Two storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 April 2019
by Jillian Rann BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 May 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/Z4718/D/19/3221297
4 Meadow Lane, Slaithwaite, Huddersfield HD7 5EX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Adam Rout against the decision of Kirklees Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 2018/62/92598/W, dated 26 July 2018, was refused by notice dated
12 November 2018.
• The development proposed is a two storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. Since the application was refused, the Kirklees Local Plan (the Local Plan) has
been adopted, on 27 February 2019. The policies referred to in the Council’s
reasons for refusal as being from ‘the publication draft Local Plan’ are therefore
now adopted. The Council has confirmed that the Kirklees Unitary Development
Plan (the UDP) has been superseded, and that any UDP policies referred to in
the reasons for refusal should therefore be disregarded. I have considered the
appeal accordingly, and have given both main parties the opportunity to
comment on this matter.
3. In reaching my decision I have also had regard to the revised updated National
Planning Policy Framework, 19 February 2019 (the Framework). The revisions
to the Framework do not materially alter the national policy approach in
respect of the particular issues raised in this appeal compared with the
previous version, published 24 July 2018, which both parties have previously
considered. References throughout this decision are to the 2019 Framework.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
• the character and appearance of the appeal site and its surroundings;
• the living conditions of the occupants of 6 Meadow Lane with regard to
outlook and light.
Appeal Decision APP/Z4718/D/19/3221297
2
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal relates to a two storey, semi-detached stone house of relatively
recent construction, which is part of a development of similar residential
properties. The appeal property is part of a courtyard of two storey and four
storey houses at the entrance to that development, close to the junction of
Meadow Lane and Meal Hill Lane. Notwithstanding some differences in their
height, those neighbouring properties and others further along Meadow Lane
are relatively consistent in their appearance, with compact, rectangular
footprints, simple, symmetrical pitched roofs and small, projecting gable
features to their front elevations. Whilst differing in other aspects of their
appearance, other older houses in the vicinity of the site also share the same
regular footprints and simple, symmetrical pitched roof forms as the appeal site
and its immediate neighbours.
6. In contrast, the proposed extension would have an irregularly-shaped footprint,
widening from front to rear, and would be made up of different components
with differing widths and roof forms. Whilst the two storey section would have
a gable to the rear, its roof would be somewhat complex in form compared to
neighbouring dwellings, made up of numerous different interconnecting
sections of varying sizes and angles. That section would also be taller at the
rear than the front, in contrast to the regular, level ridge of the main house.
The flat-roofed rear section, whilst of limited scale, would introduce a further
roof form, different again to that of the main building and of the two storey
part of the extension.
7. As a result, the extension would have an awkward and irregular appearance,
which would not reflect the simpler building forms which characterise the
appeal dwelling and other houses in the wider street scene. It would be visible
to some degree from the courtyard to the front of the site and, despite the
presence of planting within the site’s rear garden, would also be highly
prominent in wider public views along Meal Hill Lane, which runs immediately
to the rear of the site. In those public views, the extension would appear as an
unsympathetic and highly discordant addition, which would cause harm to the
character and appearance of the appeal building and its surroundings.
8. With its timber-clad walls and sedum roof, the materials of the proposed
extension would contrast with those of the appeal building and other stone
houses further along Meadow Lane. However, the site is located on the outer
edge of that wider estate and the extension would be positioned such that the
most prominent public views of the development would be along Meal Hill Lane
to the rear. In that wider street scene, I observed some greater variety in
building materials, including the incorporation of sections of white boarded
cladding to the older houses on the opposite side of the Meadow Lane junction.
9. The appeal property is one of the last houses on Meal Hill Lane before it leads
out into open countryside, and its rear elevation faces an area of open land
opposite. As a result of the steeply sloping gradient of Meal Hill Lane and the
fields beyond, the site and its immediate neighbours are viewed against the
attractive backdrop of that open countryside when travelling out of Slaithwaite
along Meal Hill Lane.
Appeal Decision APP/Z4718/D/19/3221297
3
10. In that context, the use of timber boarding and a sedum roof would make
some reference to the buildings and natural features of the rural landscape
opposite and beyond the site, and provide some sense of transition between
the built-up area and that adjacent rural landscape as the housing along Meal
Hill Lane tapers out into the countryside. Therefore, and having regard to the
variety of materials evident elsewhere in the wider street scene, the proposed
materials would distinguish the extension from the host property without
causing harm to its character and appearance, or those of its wider
surroundings.
11. However, whilst I find no specific harm arising from the proposed materials,
that does not alter my conclusions regarding the harm I have identified as a
result of the unduly complex, irregular and discordant form of the extension.
Therefore, for the reasons given, I conclude that the extension would have an
adverse effect on the character and appearance of the appeal site and its
surroundings. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policy PLP 24 a. of the
Local Plan which, amongst other things, states that proposals should promote
good design by ensuring the form and details of all development respects the
character of the townscape.
12. The proposal would also conflict with the Framework, which states that
planning decisions should ensure that developments are sympathetic to local
character, including the surrounding built environment.
Living conditions
13. The extension would be close to the boundary with No 6 Meadow Lane, and
parts of it would be visible from the rear garden of that neighbouring property
which, I observed, is relatively small in size. However, the two storey part of
the extension would project no further than the rear elevation of No 6, and the
single storey ground floor section would extend only slightly beyond the rear of
that neighbouring property. For much of its depth, including all of its first floor,
the proposed extension would therefore be positioned alongside the drive of
No 6, rather than immediately adjacent to its private rear garden area.
Consequently, and as the only section extending directly alongside No 6’s rear
garden would be a single storey component of limited depth, the extension
would not appear as an unduly dominant or overbearing feature, or create a
sense of enclosure to that neighbouring rear garden.
14. I have had regard to the appellant’s overshadowing study, and recognise that
the development, roughly to the south of No 6, may result in some additional
shading of parts of that small neighbouring rear garden at certain times.
However, the main bulk and mass of the extension would be located adjacent
to No 6’s drive, and it would not project directly alongside No 6’s rear garden
to any significant degree. The extension’s roof would also be lower than the
ridge of the existing appeal building which, itself, is located at a lower level
than No 6. Therefore, any additional shading of that neighbouring rear garden
which may arise, over and above that already caused by the existing appeal
building, would not be of such an extent or duration as to significantly or
adversely affect the living conditions of the occupants of No 6, or compromise
their use or enjoyment of that garden area.
15. For the reasons given, I therefore conclude that the proposed development
would not have an adverse effect on the living conditions of the occupants of
6 Meadow Drive with regard to outlook or light. The proposal would therefore
Appeal Decision APP/Z4718/D/19/3221297
4
not conflict with Policy PLP24 (b) of the Local Plan which, amongst other things,
states that proposals should promote good design by ensuring they provide a
high standard of amenity for neighbouring occupiers. That requirement is
consistent with the Framework, which states that planning decisions should
ensure that developments create places with a high standard of amenity for
existing and future users.
Other Matters
16. I have been referred to a number of other extensions in contrasting materials
and of differing appearances elsewhere in Slaithwaite. However, I have little
before me with regard to the circumstances in which those developments were
constructed, and cannot be certain that they were directly comparable in all
respects to the proposal before me. In any event, I have considered the appeal
on its own planning merits.
Conclusion
17. Whilst I have not found harm to living conditions, the absence of harm in that
respect does not outweigh the harm I have identified with regard to character
and appearance.
18. Therefore, for the reasons given and having regard to all other matters raised,
the appeal is dismissed.
Jillian Rann
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.