2 storey front extension, replacement rear conservatory, and remodelling of the existing house
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape
Green Belt Policy
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 April 2019
by Penelope Metcalfe BA(Hons) MSc DipUP DipDBE MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 30 April 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/Q3115/D/19/3223443
Toyes, Port Hill, Nettlebed, Henley-on Thames, RG9 5RL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs J Blundell against the decision of South Oxfordshire
District Council.
• The application Ref P18/S2402/HH, dated 6 July 2018, was refused by notice dated
4 December 2018.
• The development proposed is 2 storey front extension, replacement rear conservatory,
and remodelling of the existing house.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main issue
2. I consider that the main issue in this case is its effect on the character and
appearance of the area.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a detached two storey house constructed in the Arts and
Crafts style in the early 20th century, with later extensions to the sides and the
entrance elevation. It is located in a large triangular plot and partially
screened from the road by trees and a high acoustic fence. It is one of a
number of dwellings scattered in a small linear group along the A4130. It is
within the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. A footpath runs along
the southern boundary and the surroundings are rural in character with a mix
of open agricultural land and woodland.
4. The relevant policies in this case include policies G2, D1 and H13 of the South
Oxfordshire Local Plan 2011 (the local plan) and CSQ3 and CSEN1 of the South
Oxfordshire Core Strategy 2012 (the Core Strategy).
5. Policy G2 is a general policy to protect the environment, D1 relates to good
design and H13 allows for extensions to dwellings provided, among other
things, that their scale and design is in keeping with the character of the
dwelling. Policy CSQ3 requires new development to be of high quality design
and CSEN1 seeks to protect landscape character against inappropriate
development.
Appeal Decision APP/Q3115/D/19/3223443
2
6. The Council’s Supplementary Planning Document South Oxfordshire Design
Guide (the SPD) advises that front extensions will be resisted where they are
damaging to the appearance of a dwelling and are more likely to be acceptable
if they are modest in scale.
7. The National Planning Policy Framework 2018 (the Framework) places great
weight on conserving and enhancing the landscape beauty in Areas of
Outstanding Natural Beauty.
8. The Council has raised no objection to the proposed rear alterations and
replacement conservatory and I see no reason to disagree with that view.
9. The original drawings of 1913 show that what is now the front (east) elevation
of the house was originally the rear elevation. The west elevation was
described as the front, while the north elevation faces the road and had the
entrance door. The present front elevation had a simple, symmetrical form
with a central projecting gable typical of its period and was clearly designed as
an important elevation although it was not the principal (west) one, which
faces the garden.
10. The front elevation is perpendicular to the main road and faces the entrance
drive. It is visible from the road and also from the footpath/track which runs
along the south boundary of the site. Although the north elevation is largely
screened from the road by the fence and trees, its existing gable is visible
above the fence.
11. I consider that the scale and design of the proposed two storey front extension
would be out of keeping with the character of the house. Its projection of
approximately 8m from the original main wall would be significantly greater
than that of the original gable of approximately 1.9m. Its height, depth and
overall mass would result in a bulky addition to the front of the house, which
would appear out of proportion with the existing building and wholly out of
keeping with the simple and modest Arts and Crafts style of the original design.
12. On the basis of the submitted plans, it appears to me that the extension would
be unnecessarily large in the context of the accommodation to be provided.
The intention is to provide a fifth bedroom on the first floor of the extension
and a larger family bathroom. The existing fifth bedroom on the ground floor
would be converted to the kitchen. In addition to the new bedroom, the first
floor would accommodate two shower rooms and the stairs. The existing
commonly accessible bathroom and WC would become part of the circulation
area. The first floor plans show five bedrooms or possibly four bedrooms and a
study, and five bath or shower rooms, four of which are en suite. It is unclear
from the plans whether the only space shown as containing a bath, which is en
suite to the existing Bedroom 1, and might reasonably be expected to be the
family bathroom, is in fact intended as such.
13. The form and appearance of the original cottage have been somewhat
overwhelmed by the subsequent insensitive extensions and the alterations to
the fenestration, and the proposed demolition of the additions to the front
would help to restore some of the original simplicity of design and allow the
original form of the front gable to be expressed. However, the size and scale
of the proposed front extension would be such that it would dominate the front
elevation in a manner which would be equally insensitive to the original
character and appearance of the building.
Appeal Decision APP/Q3115/D/19/3223443
3
14. Although the property is mainly viewed in glimpses from the road, it is also
visible from the footpath. The bulk and massing of the front extension would
be visible from the front and also, to a lesser extent, as a long high roofline
against the more modest north gable above the fence by the road. I consider
that this increase in built form would not integrate well with the rural landscape
character of this part of the AONB.
15. I conclude that the proposed two storey front extension would not respect the
character and appearance of the building itself and would not conserve or
enhance the AONB. It is therefore contrary to policies G2, D1 and H13 of the
local plan and CSQ3 and CSEN1 of the Core Strategy, the SPD and the
Framework.
16. For the reasons given above, the appeal is dismissed.
PAG Metcalfe
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.