Appeal Against Conditions

πŸ“Š

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view β€” just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 7 February 2019 by R J Maile BSc FRICS an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 25th February 2019 Appeal Ref: APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 21 Corkran Road, Surbiton, Surrey, KT6 6PL. β€’ The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land without complying with conditions subject to which a previous planning permission was granted. β€’ The appeal is made by Mr Ernie Colicci against the decision of the Council of the Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames. β€’ The application ref: 18/16540/FUL, dated 26 July 2018, was refused by notice dated 26 September 2018. β€’ The application sought planning permission for demolition of existing garage and erection of single storey garage with additional living accommodation without complying with a condition attached to planning permission ref: 16/16044/HOU, dated 21 March 2016. β€’ The condition in dispute is no. 2, which states that: β€œThe development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: 160118_The Coach House – Design & Access and Heritage Statement. – 21/01/2016. 001 – Site Location Plan – 21/01/2016. 101 – Existing Ground Floor Plan – 21/01/2016. 100 – Existing Roof Plan – 21/01/2016. 102 – Existing Elevation AA – 21/01/2016. 103 – Existing Elevations GG – 21/01/2016. 104 – Existing Section – 21/01/2016. 101 – Proposed Ground Floor Plan – 21/01/2016. 102 – Proposed First Floor Plan – 21/01/2016. 100 – Proposed Roof Plan – 21/01/2016. 103 – Proposed Elevation GG – 21/01/2016. 106 – Proposed Elevation AA – 21/01/2016. 104 – Proposed Elevation GG – 21/01/2016. 105 – Proposed Section AA – 21/01/2016. 107 – Proposed Elevation CC-DD – 21/01/2016. Arboricultural Method Statement and Tree Protection Plan – 18/03/2016.” β€’ The reason given for the condition is: β€œFor avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.” Preliminary Matter 1. The Government has published an updated and revised National Planning Policy Framework (February 2019). However, none of the changes to national policy as set out in the newly revised Framework affect my consideration of this appeal. Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 2 Decision 2. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for demolition of existing garage and erection of single storey garage with additional living accommodation at 21 Corkran Road, Surbiton, Surrey, KT6 6PL, in accordance with the application ref: 18/16540/FUL, dated 26 July 2018, without compliance with condition number 2 previously imposed on planning permission ref: 16/16044/HOU, dated 21 March 2016, and subject to the following conditions: 1) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: Drawing no. 18-04 EX/01: Existing Location Plan – scale 1:1250; Existing Site Plan – scale 1:200. Drawing no. 18-04 PL/01: Proposed Ground Floor Plan – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 18-04 PL/02: Proposed Sections – scales 1:100 and 1:200. Drawing no. 18-04 PL/03: Proposed Elevations – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 18-04 PL/04: Proposed Perspectives – not to scale. Arboricultural Method Statement and Tree Protection Plan 18/03/2016. 2) The external surfaces of the building hereby permitted shall be constructed in the materials shown on Drawing no. 18-04 PL/03. 3) Details of any external lighting shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority before the building hereby permitted is first occupied. Development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details. 4) The flat roof of the building hereby permitted shall not be used as a balcony or sitting out area and access to it shall be for maintenance or emergency purposes only. 5) The building hereby permitted shall not at any time be occupied other than for purposes ancillary to the residential use of the dwelling known as 21 Corkran Road, Surbiton, KT6 6PL. 6) Notwithstanding the information contained in the approved plans no further development shall take place until detailed drawings and/or sectional plans at a scale of 1:20 indicating the relationship between the proposed window frames and the elevations/roof form shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority; and the development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details. Main Issues 3. The main issues in this case are: a) The effect of the amended scheme upon the character and appearance of the host building and that of the surrounding area. b) The impact of the amended scheme upon the living conditions of nearby residents. Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 3 Reasons a) Effect upon character and appearance. 4. The subject property, which was formerly a coach house, comprises a large detached Victorian dwelling that is approached by means of a narrow driveway off Corkran Road. The driveway also serves the garage of 21a Corkran Road and 2, 3 and 4 The Drive, which are located opposite and to the southeast of no. 21. The surrounding area is residential in character. 5. The appeal site is located within the Southborough Conservation Area. I have therefore considered the proposal by reference to the statutory duty imposed upon me by section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. This requires me to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the designated area. I have also had regard to national policy as set out at Chapter 16 (Conserving and enhancing the historic environment) of the Framework1. 6. The Southborough Conservation Area is an important heritage asset. As such, paragraph 193 of the Framework requires that great weight should be given to its conservation. The designated area is described in the Council’s published planning information2 as: β€œSouthborough Conservation Area was designated in January 1979 and extended in January 1989 and September 1991. The special character of this area can be summarised as:- An area of large detached houses dating from the 1860s–1930s surrounding Southborough House, an 1808 Grade II listed building by the architect John Nash.” 7. Policy 7.8 of The London Plan states, amongst other matters, that development affecting heritage assets and their setting should conserve their significance by being sympathetic to their form, scale, materials and architectural detail. 8. Policy CS 8 of the adopted Core Strategy3 states that the Council will protect the primarily suburban character of the Borough, existing buildings and areas of high quality and historic interest from inappropriate development. New development should have regard to the historic and natural environment. 9. Policy DM 10 sets out design requirements for new developments, which should respect the prevailing development typology, including housing types, sizes and occupancy. 10. Policy DM 12 relates to development within Conservation Areas, which should respect features of local importance and ensure that development proposals affecting historic assets will use high quality materials and design features which incorporate or compliment those of the host building or the immediate area. 11. Planning permission for demolition of the existing garage and erection of single storey garage with additional living accommodation was granted by the Council on 21 March 2016 under ref: 16/16044/HOU. That planning permission has been commenced by virtue of works to demolish the garage and site clearance. However, the development was halted once it was realised that the two storey 1 The National Planning Policy Framework (as updated and revised February 2019). 2 Conservation Area 4: Southborough – Planning Information. 3 Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames Local Development Framework: Core Strategy (April 2012). Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 4 levels of the scheme would not work within the constrained dimensions of the site and the resultant gradients. By contrast, the amended proposals before me would be on a single level, resulting in a lower roof height. 12. The Council has already accepted the principle of the erection of a new garage with ancillary residential accommodation. It is nevertheless concerned that the amended scheme would have a materially different appearance to that which was previously approved, involving significant alterations to its roof form, bulk, scale and mass, together with changes to the windows, facing materials and an increase in footprint of approximately 26m2. 13. The new structure would be almost wholly screened in views from the public domain given that it would be sited to the rear of 21a Corkran Road. It would also be separated from the narrow private drive that serves no. 21 and 21a and 2, 3 and 4 The Drive by a solid brick boundary wall. 14. There are trees to the rear, together with a detached garage that serves no. 21a, both of which will provide further screening. The ridge height of the amended scheme would be lower than that for which planning permission has already been granted, whilst the increase in the footprint of the building is minimal and is necessary to compensate for the omission of accommodation at first floor level. 15. The Council has raised objection, in particular, to the modern design and use of materials. I have nevertheless noted that the recently constructed houses at 3 and 4 The Drive are to a modern design and incorporate the use of non- traditional materials. 16. The Officer’s Report in relation to the approved scheme stated: β€˜The proposal would not necessarily be in keeping with the character and appearance of the outbuildings and garage (sic) in the wider area.’ Similarly, in the case of the amended scheme I conclude that the design and use of materials would not be in keeping with the host building. The new structure would nevertheless reflect the character of the two new houses opposite. 17. For all of these reasons I have found in relation to the first main issue that the amended scheme would result in a building that would sit comfortably with and not be harmful to the character and appearance of the host building or that of the surrounding area, including the Southborough Conservation Area. As such, the proposals would accord with the thrust of national policy in the Framework as referred to above, with Policy 7.8 of The London Plan and Policies CS 8, DM 10 and DM 12 of the adopted Core Strategy. b) Impact upon living conditions. 18. Policy 7.6 of The London Plan, together with national policy at paragraph 127 of the Framework, seek to ensure that development secures a good standard of amenity for all existing and future users of land and buildings. 19. Policy DM 10 k. of the Core Strategy requires development proposals to have regard to the amenities of occupants and neighbours, including in terms of privacy, outlook, sunlight/daylight, avoidance of visual intrusion and noise and disturbance. 20. During my site visit I carefully noted the relationship of the amended scheme to 19, 21a and 23 Corkran Road and 2, 3 and 4 The Drive. Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 5 21. The new building would abut the rear garden of 19 Corkran Road. However, it would be sited some distance from the rear elevation of that property and will be screened from its garden by trees. The amended scheme will therefore have no adverse impact upon the amenities of occupiers of that dwelling. 22. As to 21a and 23 Corkran Road, these would be largely screened from the new building by the garage within the rear garden of no. 21a and by the high brick wall along the frontage to the appeal site. It is also relevant that the building for which planning permission has been granted would be taller in terms of its ridge height. Although that approved scheme is set back from the frontage by some 2m, the proposals the subject of this appeal incorporate a reduced height to that part of the building which projects closer to the front boundary wall. 23. Accordingly, I conclude that there would be no greater impact upon the outlook from the rear-facing first floor windows of 21a and 23 Corkran Road than would be the case with the currently approved scheme. 24. There is a distance of some 20m between the front elevations of 2, 3 and 4 The Drive and the appeal site. The existing brick boundary wall, which is to be retained, would have the effect of screening much of the proposed structure as viewed from those houses. Indeed, the reduced ridge height of the amended scheme would be of further benefit in terms of the outlook from the nearby dwellings in The Drive. 25. I am also satisfied that the amended proposals would not give rise to any loss of sunlight/daylight or loss of privacy to any of the neighbouring properties. 26. For these reasons, I have found upon the second main issue that the amended scheme would not have a harmful impact upon the living conditions of nearby residents and that it would accord with national policy at paragraph 127 of the Framework, Policy 7.6 of The London Plan and Core Strategy Policy DM 10. Conditions 27. The Council has put forward a total of five conditions to be imposed should I be minded to allow the appeal. I have considered these against the tests of the Framework and advice provided by the Planning Practice Guidance and find nos. 2, 4 and 5 to be reasonable and necessary in the circumstances of this case. I have, however, amended their wording where required. 28. The development has been commenced. As such, suggested Condition 1 (the standard time limit condition) is not imposed. 29. Suggested Condition 3 requires details of the materials for all external finishes and any external lighting to be submitted for prior approval. The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the development are specified on Drawing no. 18-04 PL/03 and I consider them to be acceptable. I have imposed a revised condition (no. 2) to reflect this. I have dealt with the question of external lighting by means of a separate condition (no. 3). 30. It is also necessary for me to re-impose Condition 4 of the original permission, since this remains relevant to the amended scheme the subject of this appeal. 31. My reasons for the conditions are: Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/18/3214672 6 32. Condition 1, requiring the development to be carried out in accordance with the approved plans, is necessary in order to provide certainty. Conditions 2, 3 and 6 will ensure a satisfactory appearance to the completed development in the interests of the visual amenities of the area. 33. Condition 4 will safeguard the amenities and privacy of neighbouring occupiers. Condition 5 is necessary in order to prevent the formation of a separate unit of living accommodation, which would give rise to in an over-intensive use of the site and result in an unsatisfactory relationship between independent dwellings. Conclusion 34. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed. R. J. Maile INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation β€” you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →