Erection of a detached garage to front of property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Enforcement
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14 February 2019
by A Graham BA(hons) MAued IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28th May 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/H4315/D/18/3218837
17 Wildcherry Gardens, Rainhill, St Helens WA9 5UF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Gareth Bowers against the decision of St Helens Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref P/2018/0585/HHFP, dated 18 July 2018, was refused by notice
dated 9 October 2018.
• The development proposed is the erection of a detached garage to front of property.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are the effect of the proposed garage building upon the
character and appearance of the area and upon the living conditions of
neighbours with regard to outlook.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
3. The appeal property is located to the head of a small cul de sac within a larger
estate of similar properties. Most of the properties within the area exhibit a
loose consistency in design and materials including mock Tudor timber work,
red/orange brick and render. There appears to be an intentionally designed
relationship between the areas of development and access and views to mature
landscape contained around the estate and pockets of woodland. Such areas of
the natural environment, and access and views into it, create a positive, robust
landscape setting within which the development sits.
4. Wildcherry Gardens is a meandering cul de sac where properties have open
plan gardens planted with coniferous and other specimen planting along the
road side giving the impression of an attractive landscaped appearance. The
appeal site occupies the head of a small ‘hammerhead’ style turning head and
flanks the open aspect beyond the existing fence and wall to countryside
beyond. The dominance of this landscape is defined in the mature tree that is
clearly visible within the adjacent agricultural field. There is however no public
access to this land at this point, this being provided at other locations nearby.
Appeal Decision APP/H4315/D/18/3218837
2
5. The proposal is to erect a single storey garage to the head of this cul de sac
upon the block paving of the existing driveway. The proposed garage would
present an elevation to Wildcherry Gardens but would still be of a consistent
design and materiality when compared to the estate as a whole. The siting of
the proposed garage would therefore introduce an ancillary type building into a
location where large scale houses are generally placed relatively closely
together. Therefore I do not consider that the introduction of a smaller
building would necessarily cause harm to the wider estate aesthetics.
6. The views towards the open countryside are very important in other areas of
the estate, however at this location the open countryside beyond is segregated
by the existing boundary treatment and therefore not accessible or as obvious
as in other parts. As mentioned above the tree within this field is the dominant
natural element and the dominance of this tree will be unaffected by the
proposed garage and views will still be obtained towards it. I therefore consider
that the special character provided by the open countryside beyond will not be
adversely affected by this proposal.
7. I also note the comments regarding other, similar garage extensions within the
estate. The Council feel that such garage elements were originally intentionally
designed and as such are not applicable to this site as they form part of the
specific urban design approach to the estate. I see no evidence of such
intentional design to particular elements of the estate. Although I consider
there has been some intentional design consideration given to landscape, I do
not feel that the same attention to detail has been applied to standard
housetypes and as such front garage extensions cannot be considered
incongruous within the estate aesthetic.
8. As a result I see little aesthetic difference between the existing, relatively large
scale garage extensions on streets like Swisspine Gardens and Silverlime
Gardens and the appeal site. I therefore conclude that the proposed garage
would be sympathetic to the overall character and appearance of the area
through its use of consistent materials and its general design and scale.
Living Conditions
9. I have considered the effect of the proposed garage upon the living conditions
of neighbours with particular attention to number 15 Wildcherry Gardens.
Number 15 has two windows facing the appeal site. One window is a bay type
window and will be most affected by the proposal and the other is some
distance away from the proposed site of the garage at the opposite side of the
front door.
10. This bay window currently faces onto a selection of evergreen shrubs and these
shrubs create a landscape outlook that is consistent with the wider aesthetics
of the estate. The proposed garage would introduce built development into this
area that will create a much harsher appearance to that of the existing
landscape and would appear overly dominant when seen from number 15
Wildcherry Gardens whose front elevation is only around 8 metres from this
development.
11. Despite the proposed hipped roof to this elevation the garage will still bring a
building rising to an overall height of up to 3.8 metres, extending for around 4
metres in length along the boundary of the appeal site. Therefore despite any
potential landscape that is to be retained, the impact from the introduction of a
Appeal Decision APP/H4315/D/18/3218837
3
solid structure within such close proximity to the neighbour would be significant
and lead to a development that is over dominant and intrusive when experienced
from number 15.
12. As such I consider that the impact upon the living conditions of residents to
number 15 Wildcherry Gardens will be adversely affected through the building
being over dominant and therefore unacceptably intrusive in ways that would
not be overcome by the imposition of conditions or the retention of landscape.
13. I therefore consider that the proposal would be in conflict with Policy CP1 of the
St Helen’s Core Strategy that seeks to protect the living conditions of
surrounding occupiers and avoid detrimental impacts on the local area.
Other Matters
14. Several residents supported the original application due to issues around the
front garden area being a storage area for materials. It is possible that by
allowing this appeal this issue may be alleviated to the benefit of the
appearance of the streetscene but I do not consider that this minor potential
benefit outweighs the harm that will occur to neighbouring residents as
outlined above.
15. I also note one residents concern regarding the allegation of the property being
used to repair motorcycles. I have no evidence before me to confirm or deny
this activity and I consider that such matters are covered through other
planning and environmental health legislation that may deal with any such
future allegations appropriately.
Conclusion
16. I conclude that the proposed garage would not cause undue harm to the
overall character or appearance of the area but that this lack of harm is
substantially outweighed by the impact of the proposal upon the living
conditions of residents of number 15 Wildcherry Gardens. I therefore dismiss
the appeal.
A Graham
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.