Erection of an oak framed cart lodge to accommodate 5 vehicles
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Rural Impact
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 January 2019
by Peter D Biggers BSc Hons MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 20 March 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/H1515/D/18/3218757
Zeiger Cottage, 175 Coxtie Green Road, Pilgrims Hatch, South Weald
CM14 5RP.
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Dave Pilkington against the decision of Brentwood Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 18/01213/FUL, dated 31 July 2018, was refused by notice dated
21 September 2018.
• The development proposed is erection of an oak framed cart lodge to accommodate 5
vehicles.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. In the period since the appeal was submitted the Government has published the
revised National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) which, for the
purposes of determining this appeal, takes immediate effect. As the appellant
has referred to the existing Framework I have taken into consideration where
necessary the new Framework policies that mirror the paragraphs of the old
Framework referred to.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
• Whether the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt for the
purposes of the Framework and development plan policy;
• The effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt and
• The effect on the character and appearance of the surroundings on Coxtie
Green Road and Mores Lane.
Reasons
4. The appeal property, Zeiger Cottage is a semi-detached house built in a
traditional style and facing onto Coxtie Green Road. To the rear, both the
cottage and its semi-detached neighbour have a number of offshoots and
extensions which, in Zeiger Cottage’s case, includes a conservatory and free
standing single garage. The property has a rear yard area accessed from Mores
Lane which would be the proposed site for the oak framed building. The yard is
partly screened to the lane and to adjacent countryside to the immediate north
by fencing and evergreen planting along the lane frontage.
Appeal Decision APP/H1515/D/18/3218757
2
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
5. The Framework establishes that the construction of new buildings in the green
belt is inappropriate other than in a number of circumstances set out in
Paragraph 145. One of these is the extension or alteration of an existing
building. Whilst not expressed in the same way as the Framework, policy GB1 of
the Brentwood Replacement Local Plan 2005 (BRLP) also allows for extension.
6. It has been put to me that the proposed dwelling should be considered as an
extension to the existing house. However the proposal is for a large free
standing building along the rear boundary of the yard and some 10 metres from
the closest point of the main house. I accept the building would be within the
residential curtilage but, even if I were to agree that the proposal could be
treated as an extension, paragraph 145 specifies that, to be acceptable, the
extension should not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size
of the original building.
7. The Framework does not set a limit on the scale of extension, leaving it to the
decision maker to determine whether the extension would be a disproportionate
addition over and above the size of the original building. However Policy GB5 of
the BRLP, to assist in defining what would be a proportionate or limited
extension, stipulates that extensions should not exceed a 37 square metre
increase over the size of the original dwelling.
8. As stated above the property has already been the subject of extensions in the
past and, given the scale of the proposed building at 112 square metres, it
would be disproportionate to the original house or at least that part of the house
pre-existing in 1948.
9. On that basis I conclude that it would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt and therefore by definition harmful, contrary to the Framework and
policies GB1 and GB5 of the BRLP.
The Effect on Openness
10. Green Belt is established to achieve a number of aims one of which is to assist
in safeguarding the countryside from encroachment and one of the essential
characteristics of Green Belts is their openness.
11. The proposal, given its scale, mass and height, in an open undeveloped yard
adjoining open countryside and given that it is not proposed that the building
should replace any existing buildings, would by definition result in a loss of
openness to the detriment of the Green Belt.
12. I have been referred to other developments allowed in the area and invited to
conclude that they have greater impact. Some of these currently under
construction were evident from the site. However the details of these and the
justification for their location within the Green Belt are not before me and I must
determine this application on its own merits.
Character and Appearance
13. I acknowledge that the proposed building would be of a design and materials
that would be broadly acceptable in a rural area. However even this revised
scheme (which is lower in height), given its scale, mass and location and the
agglomeration of buildings to the rear of Zeiger Cottage would not represent an
improvement to the character and appearance of the area. Although the
appellant has offered to increase the landscaping along the lane and proposes
Appeal Decision APP/H1515/D/18/3218757
3
that a condition could be attached to achieve this, I am not persuaded that
landscaping of itself would mitigate the adverse impact of the scale, mass and
height of the building viewed from Mores Lane and around its junction with
Coxtie Green Road. Moreover the appeal proposal, although sitting in the same
curtilage as an established group of buildings, would also be seen in the context
of open countryside to the north in which its scale and mass would dominate.
14. As such the proposal would fail to comply with BRLP policy CP1 which requires a
high standard of design and layout compatible with its location.
Other Considerations
15. A number of matters have been put to me purporting to represent very special
circumstances to justify the development. These include that the siting would
ensure it was not a standalone structure but part of a group; that the design
demonstrates its subordinate nature; that it would involve materials that were
natural and suitable in a rural context; and that it would allow enhanced
landscaping and a better appearance to the yard. However all these matters are
simply aspects of good planning that should be expected in any development.
They do not, even together, outweigh the harm to the Green Belt.
16. I have also been referred in the appellant’s personal statement to the fact that
he is proposing the building to facilitate the storage and restoration of a number
of vehicles, two of which were evident on the site at the time of my visit.
However it has not been satisfactorily demonstrated why such a large
outbuilding would be necessary and why, for example, the development has to
be additional to existing garaging on site rather than a replacement for it.
Conclusions
17. I have concluded that the proposal would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt and by definition harmful. The scale of the development in its context
and the adverse impact it would have on the openness of the Green Belt adds to
this harm. I have considered the other considerations set out above but taken
together they would not outweigh the harm to the Green Belt from inappropriate
development. As such the very special circumstances necessary to warrant the
development do not exist and for the reasons given above, I conclude the
appeal should be dismissed.
P. D. Biggers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.