Part two storey side extension and single storey rear extension; conversion of roofspace to habitable use, involving replacement roof, 2 front dormers and 2 rear dormers; erection of open porch to front; part conversion of garage including associated alterations and landscaping to the front and rear
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 April 2019
by Martin Andrews MA(Planning) BSc(Econ) DipTP & DipTP(Dist) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 May 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/R5510/D/19/3222615
7 Hedgeside Road, Northwood HA6 2NX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Ashita Patel against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Hillingdon.
• The application, Ref. 38605/APP/2018/3552, dated 4 October 2018, was refused by
notice dated 7 December 2018.
• The development proposed is a part two storey side extension and single storey rear
extension; conversion of roofspace to habitable use, involving replacement roof, 2 front
dormers and 2 rear dormers; erection of open porch to front; part conversion of garage
including associated alterations and landscaping to the front and rear.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter and Main Issues
2. There is an extant permission for the alteration and extension of the appeal
dwelling under permission reference 38605/APP/2017/554 dated 15 November
2017. Whilst this serves both as a ‘fallback position’ for the appellant and in
part informs the appraisal of the appeal scheme, the latter must nonetheless be
assessed afresh in terms of the main issues arising from the Council’s Notice of
Refusal.
3. These are (i) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the
existing dwelling and the street scene of Hedgeside Road; (ii) the effect on the
living conditions for the occupiers of No. 9 Hedgeside Road as regards outlook
and light, and (iii) the adequacy of living conditions for future occupiers of the
dwelling in terms of outlook and light in the proposed ‘formal lounge’.
Reasons
4. On the first issue, the grounds of appeal illustrate that as regards footprint and
the overall extent of the profile of the front elevation the appeal scheme would
not be much larger than that already approved. However, within that
ostensibly minor difference, the current proposal does result in much more
substantial changes to the original building.
5. These are summarised in the officer’s report and include raising the walls to
create a formal eaves line on all four elevations. Below this, the previously
approved fenestration would be retained as first floor windows, whilst above it
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/19/3222615
2
there would be two pairs of small box dormers at the front and the rear to
provide light and an outlook for the enlarged roof space.
6. Further changes to the approved front elevation involve the forward projection
of the garage and the inclusion of a flat roofed canopy across the greater part of
the frontage together with the introduction of ‘classical columns’ on either side
of the front door. At the rear, the corner nearest to No. 9 would be squared off.
7. The amended proposals to the approved scheme would in my view result in the
original dwelling being extended in a form that no longer complies with the
requirement of the Council’s HDAS Residential Extension guidelines for
extensions and alterations to be subordinate to, and in keeping with, the host
building. The change in the dwelling’s appearance would result in a more
formal, rectilinear and assertive front elevation that would be accentuated by
the introduction of a wholly rendered finish to the walls and the fact that No. 7
has an elevated siting relative to the road. On a point of detail, the pastiche
porch columns would be an incongruous addition.
8. The approved scheme, despite the loss of the catslide roof, retained a
substantial element of the dwelling’s original character whereas this would be
entirely lost in the current proposal. And whilst I saw on my visit that the
street scene of Hedgeside Road does include a considerable variety of building
types, designs and materials, I am minded to agree with the Council’s
objections that the loss of the existing character and the change in appearance
would be detrimental rather than complementary to the street scene. I have
also noted the point made by the occupiers of No. 9 that the two buildings were
originally built as a pair and that the proposed radical change in No. 7’s
appearance would jar with its neighbour given their close proximity.
9. When taken overall, and having given careful consideration to the points raised
in the grounds of appeal, my conclusion on issue (i) is that the proposal would
have an unacceptable effect on the character and appearance of the existing
dwelling and the street scene of Hedgeside Road. This would conflict with Policy
BE1 of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part One – Strategic Policies 2012; Policies
BE13, BE15 & BE19 of the Local Plan: Part Two – Saved UDP Policies 2012; the
Council’s HDAS Residential Extension SPD Guidelines, and Section 12:
‘Achieving Well-Designed Places’ of the National Planning Policy Framework
2019.
10. Turning briefly to issues (ii) and (iii), in respect of the former I am not
persuaded that the squaring off of the right hand rear corner of the building and
the changes to the upper elevations and roof would have a materially different
effect to the outlook and light for the occupiers of No. 9 than that already
accepted by the Council under the extant permission.
11. As regards issue (iii), I agree that the light and outlook in the ‘formal lounge’
would be limited, but as this would be one habitable room in a substantial
dwelling this is more a matter for the occupants than a public interest concern
within the planning system as to the adequacy of living conditions. I therefore
see no harmful conflict with Local Plan Policies BE19, BE20 & BE21 and the
HDAS guidance. However, my favourable conclusion for the appellant on these
two issues does not outweigh the harm to the host dwelling and the street
scene that would be caused in respect of issue (i).
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/19/3222615
3
12. For the reasons explained above and having considered all other matters raised,
I conclude that the appeal should fail.
Martin Andrews
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.