Erection of ground floor rear and part side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planning inspectorate
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 June 2019
by K E Down MA(Oxon) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:12 June 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/C1950/D/19/3226209
15 Northaw Road West, Northaw, Potters Bar, EN6 4NW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr George Anastasiou against the decision of Welwyn Hatfield
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 6/2019/0154/HOUSE, dated 24 January 2019, was refused by notice
dated 28 March 2019.
• The development proposed is erection of ground floor rear and part side extension.
Demolition of the garage. First floor part rear extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. There are five main issues. Firstly, whether the proposed extensions would
amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt; secondly, the effect of
the proposed extensions on the openness of the Green Belt; thirdly, the effect
of the proposed extensions on the character and appearance of the host
dwelling and the surrounding area, including the visual amenity of the Green
Belt; fourthly, the effect of the proposed single storey extension on the living
conditions of occupiers of 13 Northaw Road West with respect to outlook; and
fifthly, if the proposed extensions would amount to inappropriate development,
whether the harm by reason of inappropriateness and any other harm is clearly
outweighed by other considerations, such as to amount to the very special
circumstances necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development in the Green Belt
3. The appeal site comprises a large, detached dwelling of significant character set
on a large, sloping plot in the Northaw Conservation Area (CA) and within the
Green Belt. It lies on the corner of Northaw Road West and Church Lane among
other dwellings of mixed age and design. There is a landscaped seating area on
the opposite corner of Church Lane which is characterised by mostly newer
dwellings and by a significant change in level, falling from Northaw Road West
to a low point beyond the appeal site and then rising again.
4. The original dwelling which, according to the appellant, includes pre-1948
extensions has a floor area of around 260m². There is a small discrepancy
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/19/3226209
2
between the figures provided by the appellant and those used by the Council.
The appellant states that the proposed extensions would add some 111.5m² of
floor space with 97m² being to the ground floor. This amounts to an increase of
about 42.4% over the original dwelling.
5. The Council estimates that the increase would be some 65% but refers to front
extensions and a modest rear extension. It therefore appears that the Council’s
assessment may be based on a different proposal. In consequence, I have given
most weight to the appellant’s figures, which appear to be more accurate.
6. Policy GBSP1 of the Welwyn Hatfield District Plan 2005 (LP) seeks to maintain
the Green Belt. Whilst this policy does not expressly accord with the National
Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) in resisting inappropriate development in the
Green Belt, emerging Policy SADM 34 of the Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council
Draft Local Plan Proposed Submission (DLP), 2016, states that within the Green
Belt planning permission will be granted in accordance with national policies and
other emerging policies and I am satisfied by this and by explanatory text in the
LP that the intent of Policy GBSP1 is to do so also. Inappropriate development
is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved other
than in very special circumstances. One exception to inappropriate
development, as set out in NPPF paragraph 145 (c), is the extension or
alteration of a building provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building, defined in this case as
the building on 1 July 1948. Although the LP pre-dates the NPPF, Policy RA3
accords with this exception and allows extensions to dwellings in the Green Belt
provided they would not, individually or when considered with existing or
approved extensions to the original dwelling, result in a disproportionate
increase in the size of the dwelling or have an adverse visual impact in terms of
prominence, size, bulk and design.
7. The NPPF does not define a disproportionate addition. However, the Council
states in evidence that an assessment should include both a mathematical and
a visual assessment and I agree that a combined quantitative and qualitative
approach is necessary.
8. The single storey element of the proposed extension has been built and extends
in a stepped alignment across the entire rear elevation. The deepest part
projects almost 7m beyond the original rear elevation and has a width of some
12m which includes a section which projects beyond the original side wall. It
has a flat roof with a large roof lantern. Owing to its width, depth and height
the ground floor extension, if allowed to remain, would overwhelm and visually
detract from the original dwelling, in the context of which it would appear as a
clearly disproportionate addition. Whilst the two storey addition would not
appear visually disproportionate, it would add to the scale of the overall
development.
9. In 2016 single and two storey rear extensions with a combined floor area of
some 89.7m² were permitted. It therefore appears that additions amounting to
some 40% were permitted but not built. The appellant suggests that the
difference in scale between the permitted scheme and the proposed scheme is
not materially different and therefore the proposed scheme would not amount
to a disproportionate addition. In mathematical terms I would agree. However,
although the ground floor addition in the 2016 scheme was more extensive than
the first floor they were reasonably balanced and the scale and design was
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/19/3226209
3
sympathetic to the host dwelling. The permitted scheme is not therefore readily
comparable with the appeal scheme.
10. It is concluded on the first main issue that the proposed extensions would
result in disproportionate additions, over and above the size of the original
building, and would amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
The NPPF advises that substantial weight should be given to any harm to the
Green Belt, including that by reason of inappropriateness.
Openness of the Green Belt
11. The NPPF states that the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their
openness and permanence. The proposed extensions would diminish the
openness to the rear of the dwelling by extending the area of built development
and adding significant bulk. Although predominately single storey, the elevated
position of the extension results in it having a very noticeable effect on the
openness of the plot. Moreover, it is visible, at a distance, from Church Lane
from where its width and depth result in a perceptible loss of openness. The
location of the dwelling in a village, albeit washed over by the Green Belt, and
the restricted views of the extension from outside the site would limit the harm.
This leads me to give the loss of openness moderate weight.
12. It is concluded on the second main issue that the proposed extension would
have a harmful effect on the openness of the Green Belt which would conflict
with the aims of Green Belt policy, as stated in the NPPF, to keep land
permanently open.
Character and appearance
13. The original rear of the dwelling comprised a number of single and two storey
elements that appeared small scale compared with the main part of the house.
The proposed single storey extension would result in the addition of a very large
boxy structure that failed to reflect the character or scale of the original
building, relating poorly to individual elements including roof form and
fenestration. Moreover, the unrelieved painted blockwork finish would add to
the impression of an oversized and unsympathetic extension. By contrast the
modest first floor extension would blend with the original dwelling in terms of
scale, design and materials. Moreover, the limited views of the extensions from
beyond the site would ensure that there was no material effect on the character
or appearance of the surrounding area, including the Northaw CA, or the visual
amenity of the wider Green Belt.
14. It is concluded on the third main issue that whilst the first floor extension
would be acceptable and there would be no material detriment to the
surrounding area, the proposed single storey extension would materially harm
the character and appearance of the host dwelling. In consequence it would
conflict with Policies D1 and D2 of the LP, the NPPF and the Council’s
Supplementary Design Guidance (SDG), 2005, which together expect all new
development to be of a high quality and standard of design that respects and
relates to the character and context of the area. The Council also refers to
Policy GBSP2, however, this policy does not appear to apply to Northaw.
Living conditions
15. The single storey rear extension projects towards the shared boundary with 13
Northaw Road West (referred to erroneously as No14 in the Council’s decision
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/19/3226209
4
notice). In part it replaces a detached garage but is situated closer to the
dwelling at No13 and has a noticeably greater depth than the garage. The
submitted plans show a significant gap between the extension and the shared
boundary. I noticed at my site visit that the extension that has been built lies
much closer to the boundary. Nevertheless, I have had regard to the extension
as proposed in reaching my decision.
16. Owing to the position of the dwelling at No13, away from the shared boundary,
although the proposed extension would be clearly visible there would be no
material loss of outlook from windows in the dwelling or from the patio area.
The generous garden at No13 is on lower land than either the dwelling or the
proposed extension. This would result in the extension appearing bulkier and
more prominent when viewed from the garden. Nevertheless, an open outlook
would remain beyond the extension and to the rear of the plot. I am therefore
satisfied that the extension would not have an unacceptable impact on outlook
from No13 and nor would it be unduly overbearing.
17. It is concluded on the fourth main issue that the proposed single storey
extension would have no materially harmful effect on the living conditions of
occupiers of 13 Northaw Road West with respect to outlook. In consequence,
there would be no conflict with LP Policy D1, the NPPF, DLP emerging Policy
SADM11 and the SDG insofar as they expect new development to create a good
standard of amenity for occupiers of buildings and open spaces and in particular
ensure that new development is not overbearing upon existing buildings and
open spaces.
Other considerations
18. The appellant does not suggest any other considerations which might amount
to the very special circumstances necessary to justify the proposal. It is
therefore concluded on the fifth main issue that there are no other
considerations that would clearly outweigh the harm that would be caused to
the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness and the additional harm to its
openness and to the character and appearance of the host dwelling.
Notwithstanding my findings with regard to living conditions, the very special
circumstances necessary to justify the proposed development do not therefore
exist and the proposed extensions would conflict with LP Policies GBSP1 and
RA3, DLP Policy SADM34 and national policy set out in the NPPF.
Other matters and conclusions
19. The appellant suggests that a split decision, allowing the first floor extension,
would be appropriate. However, whilst that extension is above existing
development it has an interface with the proposed single storey rear extension
and so is not clearly physically severable. Therefore, whilst the Council raised
concerns only in respect of the single storey extension, a split decision is not
appropriate in this case.
20. For the reasons set out above and having regard to all other matters raised,
including the lack of objection from Northaw and Cuffley Parish Council, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
K E Down
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.