Erection of part single and 2 storey rear extension to form additional living accommodation, following demolition of existing conservatory
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 January 2019
by Gareth Wildgoose BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 January 2019
Appeal Ref: APP/B4215/D/18/3211191
24 Larch Gardens, Manchester M8 8BJ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Mohamed Abunowar against the decision of Manchester City
Council.
The application Ref 120074/FH/2018, dated 19 May 2018, was refused by notice dated
16 July 2018.
The development proposed is ‘erection of part single and 2 storey rear extension to
form additional living accommodation, following demolition of existing conservatory’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The description of development provided by the application form has been
updated in subsequent documents to reflect revisions made to the original
proposal before the Council made its decision. I adopt the description of
development provided by the appeal form accordingly as it reflects the proposal
within the submitted plans upon which the Council made its decision.
Main Issues
3. The main issues of the appeal are:
The effect on the living conditions of occupiers of neighbouring properties,
with particular regard to Nos. 22 and 26 Larch Gardens and matters of
outlook, and;
The effect on the character and appearance of the host property and the
area.
Reasons
Living conditions – neighbouring properties
4. The appeal site consists of a two storey detached dwelling with an existing rear
conservatory that is located in a residential area with a mix of property types.
To the eastern side, is a terraced row of three properties that have front
building lines which are much closer to the road. As a consequence, the appeal
property (No 24) already has a rear projection that is significantly beyond the
rear building line of the neighbouring No 22 Larch Gardens (No 22). No 26
Larch Gardens (No 26) is a detached dwelling located on the other side of
No 24 with a rear projection beyond the rear building line of the appeal
Appeal Decision APP/B4215/D/18/3211191
2
property that is of a more limited depth. Nos. 22 and 26 had not been
extended to the rear at the time of my visit.
5. The proposal seeks to demolish the existing rear conservatory that lies closest
to the side boundary with No 26. It would be replaced by a part single and
part two storey extension located closest to the shared side boundary with
No 22 and a two storey extension toward the shared boundary with No 26.
Based upon the evidence before me, the depth of the rear extensions would be
less than 3.65m. The proposal, therefore, would not exceed the threshold in
Saved Policy DC1.3 of the Unitary Development Plan for the City of Manchester
(UDP), adopted July 1995, beyond which the Council will not normally approve
rear extensions of greater depth. Nonetheless, such matters do not override
the broader assessment required by Saved Policy DC1.1 in terms of the effect
upon the amenity of neighbouring properties which reasonably requires
consideration of the particular relationships with Nos. 22 and 26.
6. With regard to the above, due to the differences in the rear building lines of
Nos. 22 and 24, the proposal would increase the cumulative depth of two
storey built form beyond the rear building line of No 22 to around 5.5m with a
further 1.5m at single storey level. The hipped roof design reduces the height
of the roof of the two storey extension closest to the boundary. However, the
considerable depth, scale, bulk and massing of built form would be around 1m
from the shared side boundary with the rear garden of No 22 and would be a
dominant feature above the boundary fence. Consequently, the proposal would
result in an unacceptable overbearing effect and sense of enclosure upon the
habitable room windows in the rear elevation of No 22 and its rear garden.
The northern aspect of the rear elevations of the properties would prevent a
significant overshadowing effect or loss of light to No 22 and its rear garden.
Nonetheless, the overbearing effect upon No 22 and the associated loss of
outlook would significantly harm the living conditions of its occupiers.
7. The set back of the rear building line of No 26 relative to No 24 and the side
separation between the properties would ensure that a two storey rear
extension of approximately 3.5m depth would not have an unacceptable
overbearing effect, sense of enclosure or loss of outlook for the windows in the
rear elevation of No 26 and its rear garden. The absence of proposed windows
in the side elevations of the extension would also prevent any concerns in
terms of overlooking and privacy for occupiers of Nos. 22 and 26. However,
the absence of concern in those respects does not override the harm identified
with respect to the relationship with No 22 and the associated loss of outlook
from that property and its rear garden.
8. In reaching the above findings, I have taken account of No 18 Larch Gardens,
which has a recent part two storey and part single storey rear extension, and
its proximity to a taller block of flats in a set back position that adjoins the
entire side boundary of its rear garden. However, I observed that the
relationship of those properties is very much in the minority and I am not
aware of the full circumstances which led to the overbearing effect of the block
of flats upon No 18 and its rear garden. In any event, it is not the type of
development and relationship between properties that should be used as a
reason to allow a development which would significantly harm the existing
living conditions of occupiers of No 22. Furthermore, as the main rear building
lines of Nos. 18 - 22 are consistent, the rear extension at No 18 does not
replicate the circumstances of the proposal or its harmful effect upon No 22.
Appeal Decision APP/B4215/D/18/3211191
3
9. I conclude that the development would significantly harm the living conditions
of occupiers of No 22 Larch Gardens. The proposal would, therefore, conflict
with Saved Policy DC1 of the UDP and Policies SP1 and DM1 of Manchester’s
Local Development Framework Core Strategy (CS), adopted July 2012. The
policies, when taken together, require regard to the effect of the development
upon, amongst other things, matters of amenity and its impact on the
surrounding area. The policies are consistent with the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) in so far as it seeks a high standard of amenity for
existing and future users of developments.
Character and appearance
10. As previously mentioned, there is some variation in property styles and rear
building lines nearby, including the part single and part two storey rear
extension visible nearby at No 18, a terraced property. However, the rear
extension at No 18 is screened from the Larch Gardens street scene by the
intervening presence of the taller block of flats. The appeal proposal is
different in so far as it consists of a part single and part two storey rear
extension to a detached property in a position that is set back further than the
rear building line of No 18, with a more substantial width and multiple hipped
roof elements.
11. The design of the proposal seeks to ensure subservience and coherence with
the host dwelling through a consistency of eaves height of the two storey
elements with the original roof, together with a reduced ridge height of the roof
of a two storey outrigger element and the configuration of a monopitch roof at
ground floor level below the first floor windows. Nonetheless, the varied height
of the two storey elements would result in a different profile of hipped roof
forms that would be viewed as overly complicated, disproportionate and
incompatible additions at the rear of the host dwelling.
12. The discordant nature of the rear additions would be particularly evident from
the side profile that would be visible from the east, including from neighbouring
properties, their rear gardens, the car parking area at the rear of the block of
flats and the more distant views available from Larch Gardens beyond. From
those perspectives, the incongruous side profile of the extension, taken
together with its cumulative scale, bulk and massing, would harm the character
and appearance of the host building and would appear out of place when
viewed against the backdrop of the rear elevations of the detached properties
further to the west. The use of matching materials, windows and doors would
not overcome the harm identified.
13. I conclude that the proposed development would significantly harm the
character and appearance of the host property and the area. The proposal
would, therefore, conflict with Saved Policy DC1 of the UDP and Policies SP1
and DM1 of the CS, together with the associated guidance within the Guide to
Development in Manchester Supplementary Planning Document and Planning
Guidance, adopted April 2007. When taken together, the policies seek to
ensure development is of a high quality design that has regard to the character
and appearance of the street scene and surrounding area, including appropriate
scale, form and massing that is not excessively large or bulky. The policies are
consistent with the design objectives of the Framework.
Appeal Decision APP/B4215/D/18/3211191
4
Other Matters
14. The development would provide additional living space within the property.
Furthermore, the appellant has indicated that moving to a larger house is not a
viable option. In that respect, I understand and sympathise with the wishes of
the appellant to provide additional living space for his growing family.
However, there is no detailed evidence that there would be an absence of
suitable and affordable alternative properties in the local area which limits the
weight I can give. Consequently, the personal circumstances put forward are
not sufficient to outweigh the harm identified.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons given above and taking all other matters into consideration, I
conclude that this appeal should be dismissed.
Gareth Wildgoose
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.