Construction of single storey outbuilding
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 August 2019
by J Bell-Williamson MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 05 September 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/H1515/D/19/3231700
Green Keepers Cottage, Thorndon Gate, Ingrave CM13 3RQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Chris Read against the decision of Brentwood Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 19/00238/FUL, dated 20 February 2019, was refused by notice
dated 12 April 2019.
• The development proposed is construction of single storey outbuilding.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for construction of
single storey outbuilding at Green Keepers Cottage, Thorndon Gate, Ingrave
CM13 3RQ. The permission is granted in accordance with the terms of the
application, Ref 19/00238/FUL, dated 20 February 2019, subject to the
following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: SK1 (location plan), WD1 (proposed site
plan), WD2 (proposed block plan), WD3 Revision A (plans and elevations)
and WD4 (sections).
Main issues
2. The main issues are:
• whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
for the purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
and development plan policy;
• the effect on the openness of the Green Belt;
• if the proposal would be inappropriate development, whether the harm to
the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is
clearly outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to the very
special circumstances necessary to justify it; and
Appeal Decision APP/H1515/D/19/3231700
2
• whether the proposal would preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Thorndon Park Conservation Area, and related to this its
effect on the Grade II* listed park and garden of Thorndon Hall and a Special
Landscape Area (SLA).
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a detached two storey dwelling located on the entrance
road to Thorndon Park Golf Club and Thorndon Hall. It stands behind more
modern properties on The Meadows and is within the Green Belt, the Thorndon
Park Conservation Area, the Grade II* listed park and garden of Thorndon Hall
and an SLA.
Whether the proposal is inappropriate development
4. The Framework makes clear that the construction of new buildings in the Green
Belt should be regarded as inappropriate, with a small number of exceptions1.
None of these refers explicitly to domestic outbuildings as proposed in this
case.
5. For this reason, the Council considers that the proposed building is
inappropriate development. However, the use of the proposed building is
intended to be incidental to the established residential use of Green Keepers
Cottage. In these circumstances, the outbuilding is capable in principle of
being considered as an extension to the existing dwelling, in accordance with
145c) of the Framework, given that it would be a normal domestic adjunct to
the dwelling. In this regard the Framework requires extensions not to result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
6. The Council refers to Policies GB1 and GB2 of the Brentwood Replacement
Local Plan (RLP), which concern development in the Green Belt. Despite the
fact that these policies pre-date the Framework, they are broadly consistent
with it and, therefore, I have had regard to them as well as to the Framework
for the purposes of determining this appeal.
7. A number of extensions and alterations have been permitted to the appeal
property. However, it is not fully clear from the appeal submissions or site
inspection how the size of the original building may have changed as a result of
these permitted extensions. Consequently, the principal basis for assessing
proportionality in this case is the physical size and scale of the proposed
outbuilding, including the degree of bulk or mass that might be added in
relation to the host dwelling.
8. The single storey building would replace an existing traditional, smaller timber
outbuilding with a pitched roof. While of greater length and height, the low
roof profile of the structure would help to mitigate any increase in bulk and
mass. Moreover, the building would be subordinate in scale to the two-storey
host dwelling and given the size of the residential curtilage would not appear as
a disproportionate addition in its setting.
1 Paragraph 145.
Appeal Decision APP/H1515/D/19/3231700
3
9. Therefore, for the above reasons, I conclude that the proposed outbuilding
would not be inappropriate development in the Green Belt for the purposes of
the Framework and Policies GB1 and GB2 of the RLP.
Effect on Openness
10. The effect on openness is implicitly taken into account in the exceptions
included in paragraph 145 of the Framework unless there is a specific
requirement to consider the actual effect on openness. Therefore, for those
exceptions within paragraph 145, including c) as in this case, where the effect
of the development on openness is not expressly stated as a determinative
factor in gauging inappropriateness, and where the development has been
found to be not inappropriate development as is the case here, there is no
specific requirement to assess the impact of the development on the openness
of the Green Belt.
11. Nonetheless, for the avoidance of doubt, I have found above that the proposed
building would not result in substantive bulk or mass in addition to the host
dwelling and would not add significant additional built development to the
relatively spacious residential curtilage of the appeal property. As such, there
would be no material harm to the Green Belt’s openness as a result of
additional development of the type proposed.
Heritage Assets and SLA
12. The appeal property is located close to the edge of but within the Thorndon
Park Conservation Area, which comprises predominantly open land including
the Thorndon Park Golf Club and a country park. It is also within the Grade II*
listed park and garden of Thorndon Hall and an SLA.
13. While the appeal property is part of the designated heritage assets and SLA,
and despite its former association with them as an entrance lodge, the dense
woodland to its western boundary separates it visually and functionally from
the main open part of the conservation area and listed park and garden.
Moreover, due to its proximity to properties on The Meadows and along
Thorndon Gate, it effectively forms part of a transition from the residential area
to the adjoining open land that forms the predominant part of the designated
heritage assets and SLA.
14. Due to the position of the proposed outbuilding to the rear of the host dwelling
and the dense tree cover close to the western boundary, the building would not
be prominent in views from within the designated areas. It would be seen in
passing views along Thorndon Gate, but these would be limited and the
building would be seen as subordinate to the scale of the host dwelling to the
site frontage. Furthermore, there are other relatively large outbuildings nearby
in the rear gardens of properties on The Meadows, which back onto to the
appeal property. As such, the outbuilding would not be uncharacteristic in its
residential setting.
15. Accordingly, for these reasons, I conclude that the proposed outbuilding would
preserve the character and appearance of the Thorndon Park Conservation
Area, and would not have a harmful effect on the park and garden of Thorndon
Hall or the SLA. Consequently, there is no conflict with the following policies of
the RLP: CP1 concerning, amongst other matters, the effect of development on
Appeal Decision APP/H1515/D/19/3231700
4
the character and appearance, and historic heritage of the surrounding area;
C8, C9 and C14 concerning the effect of development on, respectively, SLAs,
historic parks and gardens, and conservation areas. These policies are
consistent with the Framework.
Other Considerations
16. I note the appellants’ reference to a ‘fallback’ of a similar form of outbuilding to
the appeal proposal that was approved through a Lawful Development
Certificate2. However, given my findings in the appellants’ favour with regard
to the other main issues, I have not considered this matter further.
Other Matters
17. The Council refers to the fact that some trees adjacent to the western
boundary of the appeal site have been cleared, and that the proposal would not
be considered acceptable once the replacement trees have been planted.
However, I am required to consider the appeal proposal as it pertains to
current circumstances. Moreover, given that the proposed building would be
contained within a residential curtilage, this does not have a direct bearing on
the possible replacement of trees outside the boundary. As such, I give this
matter limited weight.
Overall Conclusion
18. I have found above that the proposal would not be inappropriate development
in the Green Belt and so there is no conflict with the Framework or Policies GB1
and GB2 of the RLP. Moreover, there would be no harmful effects on the
relevant designated heritage assets and SLA. Consequently, the appeal should
succeed.
Conditions
19. Of the Council’s suggested conditions I have imposed the standard time
condition and, to ensure the proper implementation of development in
accordance with the submitted details, one requiring development to be carried
out in accordance with the approved plans.
J Bell-Williamson
INSPECTOR
2 Reference 19/00245/S192, dated 12 April 2019.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.