Mansard roof level extension to existing end of terrace, privately owned, single family dwelling house

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Extensions
Character & Appearance
Heritage & Conservation

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 11 June 2019 by Kate Mansell BA (Hons) MPhil MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 2nd July 2019 Appeal Ref: APP/N5660/D/19/3224165 49 Hinton Road, London SE24 0HR • The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission. • The appeal is made by Ms Tamsin Growney against the decision of the Council of the London Borough of Lambeth. • The application Ref 18/04521/FUL, dated 18 October 2018, was refused by notice dated 13 December 2018. • The development proposed is described as ‘mansard roof level extension to existing end of terrace, privately owned, single family dwelling house’. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issue 2. The main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the host property and the surrounding area. Reasons. 3. Hinton Road is a largely residential street characterised by mainly traditional terraced houses that incorporate a variety of ornate details, including ground floor bays, recessed front doors and decorative lintels. They range from between two and three storeys and are generally set back modestly from the road. Roof types vary between hips and gables as well as ‘butterfly’ roofs set behind a parapet. Typically constructed in a buff brick, a number of dwellings have been painted or rendered to create a characterful street. 4. The appeal site is a two-storey end of terrace corner property on a broadly triangular plot that presents a front elevation to Hinton Road, with a longer splayed side elevation facing Alderton Road. It has an irregular hipped roof that accommodates the asymmetrical shape of the property as it addresses both streets. The appeal proposal would replace the existing roof with a gable ended extension, including raising the main ridge and eaves level, and a rear mansard roof extension with a dormer window. It would include the installation of a side window and two front rooflights. The height of the chimney would be retained as existing. 5. The Council’s Building Alterations and Extensions Supplementary Planning Document (2015) (Extensions SPD) provides specific guidance on roof alterations and extensions. It advises that hip to gable extensions should not harm the design integrity of the original building or lead to a loss of spatial Appeal Decision APP/N5660/D/19/3224165 2 character. In relation to rear mansard extensions, the guidance states that where visible front roof pitches and hipped ends contribute positively to the group character of buildings or a wider street scene, their loss or alteration will be resisted. It also notes that in pairs or groups of buildings, raising the roof ridge will not be acceptable. 6. There are gable ends within the locality and I appreciate that they are not an uncommon feature. Indeed, No 51 Hinton Road, on the opposite corner to the appeal site, has a London pitched roof with a gabled side wall. They are also evident at Nos 37, 64, 106, 118 and 124 Hinton Road. There are further examples cited by the appellant on Alderton Road, as well as Wingmore Road, Poplar Road, Milkwood Road, Wanless Road and Herne Hill Road nearby. 7. However, from my observations, the appeal property is an unusual shape, with the rear elevation being wider than the front. Furthermore, the existing roof to No 49 has a relatively low profile and successfully and unobtrusively provides the mechanism for the dwelling to turn the corner at roof level. Consequently, whilst it is neither a designated heritage asset nor within a Conservation Area, the appearance of the appeal property, including its roof form, is individual and it contributes positively to the composition of the terrace and the wider area. 8. Whilst the street scene visual from Alderton Road indicates that in views along this street, the ridge height of the proposal would not be dissimilar to those within the vicinity, it would, nonetheless, substantially change the scale and form of the existing roof. Consequently, it would detract from the appearance and integrity of the host dwelling, with its presently unaltered roof profile. Furthermore, as the appeal property sits on the corner and forward of the front elevation of the adjacent terrace at 1-8 Alderton Road, the gable and rear mansard/dormer would be particularly prominent in views from the side and rear elevation. 9. I recognise that there are already small changes in height between the eaves and ridge line of the host property and its neighbour. This slight differentiation is evident in the locality, including on other properties along the street and on Alderton Road, but it is characterised by being a minor step. The street scene visual along Hinton Road shows the appeal scheme from a more oblique angle. However, in comparison to the existing form, the proposal would increase the eaves and ridge height by approximately 0.45m, which would result in a much greater and more noticeable transition to the neighbouring property. This would, in my view, appear incongruous as a result, particularly in more direct views in front of the host dwelling. 10. In relation to the two roof lights, whilst I observed that they were not a common feature on properties within the street, they would not, as a consequence of their size and position on the front roof, be unduly visible. Similarly, the new window to Alderton Road would be of modest size. Nevertheless, they form an integral part of the appeal proposal and cannot, therefore, be distinguished from it. 11. I have also had regard to the appellant’s contention that a hip to gable roof alteration could be undertaken as permitted development. However, I have nothing before me to show me what such a scheme would look like. It is Appeal Decision APP/N5660/D/19/3224165 3 therefore a matter to which I afford limited weight. I also understand that the existing roof is constructed in concrete tiles that have contributed to the bowing of the existing roof. Whilst they may require repair/replacement, I have nothing before me to indicate that the proposal is the only means to do so. It is therefore not a matter that weighs in the scheme’s favour. 12. Furthermore, I appreciate that the character of the locality may be changing and subject to new development, such as the contemporary ‘Peabody’ development nearby. Additionally, the appellant has cited four examples of roof extensions to nearby properties which, as a result, have a different height to their neighbours. I note the dormer extension to 70 Hinton Road, but it is a mid-terrace house rather than a corner property and the roof is behind an existing parapet. The properties at No 4 Deerdale Road, No 11 Wingmore Road and No 9 Kemerton Road are also mid-terraces and they do not include a hip to gable extension to a corner property. For these reasons, I do not find them directly comparable and, in any event, I must consider the proposal before me on its individual merits. 13. Taking all these factors into consideration, I conclude that the proposal would be harmful to the character and appearance of the host property and the surrounding area. It would be contrary to Policies Q5 and Q11 of the Lambeth Local Plan (September 2015). These policies require, amongst other matters, proposals to respond positively to local context and to the original architecture, including to existing roof form and roofscapes and to not dominate the host building. It would also be contrary to guidance within the Council’s Extensions SPD, in respect of mansards and roof extensions, including the need to achieve sub-ordination and protect the design integrity of the host dwelling. I also find that the proposal would be contrary to Policies 3.5, 7.4 and 7.6 of The London Plan (March 2016), cited by the appellant. Whilst Policy 3.5 relates more generally to housing developments, these policies broadly seek to secure high quality design that is appropriate to its context and to local character. 14. The appellant has referred to policies within the draft, revised Lambeth Local Plan (October 2018) and also generally to the draft London Plan (December 2017). However, as emerging plans, it limits the weight that can be afforded to them and in any event, I have nothing before me to indicate that a different approach to the main issue should be taken as a result. Other Matters 15. I appreciate that the proposal would seek to optimise the existing dwelling’s potential. I also understand the appellant’s desire to create additional space to enable them to remain within their home. However, planning decisions are taken in the public interest and therefore, these personal circumstances do not, in my view, outweigh the harm that I have identified previously. Conclusion 16. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. Kate Mansell INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →