First floor rear extension over original ground floor wing of a terraced residential house Decision
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 10 January 2019
by C Hall BSc MPhil MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 06th March 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/L5810/D/18/3215588
8 Bracken Gardens, Barnes, London SW13 9HW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Talac Mahmud against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames.
• The application Ref 18/2315/HOT, dated 9 July 2018, was refused by notice dated
3 September 2018.
• The development proposed is described as a first floor rear extension over original
ground floor wing of a terraced residential house
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
◦ whether the proposal would preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Barnes Common Conservation Area;
◦ the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupants of 7
Bracken Gardens with regard to outlook and loss of light.
Reasons
Character and appearance including Conservation Area
3. The appeal site is a two-storey, end-terrace dwelling with a single storey
addition to the rear. It is situated on Bracken Gardens which is a residential
cul-de-sac in the Barnes Common Conservation Area. The scheme
consists of a first floor, flat-roofed rear extension.
4. The Council's Barnes Common Conservation Area Character Statement
describes the significance of dwellings along Bracken Gardens as being
predominantly Arts and Crafts in style and constructed of London stock
brick; however they feature unique detailing with small oriel windows and
larger bay windows, some of which retain original stained glass and
boundary treatments.
5. Policy LP1 of the London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames Local Plan (the
'Local Plan') states that, amongst other things, development proposals
should be of a high architectural and urban design quality that would be
compatible with local character. The Council's Supplementary Planning
Document: House Extensions and External Alterations (2015) sets out advice
in respect of rear extensions to properties, advocating that they should not
dominate the existing house or its neighbours and that they should not be
greater than half the width of the original building. The Barnes Village
Planning Guidance Supplementary Planning Document seeks to promote high
standards of design.
6. The Council has previously granted planning permission for a first floor rear
addition that would extend just over half the width of the original building
which ensured that the element did not over-dominate the dwelling's original
scale and character. It is evident from the rear garden of the appeal
property that a number of similar extensions exist to the rear of other
dwellings within the terrace, although each has its own individual design.
7. Whilst the existing half-width elements display variations in design and scale
they nevertheless provide definition to the terrace through articulation of the
rear elevations and add visual interest to the group of properties. I consider
that the construction of first-floor rear additions that extend the full width of
the original building such as that proposed in this case would not be
sympathetic to the original form of properties and would erode the character
of the rear of this terrace of houses and the wider Conservation Area. The
mass of the proposal and the extent of flat roof would lack architectural
subtlety and, although not visually prominent from the public domain, would
diminish the character of the host building. Contrary to the appellant's
assertion, I am unconvinced that the approval of the scheme would not
set a precedent for the terrace as this could result in other applications for
similar extensions that could have an adverse impact on the character and
appearance of the rear of the terrace and the wider Conservation Area.
8. I acknowledge those matters that have been advanced in support of the
development, including the assertion that there are no listed buildings in
the immediate vicinity, the location of the site at the end of the terrace and
its relationship with the adjoining boundary wall, the approval of a new
development on the adjacent land, the contemporary nature of the scheme,
an improved internal layout for the occupants and the use of good quality
materials. However these arguments do not outweigh the harm to character
and appearance that I have identified above.
9. The statutory duty in Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and
Conservation Areas) Act 1990 is a matter of considerable importance and
weight. Although the harm to the individual building and surrounding area
would be less than substantial, as the element proposed is relatively minor
in scale, the incremental and cumulative loss of original form would
adversely affect the heritage significance of the Conservation Area.
10. The proposals would harm the character and appearance of the original
dwelling and would not preserve the appearance of the Barnes Common
Conservation Area, contrary to policy LP1 of the Local Plan and the guidance
contained in the House Extensions and Alterations SPD.
Living conditions
11. The appeal property forms part of a tight-knit terrace of dwellings with close
relationships between adjacent windows, doors and built form. Policy LP8 of
the Local Plan states that, amongst other things, all development will be
required to protect the amenity and living conditions of adjoining properties,
ensuring that proposals enable good standards of light to be achieved in
existing properties and are not visually intrusive or have an overbearing
impact. The House Extensions and Alterations SPD advises that extensions
that create an unacceptable sense of enclosure or appear overbearing will
not be permitted.
12. Similar relationships to that proposed between the appeal property and 7
Bracken Gardens presently exist between other dwellings along the terrace
due to the presence of rear extensions at first floor level and are
typical of the arrangement of built form in this highly urban setting.
13. In this context, and noting the existing single storey outrigger to 7
Bracken Gardens, which represents an intervening structure and buffer
between the neighbouring house and the appeal property, I consider that
the element proposed would not have significant overbearing effects upon
the adjoining dwelling.
14. With regard to light, the nearest window in the first floor rear elevation of 7
Bracken Gardens is obscure glazed. Although a 45 degree line from the mid
point of this window would be technically breached, the appeal scheme
would not have significant enclosing or shading effects given the opaque
nature of this opening. The other first floor window to no. 7 is clear glazed
but a sufficient distance away for there to be no detrimental impacts.
15. The appeal scheme would not harm the living conditions of the occupiers of
7 Bracken Gardens with regard to outlook and light. The proposals would
therefore comply with the overall amenity aims of policy LP8 of the Local
Plan and the guidance contained in the House Extensions and Alterations
SPD .
Other matters
16. In accordance with paragraph 196 of the National Planning Policy Framework
I have weighed the less than substantial harm to the heritage asset against
any public benefits of the proposal, including securing its optimal viable use.
The property would remain in use as a dwelling and the viability of its use is
not questioned. Overall, there are no identified benefits that would outweigh
the harm.
Conclusion
17. The proposal would not harm the living conditions of the occupants of the
neighbouring property at 7 Bracken Gardens. However, this is outweighed by
the harm I have found to the character and appearance of the Barnes
Common Conservation Area. For the reasons given above and taking into
account all other matters raised, including the absence of objections from
neighbouring properties, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
C Hall
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.