Demolition of existing detached garage and rear conservatory. Two storey side and rear extension with internal alteration. Amendments to front entrance porch
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 May 2019
by Sarah Manchester BSc MSc PhD MIEnvSc
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 12th June 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/H4505/D/19/3224287
Park House, Strathmore Road, Rowlands Gill Central, Rowlands Gill
NE39 1HX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Atkinson against the decision of Gateshead Council.
• The application Ref DC/18/01153/HHA, dated 13 November 2018, was refused by notice
dated 06 March 2019.
• The development proposed is demolition of existing detached garage and rear
conservatory. Two storey side and rear extension with internal alteration. Amendments
to front entrance porch.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
i) Whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Rowlands Gill Conservation Area; and
ii) The effects of the proposed development on the living conditions of the
neighbouring occupiers of Linddhu House, with regard to light and
outlook.
Reasons
Effect on Rowlands Gill Conservation Area
3. Park House is a double-fronted 2 storey detached property with a simple slate
roof. It is within the Rowlands Gill Conservation Area (RGCA).
4. The RGCA is a predominately Edwardian housing development on the northern
side of the Derwent Valley. It includes both larger detached houses in
substantial gardens, such as are found on Strathmore Road, and smaller
detached and semi-detached properties. Its significance is in part due to the
dominant aesthetic resulting from the limited palette of materials and design
features variously exhibited by buildings through area.
5. The appeal scheme would be a substantial 2 storey side and rear extension
with a gable peak feature. Interim Policy Advice 17: Conservation Area
Character Statements, Strategies and Policy Guidelines Adopted March 2006
Appeal Decision APP/H4505/D/19/3224287
2
(IPA17) state that extensions should respect the original building and should
preserve the integrity of the principal elevation. In this case, gable peaks are
not an original feature of Park House. The gable peak would therefore be an
incongruous addition that would not be in keeping with the host property and it
would not preserve the integrity of the principal elevation.
6. I therefore conclude that the proposed extension would fail to preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. However, the
proposal is modest and it would not be prominent in the context of the
conservation area as a whole. Consequently, it would cause less than
substantial harm to the significance of the conservation area as a designated
heritage asset. Nevertheless, Park House is a private dwelling and there would
be no public benefits that would outweigh the harm to the conservation area. I
therefore conclude that the appeal scheme would be in conflict with the
National Planning Policy Framework.
7. As a result of the harm to the conservation area, the proposal would be in
conflict with the development plan, including Policy CS15 of the Core Strategy
and Urban Core Plan for Gateshead and Newcastle upon Tyne 2010-2030
Adopted March 2015 (the CSUCP), saved Policies ENV3 and ENV7 of the
Unitary Development Plan Adopted July 2010 (the UDP) and Policy IPA17.
These require, among other things, that development makes a positive
contribution to local distinctiveness and character, responds to local design and
conservation guidance and preserves or enhances special architectural or
historic character or appearance.
8. My attention has been drawn to the presence of gable peak features on other
properties in the area, including extensions1. While full details of those cases
are not before me, the inclusion of such features as part of extensions, where
they were an original part of the host properties, would be in accordance with
the policies in the development plan. They are not therefore directly
comparable to the appeal scheme which I have considered on its own merits.
Living Conditions
9. The proposed extension would be in close proximity to the shared boundary
and there would be little separation between the 2 storey side elevation and
the side-facing kitchen window of the neighbouring property. This window is
the principal window serving the kitchen, as the bi-fold doors in the rear
elevation of Linddhu House serve a seating area adjacent to the kitchen and
not the kitchen itself.
10. By virtue of its height and size and limited separation to the habitable room
window, the side extension would be an overbearing and unneighbourly form of
development. Notwithstanding the change in ground levels between the
properties, it would be visually obtrusive and it would result in a poor outlook
from the kitchen window of Linddhu House.
11. Furthermore, as a result of its height, orientation and close relationship to the
neighbouring property, the proposed extension would result in a significant loss
of daylight and sunlight to the side-facing kitchen window. While it is suggested
that any reduction in daylight would be of extremely limited duration, no
substantive evidence has been submitted in this regard. Moreover, my
1 Refs DC/12/01030/HHA and DC/17/00727/HHA
Appeal Decision APP/H4505/D/19/3224287
3
observation is that there would be a significant loss of light to this window on a
regular basis.
12. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would harm the living
conditions of the neighbouring occupiers of Linddhu House. It would be in
conflict with the amenity protection aims of Policy CS14 of the CSUCP and
saved Policy DC2 of the UDP. It would also be in conflict with Gateshead
Council’s Household Alterations and Extensions Supplementary Planning
Document Adopted September 2011. This requires side extensions to have a
minimal impact on neighbouring residential amenity, including with regard to
overbearing, loss of outlook and significant overshadowing.
Other matters
13. I acknowledge the appellant’s desire to enhance the internal living
accommodation and that the extension has been designed to allow for its
possible use as a separate flat at some point in the future. However, the appeal
scheme is for the extension of an individual dwelling and not the creation of a
separate annex. In this respect, no evidence has been presented to
demonstrate that similar benefits could not be delivered with an alternative
scheme such as would not conflict with policies in the development plan.
14. Although the appellant would be willing to remove the gable peak, no amended
plans have been submitted to illustrate the proposal in the absence of this
feature. I cannot therefore be certain that a revised design would mitigate the
harm to the conservation area. In any case, the removal of the gable peak
would not address the harm to the living conditions of the neighbouring
occupiers.
15. While the side-facing window of Linddhu House may have served a utility room
in the past, it is nevertheless the principal window of a habitable room.
Therefore, although I appreciate the appellant’s concerns in respect of
overlooking of the rear of the appeal property from this window, this is not a
matter which would justify allowing a scheme that would conflict with policies
in the development plan.
Conclusions
16. For the reasons set out above, and having regard to all other matters, the
appeal is dismissed.
Sarah Manchester
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.