Detached garage/store, porch and stables
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 16 September 2019 by S Watson BA (Hons) MSc
Decision by R C Kirby BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
An Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 25 October 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/P1805/D/19/3233346
Galtons, Hartle Lane, Belbroughton DY9 9TR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Mark Beard against the decision of Bromsgrove District
Council.
• The application Ref 18/01549/FUL, dated 12 December 2018, was refused by notice
dated 1 March 2019.
• The development proposed is a detached garage/store, porch and stables.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Procedural Matters
3. The description of development in the heading above has been taken from the
application form. However, in Part E of the appeal form it is stated that the
description of development has been changed, and agreed by Bromsgrove
District Council, to “detached garage/store and porch”. As the proposal was
amended during the planning application process, and as the Council dealt with
the proposal on this basis, so shall I.
4. While the appellant’s statement of case refers to the appeal being only for the
porch extension, I can only consider the appeal before me, which includes the
erection of the garage/store.
Main Issues
5. The appeal site is located within the West Midlands Green Belt. Accordingly,
the main issues in this case are:
• Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the revised National Planning Policy Framework
(Framework) and any relevant development plan policies;
• The effect on the openness of the Green Belt; and
Appeal Decision APP/P1805/D/19/3233346
2
• Whether the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is
clearly outweighed by other considerations and if so whether this would
amount to the very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons for the Recommendation
Whether inappropriate development
6. Paragraph 143 of the Framework establishes that inappropriate development is
by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in
very special circumstances. Paragraph 144 states that substantial weight
should be given to any harm to the Green Belt and very special circumstances
will not exist unless the potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations.
7. Subject to a number of exceptions, the Framework makes it clear that the
construction of new buildings should be regarded as inappropriate in the Green
Belt. The listed exceptions are set out in Paragraph 145 of the Framework and
include the ‘extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not result
in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building’.
There is no exception within the Framework for the erection of ancillary
buildings connected with a residential use.
8. Policy BDP4 of the Bromsgrove District Plan (BDP), broadly conforms with the
Framework in this regard, setting out the size of extension which would not be
considered to be inappropriate in the Green Belt. The supporting text to the
policy states that new curtilage buildings located more than 5 metres from the
dwelling house will normally be treated as inappropriate development.
9. The new garage/store would be detached and located some distance from the
host property. This aspect of the proposal would not fall within any of the
exceptions set out within either the Framework or Policy BDP4 of the BDP.
Accordingly, it would comprise inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
10. The new porch would be attached to the house. Whilst this addition would be
relatively small in scale, the Council has calculated that it would increase the
size of the original dwelling by over 40% and over 140 square metres when
taken with other extensions to the property. The proposal, along with existing
extensions would therefore exceed the size limitations for extensions set out
within the supporting text to Policy BDP4 of the BDP. This is not contested by
the appellant.
11. Having regard to the above, I conclude that the proposal, taken with other
extensions to the property would result in disproportionate additions over and
above the size of the original dwelling. The extension would not accord with
Paragraph 145(c) of the Framework or Policy BDP4 of the BDP and would
therefore represent inappropriate development within the Green Belt.
Openness
12. Paragraph 133 of the Framework identifies that openness is one of the
essential characteristics of Green Belts, along with permanence. The Courts
have confirmed that the openness of the Green Belt has a spatial aspect as well
as a visual aspect. This means that the absence of visual intrusion does not in
itself mean that there is no impact on the openness of the Green Belt as a
Appeal Decision APP/P1805/D/19/3233346
3
result, but equally this does not mean that the openness of the Green Belt has
no visual dimension.
13. In this instance the effect of the cumulative increased size of the host dwelling
and the garage/store would clearly be experienced both visually and spatially,
although due to the size and siting of the extension and garage this impact
would be localised and limited. However, in this respect even a limited adverse
effect on openness would contribute to the overall harm to the Green Belt.
14. For this reason, the proposed development would compromise the openness of
the Green Belt, in that it would be reduced. Whilst the loss of openness would
be limited, harm to the Green Belt would occur. This matter carries substantial
weight.
Other Considerations
15. I note the appellant’s desire to provide a utility room to provide additional
facilities to accommodate the needs of a relative and to provide additional
space generally. I note also that the garage/store would provide secure storage
for machinery, vehicles and tools. Whilst I have no doubt that the additional
accommodation would be of benefit to the appellant and his family, it is likely
that the development is permanent and would remain long after the current
personal circumstances cease to exist. I am only able to attach moderate
weight to these matters as a result.
16. It has been suggested that the proposed extension would maintain the
character and appearance of the host dwelling, while an extension carried out
under permitted development would not. I acknowledge that a certificate of
lawfulness was granted by the Council for the erection of a porch and a
detached outbuilding. However, although it appears that works to the
outbuilding are nearing completion, I have not been provided with detailed
drawings of the porch and I am not able to assess the impact of such
development against the proposal before me. As such this matter carries only
limited weight in my overall consideration.
Green Belt Conclusion
17. The proposal would amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt,
and further harm to the Green Belt would be caused as a result of loss of
openness. These matters carry substantial weight. At most, moderate weight
has been given to the considerations cited in support of the proposal. I
conclude that taken together, they do not clearly outweigh the harm to the
Green Belt. Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to justify
inappropriate development in the Green Belt do not exist. The proposal
conflicts with the Green Belt aims of Policy BDP4 of the BDP and the
Framework.
Other Matters
18. I note that there is a Grade II listed waterwheel to the north of the appeal site.
Having regard to my statutory duty, I am satisfied that the porch and
outbuilding would have a neutral effect upon its setting due to the distance and
visual relationship between the proposals and the water wheel. I therefore find
that harm to the significance of the heritage asset would not occur.
Appeal Decision APP/P1805/D/19/3233346
4
Recommendation
19. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I
recommend that the appeal should be dismissed.
S Watson
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
20. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and concur that the appeal should be dismissed.
R C Kirby
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.