Single storey front, side and rear extension; open air swimming pool to rear
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Fallback Position
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 March 2019
by Chris Baxter BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 26 April 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/N4720/D/18/3219303
Caley Manor, Pool Road, Otley LS21 1EE
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr A and Mrs S Page against the decision of Leeds City Council.
• The application Ref 18/03522/FU, dated 4 June 2018, was refused by notice dated
22 November 2018.
• The development proposed is single storey front, side and rear extension; open air
swimming pool to rear.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. For the sake of brevity and clarity I have used in the banner heading the
description of development as provided in the Council’s decision notice.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
i. whether the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt;
ii. the effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt; and
iii. if the development is inappropriate, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. Policy N33 of the Leeds Unitary Development Plan 2006 (UDP) and Policy HDG3
of the Leeds Householder Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document
2012 (SPD) relate to development within the Green Belt. These policies allow
limited extensions, additions and alterations to dwellings within the Green Belt
which do not harm openness. Policy HDG3 further states that limited
development should not exceed 30% of the original house volume.
5. Paragraph 145 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
states that Council’s should regard the construction of new buildings as
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/18/3219303
2
inappropriate in Green Belt, unless the development falls within the exceptions
list. This list includes the extension or alteration of a building provided that it
does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the
original building.
6. The appeal property has been previously extended, including large dormer
windows, side and rear extensions and a detached garage. The Council have
stated that these extensions amount to approximately 50% increase in the
volume of the original house. The appellant does not contest this. The proposal
would have a volume of 1285.83 cubic metres (m3). From the evidence
submitted and my observations at my site visit I consider that the proposal
would result in additions to the original building that would be substantially
disproportionate.
7. The proposed development would therefore be inappropriate development in
the Green Belt and as such conflicts with the UDP Policy N33, SPD Policy HDG3
and paragraph 145 of the Framework which seek to safeguard Green Belt from
encroachment.
Openness
8. The Framework makes clear that inappropriate development is, by definition,
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. It also states that one of the essential characteristics of Green
Belt is their openness.
9. The openness of the Green Belt is clearly evident around the existing building
and in that the bulk of the building would be increased by the proposed
extension, then the proposal would reduce openness. The proposal would be
contained within the residential curtilage of the appeal site and would only be
visible from the immediate surrounding area and not visible from wider views.
The incremental enlargement of built development in this location would have a
small but negative effect on the openness of the Green Belt. Paragraph 133 of
the Framework indicates that openness is an essential characteristic of the
Green Belt. For this reason, there would be a degree of harm arising from this,
in addition to that arising from the inappropriate nature of the development.
Other considerations
10. The appellant has provided a site plan which shows that a different scheme
could be constructed under permitted development rights. This alterative
scheme would encroach further into the garden area and would have an overall
volume of 408.43 m3 more than the volume of the proposed extension. A
deposit payment appears to have been made to a building contractor which
shows commitment to the permitted development scheme being constructed
should the appeal fail for the proposed scheme. I therefore consider that there
is a fallback position in terms of the permitted development scheme as
outbuildings are a conventional way of providing additional habitable
accommodation associated with dwellings.
11. Planning conditions cannot come into effect if a permission has not been
implemented. Consequently, a condition cannot prevent permitted
development rights being exercised before commencement. The appropriate
mechanism to secure this would be to complete a Section 106 legal obligation
in which the appellant agrees to forgo permitted development rights
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/18/3219303
3
immediately the planning permission is granted. No such legal undertaking has
been submitted in support of the appealed proposal. Therefore, there is no
mechanism before me that would prevent permitted development outbuildings
from being erected at the site. I acknowledge the suggested condition put
forward by the Council that seeks to remove existing permitted development
rights prior to the implementation of this proposed development. However,
given the considerations above I would not advocate the Council’s approach.
Consequently, no off-setting development has been secured, therefore, whilst
having regard to the Court Judgement1 and acknowledging that the permitted
development scheme is a realistic possibility, this does not offer any weight in
favour of the proposal.
12. I have had regard to the examples of appeal decisions and the Certificate of
Lawful Development (ref: 11/02383/CLP) which have been submitted by the
appellant. However, I do not have full details of the circumstances that led to
these proposals being accepted and so cannot be sure that they represent a
direct parallel to the appeal proposal, including with regards to the acceptability
of planning conditions with regards to removal of permitted development
rights. I have therefore attached little weight to these matters in the
consideration of the appeal.
Green Belt Balance and Conclusion
13. The proposed development would be inappropriate development and the
Framework establishes that substantial weight should be given to any harm to
the Green Belt. In addition, there would be a degree of harm in terms of loss of
openness. Even when taken together, the other considerations reviewed above
do not clearly outweigh the Green Belt harm and therefore no very special
circumstances exist. The appeal scheme is in conflict with UDP Policy N33 and
SPD Policy HDG3 and no material considerations exist to justify a decision
otherwise than in accordance with the development plan.
14. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Chris Baxter
INSPECTOR
1 Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster) v Secretary of State for Local Communities and Local Government [2009]
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.