Two-storey side extension to the existing dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Parking Provision
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 September 2018
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 20 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/U3935/D/18/3207609
99 Beaulieu Close, Toothill, Swindon, SN5 8AJ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Ghuman against the decision of Swindon Borough Council.
The application Ref S/HOU/18/0425/PEKO, dated 9 March 2018, was refused by notice
dated 8 June 2018.
The development proposed is described as the erection of a two-storey side extension to
the existing dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are: - (i) the effect of the proposal on the character and
appearance of 99 Beaulieu Close and the wider area, and (ii) whether the
proposal would provide adequate private amenity and parking space.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is an end of terrace dwelling with a mono-pitched roof.
This appears in stark contrast to the remainder of the terrace, which has a
more traditional dual pitched roof and gable end, but which nevertheless
reflects an architectural style that is repeated for other buildings within this
wider residential estate.
4. I am aware of an appeal decision dated 18 September 2012 (Ref APP/U3935/A/
12/2171375). The development that was proposed at that time was described
as a ‘first floor side extension’. The appeal was dismissed, with the Inspector
concluding that the proposal would cause significant harm to the character and
appearance of the area by appearing as a dominant and unsympathetic
addition, and one that would unacceptably erode the gap that exists between
No 99 and the adjoining terrace at Nos 94-98 (consecutive). The Inspector
also found that there would be insufficient outdoor space to meet the everyday
needs of the occupants at the appeal site and that the space would be further
unacceptably eroded if parking were to be provided in accordance with the
Council’s parking standards.
Appeal Decision APP/U3935/D/18/3207609
2
5. The current arrangement at No 99 appears broadly similar to that described by
the previous Inspector insofar as 99 Beaulieu Close has been sub-divided into
two separate dwellings. The building has a single-storey, mono-pitched side
element and which projects towards Beaulieu Close, into the main outdoor
amenity space for the property. This, together with what is described as a side
conservatory and front storage shed is occupied as a small, independent
dwelling unit. The main part of the ground floor and the entire first floor is
occupied separately as a larger dwelling unit. The proposal is to effectively
extend the main dwelling over the existing ground floor footprint. The ground
floor ‘annex’ dwelling is shown on the plans to be remodelled internally, with
the conservatory relabelled as a second bedroom. The drawings and the
description of development, together with information on the application forms,
are ambiguous on this matter. Ordinarily, internal changes to a dwelling, as I
have described for the smaller dwelling, would not require planning permission.
I have therefore taken the proposal to be an extension to the larger dwelling
alone.
6. The current proposal differs from the previous appeal proposal in terms of its
size and appearance. The last appeal scheme proposed an increase of the
main dwelling from 4 to 6 bedrooms and generally followed the architectural
form of the existing dwelling in terms of its appearance. This appeal proposal
is to extend the dwelling further still to 7 bedrooms, with its external
appearance seeking to mimic the more traditional dual pitched form of the
adjacent terrace.
Character and Appearance
7. During my visit, I saw for myself the space at first floor level between the
appeal property and 98 Beaulieu Close. I agree with the previous Inspector’s
findings that the gap is important because it breaks up the two rows of
terraced dwellings into smaller block sizes that are replicated around the
remainder of Beaulieu Close and which are characteristic of the wider area.
Such features are also addressed within the Council’s Residential Extensions &
Alterations Supplementary Planning Document (SPD), adopted in 2011, where
it is recognised that, even in areas of relatively high-density development, a
sense of openness can prevail due the spaces between buildings along a
frontage.
8. As with the previous scheme, the proposal would extend across the full width of
the plot up to the side boundary and flank wall of No 98. It would virtually
double the width of the existing 2-storey dwelling and effectively link the two
terraced blocks. This would erode the existing separation and create one long
terrace that would be out of keeping with the spacing and character of the
development pattern for the area, contrary to the guiding principles within the
SPD.
9. I recognise the appellant’s efforts to attempt to match the style of the
adjoining terrace, but as was previously the case, there would remain to be a
complex arrangement of building lines and roof forms. According to the
drawing that depicts the ‘proposed front/side elevation’, there appears to be a
2-storey flat roof element to the front of the property facing Beaulieu Close.
With no roof plan, it is not easy to decipher the precise arrangement of this, or
Appeal Decision APP/U3935/D/18/3207609
3
the works more generally, either in terms of their relationship with the existing
dwelling, or with No 98.
10. My impression overall is that the extension would dominate the simple form of
the original dwelling by reason of its size, staggered forward projections, and
seemingly complex roof profile. It would also erode the spatial characteristics
of the area. Consequently, there would be serious harm to the character and
appearance of No 99 and the street scene. As such, the proposal would fail to
demonstrate the quality of design that is required by Policy DE1 of the Swindon
Borough Council Local Plan 2026 (LP), adopted in 2015, in order to ensure
adequate respect for the context and character of the area, and LP Policy HA1
which equally requires housing development to respect the character of the
surrounding area. In this regard the proposal would fail to achieve a
sustainable form of development that is required by the National Planning
Policy Framework.
Parking Provision and Amenity Space
11. The SPD provides minimum external space standards for homes and private
gardens to ensure developments are built to a high standard. It advises that
extensions and alterations to existing dwellings should aim to adhere to the
standards to ensure the size and design of external spaces meet the needs of
current and future occupiers. For 1 and 2 bed houses a private garden space
of 30sqm is required, and for dwellings of 4 or more bedrooms, 50sqm is
required.
12. The appellant has stated that around 44sqm amenity space is available. This
space, the majority of which lies between the existing building and Beaulieu
Close, appears to be shared communally by both existing dwellings and used
informally, including for off-street parking. The current level of provision
already falls below the size that would normally be expected even for the
existing principal dwelling. With a significant increase in occupancy most likely
as a result of the proposal, there would be additional use of an already
substandard space. This would be compounded by the shared use of the
garden such that overall, I find that there would be insufficient outdoor space
to meet the reasonable needs of the occupants. This would result in harm to
the living conditions of existing and future occupiers. This would be further
contrary to LP Policy DE1 regarding amenity considerations and space, as
correctly referenced within the officer’s report, rather than Policy DS6 of the
former Swindon Borough Local Plan 2011 (2006), which is misquoted within the
second reason for refusal on the decision notice.
13. The Council’s ‘Technical Guidance on Parking Standards’ would require a total
of 5 parking spaces to be provided for the 2 dwellings to ensure that adequate
and satisfactory parking provision is available. The existing parking
arrangement is ad-hoc but the application form states that 1 space exists and
that 4 spaces would be provided. An illustrative depiction of this arrangement
is given within the appellant’s appeal submission.
14. However, as was the case with the last appeal, the provision of any additional
parking would erode the already limited amenity space. This adds to my
concern and demonstrates that adequate private amenity space and parking
could not both be provided.
Appeal Decision APP/U3935/D/18/3207609
4
Other Matters
15. The appellant has suggested that the appeal proposal is similar to extensions to
other properties in the area. However, I saw none close by and within the
specific character area for the appeal site that were in any way comparable in
size, scale, form or context to the appeal proposal. I have noted the list of
examples given where planning permission has been given for 2-storey or first
floor side extensions to other properties within the wider area. However, I
have no further details of these and no evidence that the circumstances in each
case are similar. These other cases do not alter my findings in relation to the
first main issue.
16. I have noted the appellant’s criticism of the Council’s handling of the planning
application, including an alleged lack of communication and inconsistency.
However, there is no substantive evidence to support this. In any event, I
have considered the appeal based on the merits of the case.
Conclusions
17. For the reasons given, I find that the proposal would harm the character and
appearance of 99 Beaulieu Close and the wider area. It would also harm the
living conditions of future occupiers in terms of inadequate private amenity
space, which would be further compromised if adequate and satisfactory
parking provision were to be made available. I appreciate that the appellant
has worked to attempt to overcome previous reasons for refusing alternative
schemes and that there were no objections from any interested parties. I also
acknowledge that the proposal would provide the appellant with additional
living space. However, none of these factors alter my conclusion that the
appeal should be dismissed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.