Construction of a single storey rear extension and the construction of a dormer to the rear roofslope
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 3 September 2019 by AJ Sutton BA Hons DipTP DMS MRTPI
by R C Kirby BA Hons DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 2 October 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/C5690/D/19/3228717
92 Newquay Road, London, SE6 2NP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr M Afzal against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Lewisham.
• The application Ref DC/19/111474, dated 2 April 2019, was refused by notice dated 8
May 2019.
• The development proposed is described as ‘the construction of a single storey rear
extension and the construction of a dormer to the rear roofslope’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Preliminary Matters
3. Works had commenced at the time the site visit was conducted. Part of the
ground floor rear external wall had been removed and a tarpaulin covered the
full width of the rear roof. Part of the boundary fence and vegetation between
the appeal property and No 94 Newquay Road had been removed.
4. The decision notice references Policy 15 of the Lewisham local development
framework Core Strategy Development plan document and Policy 36 of the
Lewisham local development framework Development Management Local Plan
(LP) which were absent from the submitted information. My consideration of
the appeal has been made on the basis of the information before me.
Main Issues
5. The main issues in this case are:
• the effect of the single storey rear extension on the living conditions of
nearby occupiers at Nos 90 and 94 Newquay Road, with particular regard to
outlook; and
• the effect on the character and appearance of the original building and
surrounding area, with particular regard to the design of the dormer window.
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/19/3228717
2
Reasons
6. The appeal property is a mid-terrace dwelling in a short row of properties,
situated on Newquay Road which forms part of a grid patterned suburban area.
It is located within the Culverley Green Conservation Area (CGVA). The
architectural style of the property appears typical of an early 20th century
residential development. The distinct roof style and pattern of the appeal
property and attached dwellings comprises hipped roofs with lower set
intersectional connections. The front elevations include small pitched gable
architectural detail, whereas the rear roofline is largely unadorned. The appeal
property has a linear garden plot, bounded in part, by relatively low wooden
panelled fences between adjacent properties and backing onto the garden of a
property set on the parallel street. The rear boundary was partially obscured by
mature vegetation.
Living Conditions
7. The proposed single storey rear extension would cover the full width of the
existing rear elevation of the appeal property; extending from an existing
shallow return, in a solid line without windows, on the eastern boundary of the
site, with an instep on the western boundary, within which a window would be
positioned. It would project significantly beyond the rear elevation of the
neighbouring properties at Nos 90 and 94.
8. Although the extension would be set back away from the party boundary with
No 90, it would, because of the low boundary treatment between the host
dwelling and this property be a prominent feature in the outlook from its rear
ground floor windows and garden area closest to the rear of this dwelling.
9. Moreover, the extension would introduce a large expanse of solid wall in close
proximity to the party boundary with No 94. It would significantly diminish the
open outlook that currently exists from the rear of this property. The extension
would be a dominant, prominent, overbearing feature in the outlook from the
rear windows of the ground floor rooms of this property. It would have a
significant enclosing effect on the rear rooms closest to the party boundary and
also on the rear garden closest to the rear of the dwelling. The new extension
would make the rear rooms and rear garden of this property less pleasant to
use as a result.
10. Although the design of the proposed extension may reflect design guidance set
out in supplementary planning guidance in terms of height and layout, the
scale of the development, within the particular setting, would clearly harm the
outlook of nearby occupiers for the reasons set out above. The presence of
extensions nearby, including that to the rear of No 90 are not directly
comparable to the proposal before me and its context. They do not therefore
justify harmful development. Each planning application and appeal must be
determined on its merits.
11. In light of the foregoing, I conclude that the proposal would result in harm to
the living conditions of the occupiers of Nos 90 and 94 Newquay Road as a
result of loss of outlook, in conflict with Policies 30 and 31 of the LP and the
Alterations and Extensions Supplementary Planning Document 2019 (SPD
2019) which, amongst other matters requires development to be of a high
standard of design, which safeguards the amenity of adjoining houses and their
back gardens.
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/19/3228717
3
Character & Appearance
12. The CGCA covers a suburban residential estate developed in the early decades
of the 20th Century. The appeal property is within a character area developed
towards the end of this period. Evidence before me and observed on the site
visit indicates that a number of properties in, and surrounding Newquay Road
have been altered. However, the original distinct suburban architectural style
and character of the area prevails both at the front and rear of the properties.
13. There appears to be one rear dormer window in the short terrace of which the
appeal property forms part, at No 96. I also observed a large rear dormer
window at a property located to the rear of the appeal property’s garden.
However, other than these examples the roofscape of properties in the
immediate area is largely unaltered. The existing roofscape of the appeal
property and adjoining properties appear as pairings despite forming part of a
short-terraced row. The introduction of a dormer window into the rear roof
would alter the existing symmetry of the roofscape with No 94 and would, as a
consequence, be harmful to the appearance of the terrace as a whole.
14. It follows that the contribution that the host property makes to the character
and appearance of the area would be diminished as a result of the roof
extension and harm to the area would occur, even taking account of the fact
that the new window would not be visible from the street scene. The proposal
would not preserve or enhance the appearance of the CGCA.
15. In reaching this conclusion I have had regard to other roof extensions in the
locality. However, without understanding the particular circumstances of the
examples I am unable to ascertain whether or not they are directly comparable
to the scheme before me. Each planning application and appeal is determined
on its merits and the presence of a similar type of development elsewhere does
not provide justification for harmful development.
16. Although the harm to the significance of the CGCA as a designated heritage
asset would be less than substantial, the National Planning Policy Framework
(Framework) makes it clear at paragraph 196 that this harm should be weighed
against the public benefits of the proposal.
17. In this regard, I have no evidence before me to suggest that the public benefits
of the proposed dormer window outweigh the harm that would be caused to
the significance of the CGCA as a heritage asset. I therefore conclude that the
dormer window would be harmful to the appearance of the host property and
the terrace of which it forms part. Harm would also be caused to the
appearance of the area. This is in conflict with Policies 30 and 31 of the LP and
SPD 2019 which jointly seek to secure development which is sensitively
designed and contributes to local distinctiveness.
Other Matters
18. I have taken into consideration the policies and guidance that the appellant has
drawn to my attention. However, I am required to consider the development
plan as a whole and given the conflict that I have found, the policies referred to
do not alter the conclusions that I have reached. No material considerations
have been advanced which indicate that the proposal should be determined
other than in accordance with the development plan.
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/19/3228717
4
19. I have no details before me regarding the level of engagement with the Council
during the application process and therefore unable to comment on this matter.
It is however open for the appellant to take this matter up separately with the
Council.
Conclusion and Recommendation
20. Having regard to the reasons outlined above and all other matters raised, I
conclude, that the appeal should be dismissed.
A J Sutton
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and concur that the appeal should
be dismissed.
R C Kirby
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.