Two storey rear extension and single storey extensions to front, rear and side, balcony to front, detached garage, front boundary wall, garage conversion and removal of two trees covered by a tree preservation order

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 8 January 2019 by S J Lee BA(Hons) MA MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 23rd January 2019 Appeal Ref: APP/X3025/D/18/3213711 Beechwood, Atkin Lane, Mansfield NG18 5AN  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs S Bajaj against the decision of Mansfield District Council.  The application Ref 2018/0256/HHA, dated 16 April 2018, was refused by notice dated 20 August 2018.  The development proposed is two storey rear extension and single storey extensions to front, rear and side, balcony to front, detached garage, front boundary wall, garage conversion and removal of two trees covered by a tree preservation order. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Preliminary issue 2. For the avoidance of doubt, the description in the header above is taken from the appellants’ appeal form as this is more accurate than that given on the application form. Main issue 3. The main issue is the effect of the development on the character and appearance of the area, with particular regard to protected trees. Reasons 4. The appeal relates to a large detached dwelling within generous and verdant grounds in a predominantly residential area. The development would result in the loss of two trees protected by Tree Preservation Orders (TPO) in the front garden. These are identified in the appellants’ Aboricultural Report (AR) as T1 (pine) and T2 (oak). To the rear, the development is likely to effect two other trees protected by TPOs, identified as T3 (beech) and T4 (ash). 5. I understand that permission has previously been granted for development that would result in the removal of T1 and T2. However, I have not been provided with all of the details of the previous proposals and do not have the full details of the Council’s considerations of the relevant applications. I cannot be certain therefore that the schemes are entirely comparable or that there has been no change in circumstance since permission was granted. Nevertheless, I acknowledge that the Council has ostensibly accepted the loss of these trees in the past and that this constitutes an important material consideration. Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3213711 2 6. Whatever previous decisions have been made, the loss of the two trees in the front garden would still be regrettable and of detriment to local character. This is particularly the case for T1 which is in good health and is of clear value to the visual amenity and character of the area. 7. Both parties acknowledge that the health of T2 has been negatively affected by previous development. However, while the AR suggests the tree has a life expectancy of less than 10 years, the Council has suggested there are signs it may recover. It is clear from its appearance that some harm to the health of this tree has occurred, though there is no strong evidence before me that there are any imminent safety risks associated with it. In my view, the tree is still capable of making a small positive contribution to the visual amenity of the area, mainly as part of the group of trees in the grounds of the dwelling, which all add to the relatively verdant nature of the street scene. While clearly not as severe as with the loss of T1, the removal of T2 would still contribute to the harm caused by the removal of the trees. Furthermore, I do not consider that replacement soft landscaping would satisfactorily mitigate the impact of the loss of these trees. 8. The root protection areas (RPA) of the beech and ash trees would be affected by the rear extension. The RPA of T3 is already beneath the dwelling and patio. The AR does not identify any harm as a result of this, but it is an important factor in considering any additional risks from the development. The RPA of T4 is not currently affected by development, but the extension would encroach within it. 9. Again, I understand that permission has previously been granted for a single storey extension of the same footprint as the proposal before me, though no details of this have been provided. The appellants have suggested that the RPA of the two trees can be adequately protected by using mini or micro piles. However, no details have been provided of how these would be used. The appellants have suggested a planning condition relating to foundations would be suitable. However, any conditions imposed on a planning permission must be capable of being discharged. The limited evidence before me provides little comfort that this would be the case here. 10. From what little information has been provided, it appears that this would be a different form of development to what was previously been permitted and thus the two schemes are not entirely comparable. The development may therefore have potentially different structural requirements, which require a different and potentially more harmful solution. In any event, when considering the degree to which the development would encroach into the RPA of each tree, there is also no clear evidence or guarantee that the types of foundations being suggested would be appropriate in this case. 11. This is particularly the case for the beech tree, where a significant proportion of its RPA would be affected by the development. The risks to its health are therefore significant and no substantive evidence has been provided that clearly demonstrates the suggested approach to foundations would be successful in protecting the tree’s long-term health. There is also nothing in the appellants’ evidence which refutes that provided by the Council which suggests mature beech trees have poor tolerance to development impacts. This adds to my concerns over what is being proposed. Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3213711 3 12. The AR indicates that the beech tree would need the tips of part of the crown lifting or reducing to accommodate the development. This adds to the cumulative risk of either harm to the tree’s health or its amenity value. The proximity of the crowns of both the beech and ash trees to the extended dwelling would significantly increase the pressure for future works to both trees. This would be in terms of real, or perceived, risks associated with falling branches, through any nuisance that might be created by leaves dropping and/or effects on living conditions perhaps through a reduction in daylight. With the development in place, the Council would find it more difficult in the future to resist pressure for works to the trees, particularly if there were concerns over health and safety. Considering the very high amenity value of T3, a precautionary approach to any potential risks to its health is appropriate in this case. 13. I therefore find that the removal of trees T1 and T2 would be harmful to the character and appearance of the area. Furthermore, there is a significant risk to the long-term health and/or amenity value of trees T3 and T4, the damage or loss of which would also result in material harm to the character and appearance of the area. Accordingly, there would be conflict with saved Policy H13 of the Mansfield District Local Plan (1998) which seeks to ensure extensions do not have a detrimental impact on the character and appearance of the street scene or the surrounding area generally. Other matters and planning balance 14. Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 dictates that planning decisions must be made in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. I have concluded that the removal of trees T1 and T2 and potential impacts on the health of T3 and T4 would conflict with development plan policy. 15. As noted above, previous permissions clearly add weight in favour of the development, particularly in relation to the removal of trees T1 and T2. However, with regard to trees T3 and T4, there is insufficient evidence for me to be certain that the development does not carry substantially more risk of harm over and above what has already been permitted. On balance, when considering the likely degree of harm and lack of detailed evidence relating to the earlier schemes or mitigation, I am not satisfied that the previous permissions carry sufficient weight to outweigh my concerns. 16. The Council raises no objections to the overall design of the development or its impact on the living conditions of neighbouring residents. However, a lack of harm in these respects is neutral and weighs neither for nor against the development. There are therefore no material considerations that would lead me to a decision other than in accordance with the development plan. Conclusion 17. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. S J Lee INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →