Creation of an extension to the basement toward the front, rear and southern sides, to include a bedroom, family room, laundry, wine storage, plant room, storage, courtyards and study; to lower the front garden to basement level to create a courtyard; to construct a rear and side ground floor extension including the creation of windows to the rear façade; and revision of the ground floor layout including a W.C., stair and revised kitchen
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 9 May 2019
by J D Westbrook BSc(Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 24 May 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/K5600/D/19/3223497
37 Yeomans Row, London, SW3 2AL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs R and L Ogle against the decision of the Council of
the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea.
• The application Ref PP/18/07577, dated 21 November 2018, was refused by notice
dated 17 January 2019.
• The development proposed is the creation of an extension to the basement toward the
front, rear and southern sides, to include a bedroom, family room, laundry, wine
storage, plant room, storage, courtyards and study; to lower the front garden to
basement level to create a courtyard; to construct a rear and side ground floor
extension including the creation of windows to the rear façade; and revision of the
ground floor layout including a W.C., stair and revised kitchen.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. It would appear that all of the works proposed in this scheme, with the
exception of the lowering of the front garden to create a courtyard/lightwell,
have been previously permitted by the Council. There are therefore no issues
of concern with the scheme other than those relating to the courtyard/lightwell,
and, as a consequence, the main issue is the effect of the proposed front
courtyard/lightwell on the character and appearance of the Thurloe Estate and
Smith’s Charity Conservation Area (CA)
Reasons
3. No 37 is a link semi-detached house situated on the eastern side of Yeomans
Row. It is part of a group of similar houses at the southern end of the road,
and is a three-storey dwelling with additional accommodation in a mansard
roof. Much of the road is typified by 2/3 storey terraces set close to the back
of the pavement with shallow lightwells behind iron railings. The group of
houses, of which No 37 forms a part is set further back from the pavement and
has brick planters to the front boundaries with paved areas between the
planter and the front elevations. The bulk of Yeomans Row, including the
appeal site, lies within the CA.
4. The Council contends that the large lightwell proposed to the front of the
property would be uncharacteristic in the streetscene and would fail to preserve
the character or appearance of the property or conservation area. The
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/19/3223497
2
appellants contend that front lightwells are a significant feature of the
properties along Yeomans Row.
5. I acknowledge the existence of lightwells to the front of most of the terraced
properties along the road. However, these properties are set close to the
pavement edge, and there is a degree of homogeneity in the design features
within the various rows of terraces, all of them also having iron railings to the
front boundary. By way of contrast, the group of closely linked semi-detached
houses that includes No 37 is set further back from the pavement edge, and
none of the houses currently have front lightwells. A feature of the group is
the uninterrupted paved frontages between the front boundary planters and
the front elevations, albeit some having glazed elements, presumably to
provide light to basement areas.
6. The proposed lightwell at No 37 would occupy the northern half of its front
paved area and would require the erection of an iron balustrade between the
front planter and the front of the house for safety reasons. It would appear
that the balustrade would closely match the design of the front gate.
7. The appellants contend that the presence of the front planter would render the
lightwell almost invisible from views from the pavement and that it would not,
therefore, be harmful to the appearance of the area. However, from my site
visit, it is clear that the areas between the planters and the fronts of the
houses are visible from the vicinity of each of the many front gates along the
row, and the security balustrade would represent an incongruous permanent
feature in these otherwise unobstructed areas. The lightwell and balustrade
would appear out of character in the context of the rest of the group of houses.
8. The appellants also note the existence of a planning permission for a lightwell
to the front of a property in the London Borough of Lambeth. However, it
would appear that this example relates to a house in an area with a mixed
architectural scene and where the lightwell would be a small feature in an
otherwise large front garden. For these reasons, it cannot be compared with
this current proposal at No 37 and I have, in any case, considered this proposal
on its own merits.
9. In the light of the above, I conclude that the proposed front lightwell at No 37
would be a discordant feature in the streetscene along this part of Yeomans
Row, and that it would therefore fail to preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the CA. On this basis it would conflict with Policies CL1 and CL2
of the Council’s Local Plan (LP), which require development to respect local
context; Policy CL3 of the LP, which requires development to preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of a conservation area; and Policy CL7 of
the LP, which requires that basement developments should not introduce light
wells and railings to the front or side of the property where they would
seriously harm the character and appearance of the locality.
J D Westbrook
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.