Erection of side and rear extensions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Residential Amenity
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 February 2019
by Laura Renaudon LLM LARTPI Solicitor
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 2 April 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/J4525/D/18/3217187
1 Liberty Green, Washington NE38 7UA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr. J. Arca against the decision of Sunderland City Council.
• The application Ref 17/02080/FUL, dated 20 October 2017, was refused by notice dated
5 September 2018.
• The development proposed is the erection of side and rear extensions.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The Council’s decision notice amends the description of the development to
“Erection of a two storey extension to side and rear and first floor extension to
side” and I have considered the appeal on this basis.
Main Issues
3. The dwelling at 1 Liberty Green is part of what appears to be a relatively new
development in the Washington Village Conservation Area in a hillside setting
to the south of Village Lane. The Council did not refuse planning permission on
the grounds that the proposed development would have an adverse effect upon
the conservation area. The design and layout of the proposed extensions would
preserve the character and appearance of the conservation area. The reasons
for refusing permission refer to the potential effect upon trees protected by a
tree preservation order and the living conditions of the occupiers of no.8 Village
Lane. Against that background, the main issues are the effect of the proposed
development upon: (1) the health and well-being of trees protected by a tree
preservation order; and (2) the living conditions of the occupants of no.8
Village Lane having particular regard to outlook.
Reasons
The health and well-being of trees
4. A Tree Preservation Order plan dated May 2002 identifies two groups of trees
and nearly 80 individual trees to be included in the Order. This plan appears to
pre-date the construction of the Liberty Green development, and it is not clear
how many of the trees identified in the Order have since been retained.
However, the area is one of significant and established tree coverage when
Appeal Decision APP/J4525/D/18/3217187
2
viewed from its surroundings, including Village Lane and further beyond at The
Avenue.
5. In the grounds of the appeal site, trees subject to the Order include a
sycamore to the north of the dwelling on its western side, and a beech tree to
the north in front of the existing conservatory. The canopy of the beech
extends towards the conservatory, appearing to overhang it slightly, and I saw
evidence of crown lifting works having been carried out to it.
6. The appeal proposals are to construct 2 separate extensions to the dwelling: a
first floor extension above the existing garage on the western side, retaining
the existing footprint; and a 2-storey extension to the north eastern side,
replacing the existing conservatory on an extended footprint.
7. Policy CN17 of the City of Sunderland Adopted Unitary Development Plan
(‘UDP’) of 1998 refers to encouraging the retention of trees by the making of
TPOs where appropriate, and requires the retention of trees, hedges and
landscape features in all new development where possible. The trees in the
garden of the appeal site make a substantial and positive contribution to the
area, as recognised by the inclusion of some of them in the Order.
8. Plan YF/20TP, showing tree protection areas against the existing footprint of
the dwelling, appears inaccurate in that it identifies square protection areas
and the nearest beech tree appears incorrectly plotted. A tree survey has been
submitted, and re-submitted with amendments at the request of the Council,
but this remains insufficiently detailed because, although it suggests how
construction works may be carried out to minimise root damage to trees
generally, it does not identify the root structures of the particular trees in
question, how vulnerable these may be to development, or what particular
construction and protection methods could successfully be applied in this case.
Additionally it does not address the likely future crown spread of the trees or
any potential future pressure for lopping that might result from building
2-storey extensions.
9. Due to these omissions, I cannot be satisfied that the proposed development
can be carried out compatibly with avoiding harm or threat to the protected
trees, and so am unable to concur with the appellant that the matter may be
appropriately addressed by imposing a planning condition. I am unable to
conclude, on the evidence provided, that the health or longevity of the
protected trees would not be put at risk, and so consider that the development
would be contrary to UDP Policy CN17.
Living conditions
10. 8 Village Lane is a split-level dwelling to the immediate north of the appeal
property. It is accessed from Village Lane and is ‘built in’ to the hillside that
rises from Village Lane to the south, and is thus set down from the dwellings
on Liberty Green. Its principal elevation faces to the north, but habitable rooms
including the kitchen face south onto the northern elevation of the appeal
property.
11. Concerns are expressed about the effect of the proposed first floor extension
above the garage on the western end of the appeal property. I saw on my site
visit that the outlook from the kitchen window of No 8 is largely onto the
northern face of the appeal dwelling at a distance of around 17m away, with
Appeal Decision APP/J4525/D/18/3217187
3
the only tangible relief being a visible expanse of sky above the existing
garage.
12. The appellant refers to the “45 Degree Rule” and produces drawings to suggest
that this ‘rule’ is not breached by the proposals. The drawings appear to relate
to an earlier iteration of the proposed development, rather than to what is now
proposed, but in any event the ‘rule’ relates to overshadowing and light loss,
rather than to issues of overdominance. The construction of a first floor
extension above the existing garage would result in the view to the south from
No 8 consisting almost entirely of the northern façade of the appeal dwelling in
close proximity with little relief. Coupled with the extensive tree cover, this
would result in an adverse sense of enclosure to the occupiers of No 8.
Consequently I find that this element of the proposed development would be
unduly overbearing and would adversely affect the outlook from No 8.
Accordingly it would be contrary to UDP Policy B2 which requires the massing
of new developments and extensions to respect and enhance the best qualities
of nearby properties.
13. The appellant asserts that kitchens are not generally regarded as ‘habitable
rooms’ for the purposes of the “45 Degree Rule”. The kitchen is a room in
which the occupiers can be expected to spend a considerable amount of time,
during which the overbearing effects I have identified would be manifest. The
appellant also refers to No 8 having recently been sold. However, whether or
not it has been purchased with knowledge of the development in prospect does
not alter my conclusions on this issue.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal proposals are contrary
to the development plan for the area and the appeal should be dismissed.
Laura Renaudon
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.