Proposed two storey side and rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 October 2019
by Alison Scott BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 7 November 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/Z5060/D/19/3234131
180 Wood Lane, Dagenham RM9 5SS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Roma Tabu against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Barking and Dagenham.
• The application Ref 19/00561/FUL, dated 27 March 2019, was refused by notice dated
13 June 2019.
• The development proposed is described as a proposed two storey side and rear
extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
• The effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of
the area; and,
• The effect of the proposed development on the living conditions of the
occupiers of 178 Wood Lane having particular regard to outlook.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
3. The appeal site forms an end dwelling of a terrace of four, two-storey houses
within a pedestrian cul-de-sac of similar houses known locally as a ‘banjo’
within the Becontree Estate, built between 1921 and 1934. The estate is of
local importance due to fact that at the time, it was the largest public housing
scheme in Britain. The appeal site and neighbouring No.182 Wood Lane sit
perpendicular to one another. The appeal site is positioned in a corner and
benefits from having a large garden to the rear of the property.
4. The dwelling has previously been extended to the side and rear by a single
storey wrap around extension, with the side extension set back from the front
building line of the dwelling. The proposed development seeks to replace this
extension with a two-storey part side and rear extension to include a single
storey extension, together with a front porch.
Appeal Decision APP/Z5060/D/19/3234131
2
5. Although the proposed two-storey side extension would be set back from the
front building line, it would be visible within the street scene given its width
and height in this corner position. The eaves line would carry through to meet
the host eaves, however the proposed roof configuration would be at odds with
the host dwelling as it is designed as a hipped roof. The roof of the host
dwelling has been altered to a gable end, and whilst this has reduced the
symmetry of the terrace, the addition of this extension would further
emphasise the imbalance to the terrace. In addition, there is no fenestration or
design features to be introduced to the façade facing the street scene to break
up its massing.
6. On this basis, the extension would appear as an out of character addition to the
property and would be a prominent and incongruous feature within the street
scene that would compromise the character and appearance of the area as a
result.
7. None of the proposed rear development would be visible to the public domain.
However, the extension would project approximately 5.7m from the host rear
building line. The Council’s adopted 2012 Residential Extensions and Alterations
Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) advises rear single storey extensions
should not normally exceed 3.65m. The combination of extensions to the rear
of the dwelling would exceed the design guidance within the SPD and even with
the use of matching materials, the development would visually dominate the
proportions of the host dwelling and would not complement the host dwelling,
which would in turn be harmful to its character.
8. An extension has been erected to the side and rear of 174 Wood Lane and
brought to my attention by the appellant. The extension is not directly
comparable as that extension is set further back from the front building line of
the host dwelling, it is less wide than the proposed appeal development, the
front elevation provides openings to break up its facade, and the roof is
materially different. This development appears subservient to the host
dwelling, in acute contrast to the development proposed.
9. As part of my assessment I have also had regard to the historical significance
of this estate and its relevance to early public housing. Its character should
therefore be preserved by sympathetic extensions. However, the proposal is
out of context with the local area and harmful to its significance as a ‘banjo’
and is therefore in conflict with Policy BP2 of the Planning for the Future of
Barking and Dagenham Borough Wide Development Policies Development Plan
Document, March 2011 (DPD) and Policy CP2 of the Barking and Dagenham
Core Strategy July 2010, that in particular, seeks development to respect its
local context and distinctiveness.
10. As well as this, the proposal is in conflict with the Barking and Dagenham DPD
Policy BP8 in its aims of that part of the policy to have regard to local character
only. This is echoed in Policy BP11 that seeks to, amongst other matters,
provide high quality architecture.
11. In addition, the proposal is contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework) that seeks new development to achieve well designed places
by, amongst other criteria, ensuring development is sympathetic to local
character and history.
Appeal Decision APP/Z5060/D/19/3234131
3
Living Conditions
12. In terms of the impact of the development on the living conditions of the
occupants of 178 Wood Lane, I have taken account of the SPD’s guidance that
recommends applying the 45-degree rule to assess the impact of a two-storey
extension on neighbouring outlook. Having viewed the location of the
neighbouring windows and their relationship with the appeal site, together with
the length and height of the two-storey extension, I do not consider that the
extension would significantly compromise the outlook from this closest window,
which would remain largely open in aspect.
13. The single storey extension would project close to the party boundary with No.
178. The neighbouring property has a large garden shed detached from the
dwelling that sits in front of their French doors and close to the party boundary
with the appeal site. This metal shed has a degree of permanence about its size
and finished material. Part of the sloping roof of the extension would be visible
above the boundary fence, however, the combination of the shed and this
fence would screen the majority of the proposed single storey extension.
14. Therefore, I conclude that the proposals would not adversely compromise the
outlook from 178 Wood Lane or from their rear garden and to this end I do not
find harm to the living conditions of its occupants. Whilst the proposed
development is contrary to the Council’s DPD Policies BP8 and BP11 in its aims
to have regard to local character, where the policy is more specifically related
to residential amenity, the development would protect residential amenity.
Other Matters
15. There are many extended dwellings within the local area with 156 and 158
Wood Lane identified by the appellant as examples of precedent. However, this
is not directly comparable to the appeal site due to the layout of the properties,
their relationship with one another and the differing developments. As such I
am not minded to allow the appeal in their light. In any case, I have assessed
this proposal on its own individual merits.
16. I have had regard to the Framework and its aims to use land effectively as well
as the appellant’s argument that they should be able to extend their home, to
which I do not disagree. However, this does not alter my decision as I have
found there would be overriding planning harm to the character and
appearance of the area which would accordingly result in conflict with the
development plan.
Conclusion
17. Whilst I have not found there to be harm arising to the living conditions of
neighbouring occupiers, this would not be sufficient against the harm I have
found to the character and appearance of the area. For that reason, the appeal
is dismissed.
Alison Scott
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.