Improvements and Extensions to Dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 October 2019
by Rory MacLeod BA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 October 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/M3645/D/19/3232216
Samri, Effingham Road, Burstow, Horley RH6 9RP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr S Khan against the decision of Tandridge District Council.
• The application Ref TA/2019/487, dated 8 March 2019, was refused by notice dated
31 May 2019.
• The development proposed is Improvements and Extensions to Dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are
(a) whether the proposal would constitute inappropriate development in the
Green Belt,
(b) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area, and
(c) if it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
3. Samri is a detached two storey house on the northern side of Effingham Road
to the east of a busy traffic light controlled junction with Redehall Road. It
forms part of a row of mainly two storey detached dwellings. To the east of the
site there is a vehicular access leading to various commercial premises to the
rear of Samri. The cluster of buildings along Effingham road is outside of any
defined settlement. The land opposite on the southern side of Effingham Road
is less developed. The site and surrounding area are within the Green Belt.
4. The proposal is the construction of a two storey side extension on the western
side of the dwelling. This would be about 5.2m wide and set slightly forward of
the present front wall to the dwelling with a gable end facing the road. It would
extend for virtually the full depth of the house. A small front porch would be
added to align with the front wall to the side extension.
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/19/3232216
2
5. Paragraph 145 of the Framework states that the construction of new buildings
should be regarded as inappropriate in the Green Belt unless it complies with
stated exceptions. Exception (c) states “the extension or alteration of a building
provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above
the size of the original building”. The Framework defines original building as “A
building as it existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it
was built originally”. It does not define what constitutes a “disproportionate”
addition, but reference to the “size” of the original building is the starting point.
6. Policies DP10 and DP13 of the Tandridge District Local Plan Part 2: Detailed
Policies (2014) (LP) are broadly consistent with the Framework. Policy DP10
states that “planning permission for any inappropriate development which is,
by definition, harmful to the Green Belt, will normally be refused”. Policy DP13
lists as an exception to inappropriate development “the extension or alteration
of buildings within the Green Belt (outside the Defined Villages), where the
proposal does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size
of the original building”. However, for dwellings the policy cites the effective
date for the original building as it existed on 31 December 1968 rather than on
1 July 1948.
7. The building has a complicated planning history. It was originally a garage and
offices with various extensions and living accommodation over; the building
was eventually converted wholly to residential accommodation. The Council has
produced evidence relating to the size of the building in 1968; it is unclear how
the building may have changed between 1948 and 1968. Having regard to the
submitted plans, the proposal would result in approximately a 60% increase in
floor area compared to the existing building. In relation to volume, the Council
calculate that the building in 1968 would have had a volume of 480 cubic
metres, that the combined total of the proposal and other additions would be
922 cubic metres and that there would be a 92% increase over the volume of
the original building. The appellant contests this, estimating a 66% increase in
volume that could be further reduced by exclusion of the lean to at the rear
with a volume of 26.1 cubic metres. Even accepting the appellant’s figures the
proposal would result in a substantial increase in the size of the building.
8. The proposal’s effect on the openness of the Green Belt can be assessed not
only by its spatial dimensions but also by its visual impact. At about 5.2m wide
and 7.5m high the side extension’s massing would be prominent in views from
Effingham Road and a conspicuous feature when viewed from the rear and
from Hawthorn Cottage, the adjacent dwelling to the west. The porch would be
modest in size and viewed against the massing of the existing building.
9. My findings are that the proposal would result in a substantial addition that
would be harmful to the openness of the Green Belt. It would be a
disproportionate addition in relation to the size of the original building. The
proposal would not therefore satisfy the requirements of Paragraph 145 (c) of
the Framework and would thereby amount to inappropriate development.
Paragraph 143 of the Frameworks states, “inappropriate development is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances”.
Character and appearance
10. There is variety in the size and form of dwellings in the surrounding area.
Whilst many are two storey and detached, there are some single storey and
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/19/3232216
3
semi-detached dwellings. Many are modest in size and the spacing between the
buildings contribute to a relatively open appearance in the street scene. The
proposal would result in a dwelling of a size and profile similar to that of some
of the larger dwellings to the east of the site. The width of the site is such that
even with the addition of the proposed side extension there would be a gap to
Hawthorn Cottage to the west of the site similar to the gap between many
buildings along Effingham Road.
11. The proposal would not thereby conflict with Policy CSP18 of the Tandridge
District Core Strategy (2008) which requires new development to have a high
standard of design that reflects and respects the character, setting and local
context, including those features that contribute to local distinctiveness. Nor
would there be conflict with Policy DP7 of the LP which requires proposals to be
in keeping with the prevailing streetscape, reflecting the variety of local
building types and designs.
Other considerations
12. The appellant argues that the proposal would result in good design to what is
currently a “rather ugly dwelling” and would enable eradication of sub-standard
construction and severe damp problems. However, it would be possible to
make such improvements without the construction of such a large extension. A
suggestion to reduce the depth of the side extension would reduce the spatial
calculations on size but would not alter the visual impact of the proposal in the
street scene or make a significant difference to the impact on openness.
13. The appellant has drawn my attention to two allowed appeals for extensions to
dwellings in the Green Belt in Tandridge1. But the site circumstances differ
significantly from those at the current appeal site. At the first, the proposal was
largely at the rear on falling ground levels, would not be readily visible in the
street scene and would mirror a similar development at the adjacent site. The
second appeal site is enclosed by high embankments and the Inspector
considered that the extension would only have a marginal effect on openness.
Conclusion
14. The proposal amounts to inappropriate development and the Framework
indicates that this is by definition harmful to the Green Belt and should not be
approved except in very special circumstances. Paragraph 144 of the
Framework states that substantial weight should be given to any harm to the
Green Belt. There would be an impact on openness in the Green Belt, but the
proposal would not adversely affect the character and appearance of the area.
Nonetheless, there are no very special circumstances that outweigh the harm
arising from the proposal on the Green Belt. There would also be conflict with
policies DP10 and DP13 of the LP in relation to inappropriate development and
new development in the Green Belt.
15. For the reasons given and having regard to all other matters raised, including
the representations from interested parties, the appeal should be dismissed.
Rory MacLeod
INSPECTOR
1 3 St Denys Orchard (APP/M3645/D/19/3225214) and Taylors Hill (APP/M3645/W/16/3156272)
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.