/U1430/D/19/3231672
Fordlands, Crowhurst Road, Catsfield TN33 9BT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs M Lear against the decision of Rother District Council.
• The application Ref RR/2019/350/P, dated 12 February 2019, was refused by notice
dated 8 April 2019.
• The development proposed is erection of ancillary building to provide garages, storage,
gym and guest accommodation, together with new parking area.
Appeal B Ref: APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
Fordlands, Crowhurst Road, Catsfield TN33 9BT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs M Lear against the decision of Rother District Council.
• The application Ref RR/2019/1236/P, dated 15 May 2019, was refused by notice dated
11 July 2019.
• The development proposed is erection of ancillary building to provide garages, storage
and gym, together with new parking area.
Decision Appeal A
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Decision Appeal B
2. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for erection of
ancillary building to provide garages, storage and gym, together with new
parking area at Fordlands, Crowhurst Road, Catsfield TN33 9BT in accordance
with the terms of the application, Ref RR/2019/1236/P, dated 15 May 2019,
subject to the conditions in the attached schedule.
Application for costs
3. An application for costs was made by Mr & Mrs M Lear against Rother District
Council in respect of Appeal B. This application is the subject of a separate
decision.
Procedural Matters
4. There are two appeals on this site. They differ only in design and proposed use.
I have considered each proposal on its merits. However, I have dealt with the
two schemes in one decision to avoid repetition.
Appeal Decisions APP/U1430/D/19/3231672 & APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
2
Main Issues
5. The main issues are:
(a) for appeal A, whether or not the proposed development would be in an
appropriate location, with particular regard to protecting the countryside
and accessibility to employment and services; and
(b) for both appeals, the effect of the proposals on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and surrounding area, with particular
regard to siting, scale, and design.
Reasons
6. The appeal site is within the substantial and private garden of an unlisted
country manor house, within a mature landscape setting. The ground slopes
down towards the south, affording distant views from the house and the appeal
site over the garden and wider countryside. The house and appeal site are
accessed via a sweeping driveway from the east. The effect of both proposals
would be to introduce an ancillary building within the grounds, sited along the
driveway and main entrance leading to the property.
Location
7. Notwithstanding the description of the application, Appeal A has been assessed
by the Council as tantamount to the erection of a new dwelling and determined
against policy RA3(iii) of the Rother Local Plan Core Strategy (2014)(CS) which
relates to new residential development in the countryside. The proposal may be
some 36 metres distant from the house, however this would not be a long walk
for guests. Furthermore, at my site visit I observed a visual link between the
proposal and the conservatory of the host dwelling, such that there would not
be full visual separation. Rather than the intervening landscaping creating a
visual barrier, I found it would assist in ensuring that the proposed building
would settle into its surroundings.
8. Whilst the proposed parking area would be associated with the outbuilding, it
would not be seen as necessarily serving the ancillary accommodation. Rather,
it would be viewed in the context of the garage entrance, and it is not unusual
for a large country house to require parking and garaging for multiple vehicles.
In terms of the accommodation provided, the sitting room, bedroom and
shower room represents relatively modest accommodation and, in the context
of the main house, is again not untypical of such guest accommodation. In the
absence of kitchen facilities, the proposal could not in normal circumstances be
occupied independently from the main dwelling. Furthermore, the proposal
would share access arrangements with the main house, and there is no
evidence to suggest any subdivision of the wider garden. Given these
circumstances, I find that the proposed guest accommodation is not
tantamount to a new dwelling. It follows that occupants would be guests not
requiring any access to employment and services.
9. With regard to appeal A, I conclude that the proposed development would be in
an appropriate location, with particular regard to protecting the countryside
and accessibility to employment and services. As such, the proposal accords
with policies RA3(iii), OSS3(x) and TR3 of the CS, and paragraph 8 of the
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). Amongst other matters,
these policies restrict new dwellings in the countryside except in limited
Appeal Decisions APP/U1430/D/19/3231672 & APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
3
circumstances, and require new dwellings to have access to employment
opportunities and services to ensure the need to travel is minimised.
Character and appearance
10. Appeal B is for a 4-bay garage with level vehicular access from the driveway
provided at upper ground floor level. Whilst the pitched roof is slightly larger
than would otherwise be expected, the building would read visually from the
driveway simply as being a large garage commensurate with a large country
house. The siting is such that the lower-ground level containing tractor store
and gym would be partially hidden from view on the approach along the
driveway. Whilst from the south the building would appear more pronounced,
being two storeys in height, the proposal would still be seen as a simple, albeit
large, outbuilding serving the much larger house, set against a backcloth of the
rising garden. Overall, the design reflects its function as a general-purpose
outbuilding, rather than as a dwelling, emphasised by the use of blind windows
on the rear elevation.
11. The building integrates comfortably with the topography of the site and utilises
sloped ground to minimise visual impact. Modest earthworks and retaining
walls define the car parking area, already constructed at the time of my site
visit, opposite the proposed building. Neither the dwelling nor the countryside
are subject to any protective designations. The enclosure of the host dwelling
and appeal proposal within mature landscape screening ensures that no harm
is caused to the host dwelling, its setting, or to the surrounding countryside.
12. I conclude that Appeal B would not have an adverse effect on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding area, with particular
regard to siting, scale, and design. As such, the proposal would comply with
policies OSS3 (vi), OSS4(iii), EN1, EN3, RA2(viii) and RA3 of the CS, policies
DEN1 and DHG9(ii), (iii), and (vii) of the emerging Rother District Council
Development and Site Allocations Local Plan, which are not substantially
different to adopted policies in respect of this proposal, and paragraphs 127
and 170 of the Framework. Together these policies require high quality design
which contributes positively to the character of its surroundings and landscape.
13. Turning to Appeal A, this is a more substantial building. Whilst the dormers to
front and rear are single, they are substantial in size, particularly to the front
where the dormer extends to the full depth of the roofscape. The cheek of the
dormer will be dominant in the view as seen from the approach road. The lower
level is approximately double the size of the upper and, whilst much of this is
underground, there is a consequential and substantial increase in hardstanding
at lower levels, along with the introduction of substantial retaining walls.
14. Together, these elements combine to create a much more visually substantive
building that would no longer appear as a simple large outbuilding. Instead, the
proposal would have a demonstrably urbanising effect, which is inappropriate
in the context of the rural country house, notwithstanding that it would have no
adverse effect on the wider landscape or public views. Overall, these elements
tip the balance of the proposal into being unacceptable. The removal of
chimneys by condition would not be sufficient to mitigate this harm.
15. I conclude that Appeal A would have a significant adverse effect on the
character and appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding area, with
Appeal Decisions APP/U1430/D/19/3231672 & APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
4
particular regard to siting, scale, and design. The proposal would conflict with
the same policies identified above.
Other matters
16. With regard to Appeal B, whilst concerns have been raised in respect of
potential future conversion of the proposed outbuilding, I must consider the
appeal on its merits and as submitted. It is understood that tree removal has
occurred to facilitate the development, however I have not been provided with
any evidence that such trees were statutorily protected. Although it is
suggested that the proposal is not within the host dwelling’s garden, no
evidence has been provided that the site is not within the curtilage.
17. The Council cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply, however,
given my above findings that Appeal A would not be tantamount to a new
dwelling, paragraph 11(d) of the Framework is not engaged.
Conclusion Appeal A
18. I have found that the proposal would be in an appropriate location, with
particular regard to protecting the countryside and accessibility to employment
and services. However, this is outweighed by the significant adverse effect of
the proposal on the character and appearance of the area. I conclude that
Appeal A should be dismissed.
Conclusion Appeal B
19. A condition defining the plans is necessary in the interests of certainty. To
ensure the development is in keeping with the host property and its
surroundings, a condition is also required regarding materials. For the reasons
given above, and having had regard to all other matters raised, I conclude that
Appeal B should be allowed.
Patrick Hanna
INSPECTOR
Schedule of conditions for Appeal B (Ref: APP/U1430/D/19/3235396)
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 5987/102/LBP Location Block Plan
(May 2019); 5987/102/1 Proposed Garage Block (April 2019); and
5987/102/2 Proposed Site Plan (April 2019).
3) The external surfaces of the development hereby permitted shall be
constructed in materials to match the host building.
End of schedule
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 29 October 2019
by Patrick Hanna MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23rd December 2019
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
Fordlands, Crowhurst Road, Catsfield TN33 9BT
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr & Mrs M Lear for a full award of costs against Rother
District Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for erection of ancillary
building to provide garages, storage and gym, together with new parking area.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. Paragraph 030 of the Planning Practice Guidance advises that costs may be
awarded where a party has behaved unreasonably and the unreasonable
behaviour has directly caused another party to incur unnecessary or wasted
expense in the appeal process.
3. Paragraph 049 of the Planning Practice Guidance gives examples of the type of
behaviour by local planning authorities that may constitute unreasonable
behaviour, including not determining similar cases in a consistent manner.
4. The appellant states that the appeal was unnecessary as the proposal is similar
to a case where planning permission was granted for an outbuilding at Magpies
Parlour, Burwash Weald, East Sussex.
5. From the evidence provided, although the outbuilding at Magpies Parlour is also
a garage, both the form of the building and the context of its siting are quite
different from that at Fordlands. Notwithstanding that I found the Fordlands
garage to be acceptable, it is nonetheless a two-storey building that is
considerably larger than the single storey building, albeit with attic storage, at
Magpies Parlour. Contextually, the appeal site relates to sloping land within the
expansive grounds of a country house, the evidence suggests Magpies Parlour
is flat elevated land within a more tightly knit grouping of dwellings.
6. Whilst I ultimately reached a different conclusion to the Council on the overall
merits of the appeal proposal, I do not consider that the Council failed to
properly evaluate the application with particular regard to the circumstances of
Magpies Parlour. Rather, the Council had reasonable concerns about the impact
of the proposed development and appropriately justified its decision.
Costs Decision APP/U1430/D/19/3235396
2
Conclusion
7. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has not been
demonstrated.
Patrick Hanna
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.