Demolition of existing outbuilding and erection of pool house (resubmission following refusal)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 March 2019
by Chris Couper BA (Hons) DiP TP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15th March 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/C1950/D/18/3217775
5 Oakwell Drive, Northaw, Potters Bar EN6 4EZ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Andrew Marler against the decision of Welwyn Hatfield
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 6/2018/1808/HOUSE, dated 6 July 2018, was refused by notice
dated 12 September 2018.
• The development proposed is described as ‘demolition of existing outbuilding and
erection of pool house (resubmission following refusal)’.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the demolition of
the existing outbuilding and the erection of a pool house at 5 Oakwell Drive,
Northaw, Potters Bar EN6 4EZ, in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref 6/2018/1808/HOUSE, dated 6 July 2018, subject to the following
conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: TD255/PL/001, TD255/PL/201,
TD255/PL/202 Rev A, TD255/PL/203 Rev A, TD255/PL/204,
TD255/PL/101 Rev A, and TD255/PL/102 Rev B.
3) No development above ground level shall take place until samples of the
materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
building hereby permitted have been submitted to and approved in
writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be
implemented using the approved materials and subsequently, the
approved materials shall not be changed.
4) Development shall not commence until the tree protection measures set
out in the Arboricultural Implications Assessment and Method Statement
by Andrew Belson Arboricultural Consultant - read in conjunction with
drawing numbers: 3067.PottersBar.TD.TPP Revision B and
3067.PottersBar.TD.AIP Revision B - are in place. Those tree protection
measures shall be maintained until the completion of the development.
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/18/3217775
2
Procedural Matter
2. As it does not form an act of development, I have omitted from my description
of the proposal the words ‘resubmission following refusal.’
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
• Whether or not the proposal would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt, having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework and
any relevant development plan policies; and
• The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area,
with particular regard to the impact on protected trees.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development in the Green Belt
4. The National Planning Policy Framework (‘Framework’) sets out the great
importance that the Government attaches to Green Belts. It states that
inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt, and
should not be approved except in very special circumstances. At paragraph
145 it regards the construction of new buildings as inappropriate unless,
amongst other things, it is the extension or alteration of a building provided
that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of
the original building.
5. Policy RA3 of the Welwyn Hatfield District Plan 2005 (‘WHDP’) states at part (i)
that house extensions will only be allowed where they would not individually, or
cumulatively, result in a disproportionate increase in the size of the dwelling.
It states that this also applies to outbuildings. At part (ii) it continues that the
visual impact will also be considered. WHDP Policy GBSP1 sets out the
purposes of the Green Belt and that the Green Belt will be maintained. That
policy and Policy RA3 part (i) are broadly consistent with the Framework, and I
give them substantial weight in my decision.
6. The Council also refers to emerging Policy SADM34 of the Welwyn Hatfield
Draft Local Plan Proposed Submission 2016 (‘DLP’). It takes a broadly similar
approach to that detailed above, but provides additional commentary on what
would constitute a disproportionate extension. It states that a quantitative and
qualitative assessment will be undertaken. It continues that proposals that
would result in the footprint, volume and/or above ground external dimensions
of a building being 50% greater than the original will generally be refused.
7. No 5 Oakwell Drive is a substantial detached house which has been previously
extended to the side and rear, and with dormers in its roof. This scheme would
involve the replacement of an existing outbuilding within the dwelling’s
curtilage, and the creation of an underground section to house a swimming
pool and associated equipment and facilities.
8. The Council contends that the underground section would not be completely
concealed due to changes in levels and rooflights which, when considered with
existing extensions, would result in a disproportionate addition to the original
building.
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/18/3217775
3
9. According to the appellant’s calculations, the existing extensions and the
proposed outbuilding (excluding the underground section) would cumulatively
amount to a 50% increase compared to the floor area of the original building,
and a 28.45% increase in its volume.
10. For my part, I note that the existing extensions to the dwelling are generally
lower than the original building, are of relatively modest proportions, and are
cumulatively subservient to it in scale and mass. That also goes for the above
ground section of the proposed pool house, which would be very similar in size
to the outbuilding it would replace.
11. Whilst the scheme would have an underground section, it would be largely
concealed under its predominantly green roof. There would be six roof
windows in a part of the garden where the gradient would be increased.
However, as illustrated by the existing and proposed elevations on drawing
nos. TD255/PL/202 Rev A and TD255/PL/203 Rev A, those levels changes
would be modest. Those changes, and the roof windows, would be very well
screened by an existing fence and landscaping.
12. Having regard to cumulative impacts, I therefore conclude that the scheme
would not constitute a disproportionate addition to the original building, and
that the proposed building itself would not have an adverse visual impact on
the area’s character. On this issue, the scheme would not therefore conflict
with WHDP Policies GBSP1 and RA3, the Framework, or with emerging Policy
SADM34 in the DLP. Having reached that conclusion, it is not necessary for me
to go on to consider the impact on the Green Belt’s openness.
Character and appearance
13. The host property and nearby dwellings sit in a spacious, landscaped setting.
Many large trees make a significant contribution to the area’s character, and
are protected by a Tree Preservation Order.
14. Two such trees are located close to the proposed pool house. These are large
Wellingtonias, which are identified as Grade B trees ‘NT1’ and ‘NT5’ on the
appellant’s Arboricultural Implications Plan (‘AIP’). The parties agree that the
proposal would intrude into their Root Protection Areas (‘RPAs’), but disagree
with regards the impacts on their root system and their long term health.
15. The application was accompanied by an Arboricultural Implications Assessment
and Method Statement by Andrew Belson Arboricultural Consultant (‘Method
Statement’). It found that NT1 and NT5 are in good condition; that a trial
trench indicated minimal rooting volume to the north of NT1 – where the
proposed pool house would be; but that there is significant rooting under the
block paving to the west of NT1 and to the south of NT5.
16. Even with the footprint of the proposed development subtracted, it found that
there would still be more than adequate root space for each tree to expand its
root system into. It concluded that incursions would be well below the level
that would be detrimental to the health or vigour of these trees.
17. Those findings were supported by a Root Investigation by Tree Radar by
Sharon Hosegood Associates (‘RI’), which the Council commented on during the
appeal process. Through ground penetrating radar it confirmed moderate to
high rooting densities beneath the road and paved areas, but no major roots
below the depth of the trench in the rear garden. As pointed out by the
Appeal Decision APP/C1950/D/18/3217775
4
appellant, the RI reliably detects roots of 20mm or more diameter, not 20cm as
stated by the Council.
18. I agree that the RPAs of these two trees have been breached by historic
structures and hardstanding. In accordance with BS5837:2012 I have taken
into account the cumulative effects of such incursions. However, having regard
to the trees’ condition, and section 9.3 of the Method Statement, I have no
cogent reason to doubt that they have recovered and made new roots to repair
and compensate for historic damage. I therefore agree with the Council’s Tree
Officer that the trees appear to have coped well with those incursions.
19. Given the evidence in the RI and the Method Statement, on the basis of the
conflicting views before me, I conclude that the site of the proposed pool house
is unlikely to provide a significant rooting area for trees NT1 and NT5. Those
trees are likely to gain water and nutrients from the modified RPAs as depicted
on the AIP, and subject to suitable protective measures, including barriers and
appropriate ground protection, I conclude that the proposal would not have an
adverse effect on them.
20. The proposal would not therefore harm the character and appearance of the
area, and it would not conflict with WHDP Policies SD1, D1, D2, R17, D8. In
general terms they require that proposals accord with principles of sustainable
development and good design, and that they maintain the character of the area
through, for instance, the retention of key landscape features such as trees.
Additionally, it would not conflict with the broadly similar stance in the
Framework, and in DLP Policies SP1, SP9 and SADM16.
Conditions and conclusion
21. I have found that the scheme would not be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt, and that it would not harm the character and appearance of the
area. The appeal will therefore be allowed.
22. The Council proposed conditions, which I have considered against the
Framework’s tests, making minor amendments to improve precision, clarity
and enforceability. I have imposed the standard time limit condition and, in
the interests of certainty, a condition requiring that the development be carried
out in accordance with the approved plans. In the interests of the area’s
character and appearance, I have also imposed a condition requiring the
submission and approval of samples of the building’s external surfaces.
23. The Method Statement suggested various measures to protect the trees during
construction. Those included pre-commencement measures which I agree are
necessary from the outset of the development to prevent potentially
irreversible damage. I have therefore imposed the Council’s suggested
condition requiring that the protection measures detailed in the Method
Statement be put in place prior to the commencement of the development.
24. Subject to those conditions, and having regard to all other matters raised, the
appeal is allowed.
Chris Couper
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.