Ground floor extension with development of roof space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 24 September 2019
by Diane Cragg DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16 October 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/W4223/D/19/3232997
New House, Cooper Street, Springhead OL4 4QT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Mark Wilson against the decision of Oldham Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref HH/343133/19, dated 25 March 2019, was refused by notice dated
4 July 2019.
• The development proposed is ground floor extension with development of roof space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The Council refers to the extension as a rear extension as does the appellant in
his statement. However, the drawings indicate that the extension is to the front
elevation. For consistency with the Councils and appellants submissions I have
referred to the extension as being on the rear elevation. However, it is not for
me to determine as part of this appeal which elevation is the principal elevation
of the appeal property.
Main Issue
3. The effect of the development on the setting and thereby significance of a
designated heritage asset, Ashfield House, a grade ll listed building.
Reasons
4. New House is a detached property providing accommodation over two floors in
a dwelling designed with single storey eaves and with bedrooms in the roof
space. It has a detached double garage which sits to the side and adjacent to
the dwellings enclosed amenity space.
5. Ashfield House is a grade ll listed building located immediately adjacent to the
appeal site. It is divided into two properties with parking and outbuildings to
the rear. There are two further relatively modern properties to the front and
within the environs of the listed building.
6. Section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990, (the Act) requires the decision maker, in considering whether to grant
planning permission for development which affects a listed building or its
setting, to have special regard to the desirability of preserving the building or
Appeal Decision APP/W4223/D/19/3232997
2
its setting or any features of special architectural or historic interest it
possesses.
7. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) defines the setting of
a heritage asset as the surroundings in which a heritage asset is experienced.
8. Ashfield House is described in the list description as dating back to the Early
C19. It is constructed of watershot hammer-dressed stone with graduated
stone slate roof. The side and rear flat roofed extensions, according to the list
description, were part of the structure when it was listed in 1986. The
significance of this heritage asset relates primarily to its age and architectural
interest. However, the height of the building relative to its surroundings gives it
a physical presence in its immediate environment and in views towards it.
9. The rear elevation of the appeal property sits roughly in line with the rear of
the listed building. The effect of the extension would be to bring the elevation
forward towards the front elevation of Ashfield House. The height and width of
the extension, where the current low eaves line would be replaced with a
gable, would be more prominent. Although the new window and patio door
openings would relate acceptably to the surrounding design details, the large
gable would significantly increase the mass of the building. The extension’s
width and height would be more prominent and there would be a higher level
of inter-visibility between the dwelling and the listed building.
10. Further, on the approach to the site along Cooper Street the road is elevated
and the scale and mass of Ashfield House, its surrounding boundary treatment
and its juxtaposition with the appeal site and other modern development can
be discerned in views over the playground of the adjacent primary school.
From this vantage point the proposed extension, with its pitched roof extending
from just below the ridge and its forward projection, would impinge on the
setting of Ashfield House in that it would appear closer to it and introduce
additional built form to its immediate context.
11. Consequently, I consider the development would adversely affect the setting of
Ashfield House by being more conspicuous in views towards it and detracting
from the surroundings in which the listed building is experienced.
12. I acknowledge that there is significant other development within the environs
of Ashfield house that has detracted from the setting of the listed building. I
have been provided with limited information of the circumstances of these
approvals. However, I have had regard to the positioning of adjacent
development in considering the proposed development but the existence of
these developments does not negate the harm I have found.
13. Overall, the appeal scheme would detract from the setting of the listed building
in a small, but nonetheless unduly harmful way. Accordingly, I find conflict with
Policy 9, Policy 20 and Policy 24 of the Oldham Local Development Framework
Development Plan Document – Joint Core Strategy and Development
Management Policies adopted 9 November 2011 which collectively seek to
protect local environmental quality, promote high quality design and protect
the special interest and setting of listed buildings.
14. In accordance with Paragraph 193 of the Framework the finding of harm to a
designated heritage asset is a matter to which I must attach considerable
importance and great weight. Given the scale of the proposed extension in its
Appeal Decision APP/W4223/D/19/3232997
3
context, I quantify this harm as less than substantial. Where a development
would lead to less than substantial harm, in accordance with Paragraph 196 of
the Framework, this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the
proposal.
15. The Planning Practice Guidance1 advises that public benefits may follow from
many developments and could be anything that delivers economic, social or
environmental objectives. Public benefits should flow from the proposed
development. They should be of a nature or scale to be of benefit to the public
at large and not just be a private benefit.
16. I acknowledge that the extension would provide additional accommodation and
in a small way would support investment within Oldham and the aims of
Oldham’s Housing Strategy. However, whilst I agree that providing good
quality housing and supporting the local economy are important and should be
afforded some weight, this would not outweigh the great weight to be given to
the less than substantial harm I have identified to the setting and thereby
significance of Ashfield House.
17. I accept that the design of the extension would be in keeping with the design of
the appeal property. However, I do not regard this as a public benefit as this is
a normal expectation of planning policy.
Other Matters
18. I note the appellant’s view that there may be other development that would
not need planning permission that could be erected at the appeal site.
However, I have not been provided with any specific details of an alternative
scheme to compare with the appeal development and there is no evidence
before me of any realistic prospect that an alternative scheme would be
implemented.
Conclusion
19. I find that overall the proposed development would cause less than substantial
harm to a designated heritage asset. No material considerations or public
benefits have been put forward that are enough to outweigh the harm
identified. For the reasons given above, I therefore conclude that the appeal
should be dismissed.
Diane Cragg
INSPECTOR
1 Paragraph: 020 Reference ID: 18a-020-20190723
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.