Appeal Against Conditions
π
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view β just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape
Inspectorβs Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 August 2019
by E Symmons BSc (Hons), MSc
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 12 November 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/G2713/D/19/3231887
The Old Orchard, Cooper Lane, Potto, North Yorkshire DL6 3HQ
β’ The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land without complying with
conditions subject to which a previous planning permission was granted.
β’ The appeal is made by Mr John Graham against the decision of Hambleton District
Council.
β’ The application ref 19/00717/MRC, dated 27 March 2019, was refused by notice dated
22 May 2019.
β’ The application sought planning permission for an extension to the existing dwelling
comprising extended garage and entertainment area above, as amended on
4 November 2018 without complying with a condition attached to planning permission
ref 18/01815/FUL, dated 27 November 2018.
β’ The condition in dispute is No 2 which states that: The permission hereby granted shall
not be undertaken other than in complete accordance with the drawings numbered:
(00) 3 E and (00) 5 D; received by Hambleton District Council on 4 November 2018;
unless otherwise approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority.
β’ The reason given for the condition is: In order that the development is undertaken in a
form that is appropriate to the character and appearance of its surroundings and in
accordance with the Development Plan Policies CP1, DP1, CP17, DP32, CP16, NPPF -
National Planning Policy Framework and DOMEX β Domestic Extensions SPD Dec 2009.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and permission is granted for an extension to the existing
dwelling comprising extended garage and entertainment area above, at The
Old Orchard, Cooper Lane, Potto, North Yorkshire DL6 3HQ in accordance with
application reference 19/00717/MRC without compliance with condition No 2
previously imposed on planning permission 18/01815/FUL dated 27/11/2018
but subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall be begun within three years of
the date of this permission.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans where applicable: 18011-00-02 β
Location Plan, 18011-SPA-00-16 - Floor Plans (Proposed) and 18011-
SPA-00-16 - Elevations (Proposed).
3) No above ground construction work shall be undertaken until
details/samples of the materials to be used in the construction of the
external surfaces of the extension hereby permitted have been submitted
to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. Development
shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details/samples.
Appeal Decision APP/G2713/D/19/3231887
2
4) No part of the existing boundary hedge along the southern boundary of
the site shall be uprooted or removed and the hedge shall not be reduced
below a height of 2.5 metres; unless otherwise approved in writing by the
Local Planning Authority.
Procedural Matters
2. Both the Council and the appellant refer to the drawing showing the proposed
floor plans as Plan 15. However, the submitted drawing itself is labelled Plan 16
(18011-SPA-00-16 - Floor Plans (Proposed). The appellant has confirmed that
this was an error and the Council have confirmed that they determined the
application with reference to plan 18011-SPA-00-16 - Floor Plans (Proposed).
The corrected plan reference is used within my decision.
Main Issues
3. The main issue is the effect of varying condition 2 of permission 18/01815/FUL
on the character and appearance of the area.
Reasons
4. This L-shaped bungalow sits somewhat apart from other dwellings in the village
having no immediately adjacent neighbouring residential properties. It has an
elevated position above the highway being reached from Coopers Lane via a
steep driveway leading into a large courtyard area. The property is well
screened from public views having fields to the north and west, a public house
car park to the south and the highway to the east. It is set back from the
highway by a wide grass verge. The verge merges with a mature hedge
situated on a raised bankside which, in combination with other adjacent hedges
and trees, screens the property.
5. The Domestic Extensions Supplementary Planning Document1 2009
recommends that extensions are subordinate to the original dwelling. It
however, goes on to say that levels of subservience are dependent on the host
property and are judged on their own merits. The consented scheme permits
an extension to the side of the existing double garage with construction of an
entertainment area above. To achieve this the roof height is raised and the
garage reconfigured at ground floor level to provide an additional car space.
6. The condition which is the subject of this appeal relates to the approved plans.
In particular, the consented scheme shown within plan Ref 18011 Drawing 03,
Rev E includes rooflights on the roof elevation facing the courtyard. The
appellant wishes to replace the rooflights with three dormer windows as shown
on plans Ref 18011-SPA-00-16 β Floor Plans (Proposed) and 18011-SPA-00-16
β Elevations (Proposed).
7. The roof of the dwelling can be seen from the highway. Although addition of
dormer windows would further increase the mass of the roof and its
prominence, this would be mitigated by several factors. The host plot size and
existing footprint of the dwelling are large and within this context the proposed
increase in mass would be less significant. There would also be substantial
screening of the proposal by the host property itself and along the property
boundaries by the public house and the roadside and adjacent field hedge
1 Hambleton Local Development Plan Document. Domestic Extensions Supplementary Planning Document. Adopted
22 December 2009.
Appeal Decision APP/G2713/D/19/3231887
3
boundaries in addition to various trees. Views of the property would therefore
not be prominent and additionally, there are no adjacent properties to provide
a prevailing character or appearance which would make the proposal appear
incongruous or out of scale. These factors weigh in favour of the proposal and
within the context of the consented scheme, the altered roofscape would have
a neutral effect upon the area and not harm the character and appearance of
the host property.
8. This proposal would therefore not conflict with CP16, CP17 and DP32 of
Hambleton District Council Development Plan Document2 2008 (DPD) which
together and amongst other matters seek that development respects the local
context, the scale of buildings and spaces.
9. The guidance in the PPG3 makes clear that decision notices for the grant of
planning permission under section 73 of the Act should also repeat the relevant
conditions from the original planning permission, unless they have already
been discharged. I have no information before me about the status of the
conditions imposed on the original planning permission and I have therefore
considered all that were applied. I shall use the decision notice as the basis for
the conditions within this decision and impose all those that I consider relevant.
If some have already been discharged, that is a matter which can be addressed
by the parties.
10. The National Planning Policy Framework4 makes it clear that conditions should
be kept to a minimum and only used when they meet the six tests set out in
paragraph 55. Condition 4 of the original consent was applied to ensure that
the extension remained as an annex to the dwelling. However, any business
use which was not ancillary to the main dwelling, or its use as a separate
dwelling, would require planning permission. The condition therefore is not
necessary to make the development acceptable in planning terms.
11. In addition to the standard condition regarding the time period for
implementation, there is a need for a condition specifying the plans to which
this permission relates, in the interests of certainty. Condition 3 refers to the
requirement for materials to match the existing in the interests of protecting
the character and appearance of the area. Condition 4 refers to retention of the
hedge to the south of the property which contributes to the screening of the
property from the highway.
Conclusion
12. For the reasons set out above the amended proposal would not affect the
character or appearance of the area. Consequently, I shall remove Condition 2
and replace it with a plans condition reflecting the amended plans.
13. The appeal is allowed.
E Symmons
2 Hambleton District Council. Local Development Framework Development Plan Document . Adopted 26 February
2008.
3 Use of Planning Conditions. Planning Policy Guidance. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.
Last updated 23 July 2019.
4 February 2019.
Appeal Decision APP/G2713/D/19/3231887
4
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation β you only pay if you win.