First floor side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 April 2019
by A Blicq BSc (Hons) MA CMLI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 April 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/G5750/D/19/3223051
9 Vine Road, Stratford, London E15 4HH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Mohammed Razaq against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Newham.
• The application Ref 18/02987/HH, dated 29 September 2018, was refused by notice
dated 28 November 2018.
• The development proposed is first floor side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. During the appeal the Council advised that the Core Strategy1 and
Development Plan Document2 policies cited in the decision notice are no longer
applicable. I have not referred to these policies. The decision notice also cited
policies from the Draft London Plan. As these may yet change, I have given
them limited weight.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the development on:
• The living conditions of occupiers of dwellings of 26 and 28 Hartland Road,
with particular regard to outlook and light; and,
• The character and appearance of the area.
Reasons
Living conditions
4. Number 9 Vine Road (No 9) fronts a triangular plot which tapers to the rear.
There is an existing single storey side extension which extends almost as far as
the plot boundary and which effectively abuts the short rear gardens of
terraced dwellings on Hartland Road. The development would comprise a first
floor extension, situated above the single storey side extension.
5. From the front the extension would appear notably narrower than the ground
floor extension. However, towards the rear it would extend as far as the plot
1 Newham Local Plan Core Strategy January 2012
2 Newham Local Plan Detailed Sites and Policies Development Plan Document October 2016
Appeal Decision APP/G5750/D/19/3223051
2
boundary and would have a canted corner. Although this is not apparent from
the side elevation, it is apparent from the floor plans. Given the limited
separation between No 9 and 26 and 28 Hartland Road (Nos 26 and 28), the
extension would represent a disproportionate intrusion into that space.
6. Although I have noticed some inconsistency between drawings insofar as scale
is concerned, the site location plan indicates that the distance between No 9’s
side boundary and the rear of Nos 26 and 28, is considerably less than the
10 metres cited by the appellant. This observation is supported by evidence
from interested parties and my site visit.
7. The appellant argues that No 9 already has a significant overbearing effect for
occupiers of dwellings fronting Hartland Road and that concerns expressed by
interested parties should be given little weight. However, there is existing
openness above the single storey extension and this would be considerably
reduced if the appeal was allowed. The fact that there may be existing
intrusion to the detriment of living conditions does not justify aggravating the
harm by introducing further extensions into the space separating the building
lines. In fact, within such a tight development pattern where existing buildings
already affect outlook and overshadowing to a notable degree, it is appropriate
to pay more attention to the living conditions of occupiers of nearby dwellings.
8. As the rear gardens of dwellings fronting Hartland Road are particularly short, I
conclude that the extension would be overbearing and would significantly
obstruct sunlight and daylight. This would have a detrimental effect on the
living conditions of occupiers of Nos 26 and 28 with regard to outlook and light.
9. In the light of the above, the extension would therefore be contrary to the
SPD3 which requires development to be neighbourly, amongst other
considerations, and Policy SP8 of the 2018 Local Plan4 (LP) which seeks to
ensure that change brought about by development does not cause problems for
existing lawful uses and to minimise any overshadowing and overbearing
impact, amongst other aims and objectives.
10. LP Policies S1, S2, SP1, SP2, SP3 and H1 are concerned primarily with spatial
strategy and strategic development, including new housing. Policies 7.4 and
7.6 of the London Plan are also cited but these are primarily concerned with
design. These policies are less specific than those I have referred to and carry
little weight in my deliberations. The Council has also cited the National
Planning Policy Framework which is generally supportive of the policies given
above.
Character and appearance
11. The extension would be set back from the host dwelling’s front elevation and
its ridgeline would be lower than that of the host dwelling. When viewed from
the front and the rear it would appear subservient to the host dwelling.
However, from angled and side views from dwellings on Hartland Road the full
extent of the extension to the side boundary would be apparent. The section of
angled wall in particular would appear poorly designed and awkward, and
unrelated to the overall form of the host dwelling. Moreover, there is
inconsistency between the elevations and the floor plans which suggests that
3 Newham’s Local Plan SPD Altering and Extending your Home February 2018
4 Newham Local Plan 2018
Appeal Decision APP/G5750/D/19/3223051
3
the roof form could be built as shown. This reinforces my concern with regard
to design.
12. I conclude that the extent of the extension would appear inappropriately close
to the building line of Hartland Road, and that it would also appear poorly
designed. It would have an adverse effect on the character and appearance of
the area.
13. Consequently, the development would be contrary to the design aims of
Policies 7.1, 7.4 and 7.6 of the London Plan, as well as LP Policies S1, S2, SP1,
SP2, SP3, SP8 and H1 insofar as these are concerned with design and the
reinforcement of local character, and the SPD. Policy 7.5 of the London Plan
appears to be concerned with public realm open space and as such weighs
nether for nor against the appeal. The Council has also cited the National
Planning Policy Framework which is generally supportive of the policies given
above.
Other matters
14. The appellant argues that there are similar first floor extensions within the
locality but none have been identified and I did not see any at my visit.
15. The appellant has also highlighted other appeal decisions. However, although I
have copies of the appeal decisions I do not have the plans or information
regarding the particular circumstances of those appeals before me. In any
case, although they are both in Newham, they do not appear to be close to the
appeal site and I am unable to determine whether the situations are directly
comparable. In any case, each appeal is determined on its merits.
16. The evidence before me includes an aerial view taken from Google. However,
the distances between the building lines on the aerial view appears greater
than that shown on the site location plan which, from the grid lines, appears to
be taken from Ordnance Survey data. As such I cannot be sure that the
Google view is an accurate representation and I give this limited weight.
Conclusion
17. In the light of the above I conclude that the development would be contrary to
the relevant policies of the Local Plan and that therefore the appeal should be
dismissed.
Amanda Blicq
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.