Proposed loft conversion/roof replacement and front and rear infill extensions

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 18 December 2018 by Michael Evans BA MA MPhil DipTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 7th January 2019 Appeal Ref: APP/U2235/D/18/3213305 38 Plantation Lane, Bearsted ME14 4BJ  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Justin Gilmore against the decision of Maidstone Borough Council.  The application Ref 18/502568/FULL was refused by notice dated 29 August 2018.  The development proposed is described on the application form as “proposed loft conversion/roof replacement and front and rear infill extensions”. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Preliminary matter 2. It is indicated on the appeal form that during the Council’s consideration of the application the description of the proposed development was changed to: “front and rear infill extensions together with raising of the roof height to provide first floor accommodation. Changes to fenestration and construction of raised patio to rear”. Main issues 3. The main issues in this appeal are: - The effect on the living conditions of the occupiers of the adjacent dwelling at 36 Plantation Lane, with regard to whether the development would appear overbearing and privacy. - The effect on the character and appearance of the locality. Reasons Living conditions 4. The appeal concerns a detached bungalow with a flank wall adjacent to and in fairly close proximity to a side of the chalet style dwelling at no. 36. There are three dormer additions in this side of the neighbouring property with windows serving bedrooms. The host dwelling also projects significantly beyond the back of no. 36 where there is a conservatory. In the current situation, where the outlook from the flank bedroom windows and at the rear is already partly Appeal Decision APP/U2235/D/18/3213305 2 obstructed, I consider that the quality of the residential environment for the adjacent occupiers is particularly vulnerable to any increased sense of enclosure. 5. To enable first floor accommodation both the eaves and ridge of the roof would be raised. There would also be infill extensions at the front and rear. A pair of contiguous ‘blind’ dormers would form a single addition. Their faces would rise vertically from the flank wall above the eaves level, with the top of their pitched and hipped roofs virtually reaching the ridge of the raised main roof. 6. The infill and dormer additions would result in parts of the dwelling projecting significantly closer to the adjacent side windows. Appreciable extra bulk would also arise from the gabled form by comparison to the existing hip ends. The eaves level would be raised by a metre with the ridge rising by a noticeably greater amount. Having considered the effect from no. 36 at my site visit, I saw that these changes would result in a particularly unpleasant and oppressive sense of enclosure when looking from the side bedroom windows, due to factors such as the increased height, bulk and proximity. 7. It is acknowledged that the main bedroom has a dual aspect with another window in the rear elevation. I agree that an open view would remain directly to the rear. However, the infill extension at the back would bring development that extends significantly rearwards of this window appreciably closer. Together with factors such as the additional height of the enlarged dwelling and the bulk resulting from the gabled form this would give rise to an unacceptable sense of enclosure to the outlook from this window as well. The extent of the outlook over the top of the enlarged property would be insufficient to significantly mitigate this effect. 8. From the back garden and conservatory, I agree that the angle of view may limit the perceived increase in ridge height, as suggested in the annotated drawings. Nevertheless, the increase in eaves height, the appreciably greater proximity of the infill extension in this part and the gabled form would all contribute to an unacceptable increase in enclosure that would be experienced both in the garden and conservatory. This would occur despite the fairly large overall size of the garden at no. 36. 9. Due to these adverse effects, the overall impact of the development would be an unpleasant and oppressive feeling of being hemmed in, with an unacceptable increase in the sense of enclosure. This would be the case despite the chalet style design of the enlarged dwelling, which would be unacceptably dominant and appear overbearing. 10.The proposal would remove the existing terrace at the side of no. 38 which readily enables overlooking of the garden immediately to the rear of the neighbouring property and the conservatory. There would be a new terrace at the back. However, because of its fairly elevated position I saw at my site visit that overlooking would still be possible in relation to a part of the garden in fairly close proximity to the back of the adjacent dwelling by looking to the side. 11.In any event, the overbearing effect would arise in relation to a number of bedrooms, as well as the conservatory and garden. As a result, even if there was no overlooking at all from the new terrace, this matter would be insufficient to outweigh the harm in respect of the overbearing impact of the development. Appeal Decision APP/U2235/D/18/3213305 3 12.Any overlooking of the rear garden of no. 36 from the large first floor rear windows would be at a fairly oblique angle and significantly beyond the back of the adjacent dwelling. As a consequence, this would not result in any undue loss of privacy. 13.I considered the effect of the proposal from the dwelling at 17 Roseacre Lane during my site visit. This property would be sufficiently distant from the enlarged dwelling to prevent any adverse impact in respect of matters such as privacy, outlook and light. 14.Nevertheless, for the above reasons it is concluded that the living conditions of the adjacent occupiers at 36 Plantation Lane would be harmed. In consequence, there would be conflict with Maidstone Borough Local Plan 2017 (LP) Policies DM 1 and DM 9, which among other things, intend that development should respect the amenities of the occupiers of neighbouring properties and safeguard their outlook. 15.There would be conflict with the advice in the Council’s Residential Extensions, Supplementary Planning Document (SPD), 2009, that extensions should not cause significant harm to the amenity of adjoining occupiers. Paragraph 4.79 of the SPD states that “the Council is primarily concerned with the immediate outlook from neighbours’ windows, and if a proposal significantly changes the nature of the normal outlook. For example, it would be unacceptable for the resulting outlook from a main window to be of a large wall of a residential extension”. 16.It is clear that the latter is only an example and not indicative of all the instances where an undue reduction in outlook might occur, such as where a roof is involved rather than a wall. However, the fairly extensive vertical wall rising above the raised eaves level would be unduly prominent in the outlook from the side windows to the main and middle bedrooms, in itself unacceptably changing the nature of the normal outlook, contrary to the SPD anyway. The 45 degree test indicated in the SPD is used to assess the effect on light levels and not outlook which is a different matter. Character and appearance 17.The side dormer addition would reflect the presence of others in the vicinity, including pitched and flat roof types. The top would not rise above the ridge of the property, with a fairly large expanse of roof to either side. Together with the hipped roof form this would result in it being proportionate to the roof slope and not being excessive in scale or unduly bulky. Despite having no windows in their faces, there is no significant pattern of openings that would be unacceptably disrupted by this. 18.The design and scale of the enlarged roof, as well as the facing materials of the extended and altered dwelling, would be compatible with the variety found in the street. Because of the fairly varied context the blind dormers would not be at odds with any significant consistency or regularity. Moreover, rather than being an unattractive and bland feature, they would provide visual interest and articulation, while relieving the otherwise fairly extensive area of roof. 19.The scheme would significantly change the appearance of the host dwelling from a bungalow to a chalet style dwelling. However, the resultant appearance, including the blind dormers, would be appropriate and compatible with the Appeal Decision APP/U2235/D/18/3213305 4 surroundings. As a consequence, there would be no harm to the character and appearance of the locality. 20.Together and amongst other things, LP policies DM 1 and DM 9 seek to ensure that new development achieves a high quality of design and responds positively to local character. The scale, height, form and appearance of residential extensions should fit unobtrusively with the character of the streetscene and context. I conclude that the proposal would comply with these development plan policies. 21.It is acknowledged in the SPD that innovative design can be acceptable. Although the proposal would break the eaves line and not relate to existing windows, given the absence of harm that I have found, I consider that the SPD should not be strictly applied in these respects. Other considerations 22.The design and access statement provided with the application refers to the possibility of extensions being built using permitted development rights. However, no drawings of any particular scheme have been provided that would enable any meaningful comparison with the current proposal. Moreover, there is no clear indication that any specific development would be implemented in the event of the appeal failing. This matter is not therefore a significant consideration in this appeal. 23.The National Planning Policy Framework states that decisions should ensure that developments create places that promote health and well-being, with a high standard of amenity for existing and future users. The proposed development would be inconsistent with this objective. In this case the improved accommodation at the host dwelling would be achieved at the undue expense of the quality of the residential environment of the adjacent occupiers at no. 36. Conclusion 24.Taking account of all other matters raised, I conclude that despite the acceptability in relation to character and appearance, because of the harmful effect on the living conditions of the adjacent occupiers the appeal fails. M Evans INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →